Night 3 results: Maribro, Chocolate Townie, has been killed!
Day 4 begins! With five alive, it takes three to lynch.
02/03/2016 12:21:43
I am a man of my word.
Vote: Corvid
02/03/2016 11:53:45
Vote: Corvid
02/03/2016 11:53:45
*From beyond the grave* I could of saved you maribro on the night cycle, because my ability would of happened even if I was killed at night. GG all, sorry if I was abit mad and frustrated im not normally like that xD I just got really into this, goodluck!
02/03/2016 11:56:51
02/03/2016 11:56:51
Just as an aside, since I should have posted this earlier:
Mafia is about making people uncomfortable and pressuring them out, so you can call out their bullshit. As a result if this things can get quite heated. There are certain limits on what you can do and say (e.g. race/religion/gender shit is defs out of bounds) but you'd need a bit of a thick skin in order to play, so when someone is making you feel uncomfortable don't take it personally as we're doing our part to play the game.
all i'm saying is ggs Barry And someone lynch this kid Corvid so we can win already
02/03/2016 12:02:26
Mafia is about making people uncomfortable and pressuring them out, so you can call out their bullshit. As a result if this things can get quite heated. There are certain limits on what you can do and say (e.g. race/religion/gender shit is defs out of bounds) but you'd need a bit of a thick skin in order to play, so when someone is making you feel uncomfortable don't take it personally as we're doing our part to play the game.
all i'm saying is ggs Barry And someone lynch this kid Corvid so we can win already
02/03/2016 12:02:26
JLo said:And someone lynch this kid Corvid so we can win already
Whoa whoa whoa, let's not get too hasty here. Give me a few minutes, I have a wall of text to write.
02/03/2016 12:06:45
dean said:
Night 3 results: Maribro, Vanilla Townie, has been killed!
Day 4 begins! With five alive, it takes three to lynch.
I was a chocolate townie Dean, I thought we agreed to this. I hate vanilla flavour
02/03/2016 12:13:04
haha rip Maribro 26th Jan - 3rd of Feb 2016
02/03/2016 12:17:42
02/03/2016 12:17:42
Bloody ghosts. I'll change it Maribro so stop haunting me.
02/03/2016 12:21:11
02/03/2016 12:21:11
Oh wow that was quick. I'll be voting for corvid unless invisi's wall of text says something that changes my mind. Don't add it to the voting thing yet though, I want to see what invisi says first.
02/03/2016 12:22:42
02/03/2016 12:22:42
Trigger warning: Contains roleplay
So, everything I said yesterday (as in, game yesterday, so the last couple hours in real life) was based on the assumption that Barry was mafia. This assumption was based on my initial suspicion that cAKE and Barry were working together. Once cAKE was revealed to be the mafia godfather, I had assumed that it confirmed my suspicion and that therefore Barry was a mafia goon.
As it turned out, Barry's final plea of innocence was founded in truth, as he was in fact the townie doctor. I think we should all take a moment to say a prayer for Barry, giving him the respect he deserves in death that he unfortunately was not given in life.
Barry did an essential service to our town. The night before he was killed, he saved my life, and I owe him my gratitude.
His service also gave us one final shot at eliminating the mafia. Of the five of us who remain, it is very likely that two are in the mafia, leaving three of us as innocent townsfolk. Had I been killed two nights ago, the two remaining townsfolk would not have had the strength to band together and overthrow the mafia, and we would've been doomed. As such, I thank Barry for his service to this town, and he will be forever remembered as a hero.
In death, Barry provided assurance to all of you that I am indeed a townsperson. In his role as the town doctor, he managed to save my life on a night where the mafia did not manage to kill anyone, thus confirming my innocence as a townsperson beyond doubt. The mafia made a crucial error of judgement last night, in coming after Maribro instead of myself. While I was fairly confident Maribro was a townsperson, there was no way of being absolutely certain. But, thanks to Barry, you can all be absolutely certain that I am a townsperson.
With this in mind, I am certain that the mafia will come after me tonight. It is in our best interests to work together as a town in order to identify both members of the mafia today. This is our last shot everyone. If we screw it up, the mafia will kill us all.
Unfortunately, I am but a mere vanilla townie, so I have no information to identify the remaining mafia members. I have reason to believe all of you, and I have reason to be suspicious of all of you. PS. For all I know, there could be only one mafia left, which makes our job a lot easier. It's safest to assume two and try to work it out from there.
02/03/2016 12:36:17
So, everything I said yesterday (as in, game yesterday, so the last couple hours in real life) was based on the assumption that Barry was mafia. This assumption was based on my initial suspicion that cAKE and Barry were working together. Once cAKE was revealed to be the mafia godfather, I had assumed that it confirmed my suspicion and that therefore Barry was a mafia goon.
As it turned out, Barry's final plea of innocence was founded in truth, as he was in fact the townie doctor. I think we should all take a moment to say a prayer for Barry, giving him the respect he deserves in death that he unfortunately was not given in life.
Barry did an essential service to our town. The night before he was killed, he saved my life, and I owe him my gratitude.
His service also gave us one final shot at eliminating the mafia. Of the five of us who remain, it is very likely that two are in the mafia, leaving three of us as innocent townsfolk. Had I been killed two nights ago, the two remaining townsfolk would not have had the strength to band together and overthrow the mafia, and we would've been doomed. As such, I thank Barry for his service to this town, and he will be forever remembered as a hero.
In death, Barry provided assurance to all of you that I am indeed a townsperson. In his role as the town doctor, he managed to save my life on a night where the mafia did not manage to kill anyone, thus confirming my innocence as a townsperson beyond doubt. The mafia made a crucial error of judgement last night, in coming after Maribro instead of myself. While I was fairly confident Maribro was a townsperson, there was no way of being absolutely certain. But, thanks to Barry, you can all be absolutely certain that I am a townsperson.
With this in mind, I am certain that the mafia will come after me tonight. It is in our best interests to work together as a town in order to identify both members of the mafia today. This is our last shot everyone. If we screw it up, the mafia will kill us all.
Unfortunately, I am but a mere vanilla townie, so I have no information to identify the remaining mafia members. I have reason to believe all of you, and I have reason to be suspicious of all of you. PS. For all I know, there could be only one mafia left, which makes our job a lot easier. It's safest to assume two and try to work it out from there.
02/03/2016 12:36:17
Okay for now I'll go with your reasoning Invisi. So there are five people left:
- JLo
- Invisi
- Windkeeper0
- Corvid
- Deez
And we're assuming what there are two mafia goons left. As of now, Corvid is the most suspected player and he's two votes away from getting lynched. So let's assume that the vote does go through and he gets lynched, what would the mafia's play be on the following night?
Invisi stated that he's the most likely target for mafia tonight, and I believe that to be true as well. With him out of the picture, the town's most vocal and productive member at this moment will be gone, and that will severely weaken our town.
So out of the three left:
- JLo
- Windkeeper0
- Deez
Who is the most likely to be mafia?
I know for a fact that I am a Vanilla Townie, so it's either Windkeeper0 or Deez who is town. Notice how fast the past night phase went and Deez's last post was 18 hours ago, so unless he is lurking quietly I don't believe he was here to make the kill during the night. This leaves us with Windkeeper0 as the suspected second mafia. But this couldn't be possible, since Windkeeper0 voted for both cAKE and Barry, so unless he made some risky next level metagame play to throw his fellow mafia under the bus, I don't think he is the mafia as well.
But let's look at another scenario: what if Invisi doesn't get killed tonight? This would be highly unlikely... unless he's the mafia. But all this time he has displayed pro-town behaviour so it's hard for me to pin him as mafia. Which leaves us with... Deez. But we already established that he couldn't have made the kill last night
... so idk all this assuming shit is going nowhere, I'd defs lynch Corvid tho
02/03/2016 13:25:47
- JLo
- Invisi
- Windkeeper0
- Corvid
- Deez
And we're assuming what there are two mafia goons left. As of now, Corvid is the most suspected player and he's two votes away from getting lynched. So let's assume that the vote does go through and he gets lynched, what would the mafia's play be on the following night?
Invisi stated that he's the most likely target for mafia tonight, and I believe that to be true as well. With him out of the picture, the town's most vocal and productive member at this moment will be gone, and that will severely weaken our town.
So out of the three left:
- JLo
- Windkeeper0
- Deez
Who is the most likely to be mafia?
I know for a fact that I am a Vanilla Townie, so it's either Windkeeper0 or Deez who is town. Notice how fast the past night phase went and Deez's last post was 18 hours ago, so unless he is lurking quietly I don't believe he was here to make the kill during the night. This leaves us with Windkeeper0 as the suspected second mafia. But this couldn't be possible, since Windkeeper0 voted for both cAKE and Barry, so unless he made some risky next level metagame play to throw his fellow mafia under the bus, I don't think he is the mafia as well.
But let's look at another scenario: what if Invisi doesn't get killed tonight? This would be highly unlikely... unless he's the mafia. But all this time he has displayed pro-town behaviour so it's hard for me to pin him as mafia. Which leaves us with... Deez. But we already established that he couldn't have made the kill last night
... so idk all this assuming shit is going nowhere, I'd defs lynch Corvid tho
02/03/2016 13:25:47
Alright, reading through the thread again I've gathered my evidence. This one's going to be tough boys:
Deez: Most likely town. Unfortunately he hasn't really contributed too much, so it's kinda hard to know, but the fact that we got through two night phases today without him here means he's unlikely to be mafia. That said, maybe Dean allowed a 1/2 majority in his absence, or maybe Deez is even super mindgaming us and has actually just been lurking all day.
JLo: Very quick to accuse. Immediately turned on Corvid without super hard evidence in a phase where we need to take this slow. He was also the first on the cAKE wagon, well before the rest of the band, and didn't get off at any point. I seriously doubt that a mafia member would oust another in such a fashion, but I won't rule it out.
Windkeeper: A man of few words. Had several opportunities to finish cAKE off when he was at four votes, but instead chose to wait for more evidence. Once the evidence mounted against him, he turned with a swift strike. While this behaviour is not necessarily indicative of mafia, it definitely doesn't rule out him trying to throw cAKE under the bus in a quite manner without drawing attention to himself (a well executed play I must say, if this is indeed what happened). That said, I'd say it looks more mafia that JLo's starting the engine on the cAKE bandwagon.
Corvid: On the Maribro case the whole time, which definitely makes him more suspicious than those who were trying to vote off cAKE. That said, Barry was on cAKE's side, so it obviously doesn't confirm anything. Probably the most suspicious player at the moment, but I'm not totally convinced that he's mafia, especially with JLo and Windkeeper ganging up on him at the moment.
02/03/2016 13:35:38
Deez: Most likely town. Unfortunately he hasn't really contributed too much, so it's kinda hard to know, but the fact that we got through two night phases today without him here means he's unlikely to be mafia. That said, maybe Dean allowed a 1/2 majority in his absence, or maybe Deez is even super mindgaming us and has actually just been lurking all day.
JLo: Very quick to accuse. Immediately turned on Corvid without super hard evidence in a phase where we need to take this slow. He was also the first on the cAKE wagon, well before the rest of the band, and didn't get off at any point. I seriously doubt that a mafia member would oust another in such a fashion, but I won't rule it out.
Windkeeper: A man of few words. Had several opportunities to finish cAKE off when he was at four votes, but instead chose to wait for more evidence. Once the evidence mounted against him, he turned with a swift strike. While this behaviour is not necessarily indicative of mafia, it definitely doesn't rule out him trying to throw cAKE under the bus in a quite manner without drawing attention to himself (a well executed play I must say, if this is indeed what happened). That said, I'd say it looks more mafia that JLo's starting the engine on the cAKE bandwagon.
Corvid: On the Maribro case the whole time, which definitely makes him more suspicious than those who were trying to vote off cAKE. That said, Barry was on cAKE's side, so it obviously doesn't confirm anything. Probably the most suspicious player at the moment, but I'm not totally convinced that he's mafia, especially with JLo and Windkeeper ganging up on him at the moment.
02/03/2016 13:35:38
Did the thread die
02/04/2016 10:07:53
02/04/2016 10:07:53
Why, did you run into it in death land?
I think Bayonetta and Corrin may have had something to do with it.
02/04/2016 10:28:52
I think Bayonetta and Corrin may have had something to do with it.
02/04/2016 10:28:52
Yeah quiet day. It was a big day in Smash though so I suppose it's OK.
With five players alive, it takes three to lynch!
Votes:
JLo (0)
Corvid (1) - JLo
Deez (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (4) - Corvid, Deez, Windkeeper0, Invisi
02/04/2016 12:25:14
With five players alive, it takes three to lynch!
Votes:
JLo (0)
Corvid (1) - JLo
Deez (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (4) - Corvid, Deez, Windkeeper0, Invisi
02/04/2016 12:25:14
So guys, I have to say that I haven't been lurking but have just spent more time in my house doing homework, so I haven't been out the door of my house to to participate in Town talk sadly, so I do cramped to try and chat in this thread but the moment I do, I try and help out the thread. Now, I know for a fact I'm a Townie and have always hinted to this in my discussions,
From all this discussion, something leads me to believe that Jlo is not a townie but is lying to us secretly, I don't know but it's just a thought.
Corvid: just because he was on maribros case
Invisi: I feel like he is fine.
Windkeeper: he has been too quite in my opinion. Could be wrong though
02/04/2016 23:05:59
From all this discussion, something leads me to believe that Jlo is not a townie but is lying to us secretly, I don't know but it's just a thought.
Corvid: just because he was on maribros case
Invisi: I feel like he is fine.
Windkeeper: he has been too quite in my opinion. Could be wrong though
02/04/2016 23:05:59
Nice to see you come out of the woodwork Deez.
Out of the five people left, Invisi has been established as a townie due to Barry's save which clears him of suspicion. I also believe that Deez has a high chance of being town (~85%) due to how fast the previous night cycle went and his activity before the night phase, which I established in my previous post. This leaves us with three people including myself:
- JLo
- Corvid
- Windkeeper
If we keep going with the assumption that there are two mafia left, it is crucial that we lynch a mafia this day phase, or else town loses. This is why I'm vehemently advocating for Corvid to be lynched, since it's the safest play we have at the moment and we can't afford to screw up today.
Corvid has been incredibly inactive (way less than Deez), just lurking and saying things like:
After the first night. This is an incredibly detached statement, the first tell that I picked up on that started making me suspicious of him.
He voted for Maribro for the second time in the game. Note that Maribro was the first one to vote for cAKE in the second day, contrary to his claim of bandwagoning. This smells like a subtle attempt to throw off suspicion from his fellow mafia by voting for his accuser.
There's also this gem of a comment which tries to accuse townies (me and Deez) just because we got the kill on cAKE.
Incredibly detached statement. Refer to point 1 on tells.
I am 75% sure he's mafia and should be the one on the chopping block today. The question is what do we do on the next day phase. Since Invisi is a prime target, if we assume that he will die tonight the leaves us with me, Deez and Windkeeper0 to identify the last mafia. As I've already established, Deez is most likely a townie so if it comes to this scenario, it's my word against Windkeeper0.
I have a few more points to write but i'll do it once I get home. Spoiler alert: I'm not mafia.
02/05/2016 02:31:39
Out of the five people left, Invisi has been established as a townie due to Barry's save which clears him of suspicion. I also believe that Deez has a high chance of being town (~85%) due to how fast the previous night cycle went and his activity before the night phase, which I established in my previous post. This leaves us with three people including myself:
- JLo
- Corvid
- Windkeeper
If we keep going with the assumption that there are two mafia left, it is crucial that we lynch a mafia this day phase, or else town loses. This is why I'm vehemently advocating for Corvid to be lynched, since it's the safest play we have at the moment and we can't afford to screw up today.
Corvid has been incredibly inactive (way less than Deez), just lurking and saying things like:
Corvid said:
Well shit, a cop dead, we need to find some clues to pin someone as scum..
After the first night. This is an incredibly detached statement, the first tell that I picked up on that started making me suspicious of him.
Corvid said:
I've been pondering on this for a while, though the amount of information we have at the moment is rather small we still have some leads, though in hindsight i believe Maribro's vote in particular was rather shifty with a few others just bandwagoning that rather small evidence. I'm sure that Maribro of all people is mafia right now.
VOTE: Maribro
He voted for Maribro for the second time in the game. Note that Maribro was the first one to vote for cAKE in the second day, contrary to his claim of bandwagoning. This smells like a subtle attempt to throw off suspicion from his fellow mafia by voting for his accuser.
Corvid said:
I still dont see how voting cAKE off makes you immediately town, there was a great lot of bandwagoning over day 2, and then really a small suspicion gave us the opening of killing the godfather. Bandwagoning like that, in particular from Invisi was suspicious, though if Barry is telling the truth Invisi would be town. and perhaps seeing that cAKE was going to be lynched perhaps the goon voted against him in a sick strategy, In this case it doesnt avoid the possibility for JLo or Deez in some way. I honestly dont think this game is completely settled yet.
Becides Barry there is still the possibility of the Mafia deciding not to kill someone overnight,however strange that may be, how can we trust you?
There's also this gem of a comment which tries to accuse townies (me and Deez) just because we got the kill on cAKE.
Corvid said:
Vote: Barry
Cya, and i guess everyone is onto me now that ur gone, Mafia, you were gone today anyway yet this defends me of nothing...
Incredibly detached statement. Refer to point 1 on tells.
I am 75% sure he's mafia and should be the one on the chopping block today. The question is what do we do on the next day phase. Since Invisi is a prime target, if we assume that he will die tonight the leaves us with me, Deez and Windkeeper0 to identify the last mafia. As I've already established, Deez is most likely a townie so if it comes to this scenario, it's my word against Windkeeper0.
I have a few more points to write but i'll do it once I get home. Spoiler alert: I'm not mafia.
02/05/2016 02:31:39
No posts from Windkeeper0 and Corvid in 48+ hours, pls be a bit more active.
02/05/2016 11:59:50
02/05/2016 11:59:50
FYI there are Smash tournaments both days this weekend, so I'm not going to get a chance to look at this thread again until Monday.
02/05/2016 13:00:04
02/05/2016 13:00:04
Sorry I wasn't on the last 2 days I was busy yesterday and the day before I was busy until around 9 and was playing smash after that.
I am a vanilla townie but at this point in the game just saying that is pretty pointless seeing as everyone will claim that. Corvid is the only person I see with solid evidence against him so I won't be surprised if there is only one mafia left however I agree that it is probably for the best for now that we decide who to kill next round now.
Invisi: If Invisi turns out to be mafia he deserves to win by how unsuspicious he has been. I agree that he is town. I won't bother with my Sherlock level explanation of the possibility that he could still be mafia since I feel like that's just me overthinking.
Deez: Though he did seem a bit anti town in day 1 it's pretty safe to assume he is town at this point even counting out the fact that he wasn't active in chat he voted for cAKE when cAKE was already at 3 votes.
Corvid: There is a possibility that he is just shy or something but he is my main suspect.
1. How little he has said has struck me as suspicious.
2. His second post is something I have seen several time when playing mafia. He was almost completely silent said something against the mafia then went back to being silent until the next vote. From my experience about 80% of the time that this scenario happens they end up being mafia.
3. I found it kind of odd how he never told us how much experience he has had with the game when everyone else was also stating their experience closing himself off from the rest of the group. Though I do admit this argument is a bit weaker, it would have been a perfect chance to slip in with the town but instead he decided not to and made his silence even more know.
4. He only started posting things that could be seen as attached to the group when he was being accused of being mafia.
5. He has only voted against town members.
6. In the night that invis was healed Invisi would be the logical person to kill for Corvid as he had been on Maribro's case for so long. It would look even more suspicious if he killed Maribro at this point so he went for invisi the second most trusted person.
Jlo: He has been really hasty to vote on people being one of the first to bandwagon on cAKE when there was no evidence shown. Voting away from cAKE would only make him suspicious when cAKE was actually taken down but it doesn't completely prove anything either.
To be completely honest I don't feel like we have enough information to kill anyone off yet apart from Corvid so I'm not voting on him yet to make sure we continue the discussion.
02/06/2016 04:13:39
I am a vanilla townie but at this point in the game just saying that is pretty pointless seeing as everyone will claim that. Corvid is the only person I see with solid evidence against him so I won't be surprised if there is only one mafia left however I agree that it is probably for the best for now that we decide who to kill next round now.
Invisi: If Invisi turns out to be mafia he deserves to win by how unsuspicious he has been. I agree that he is town. I won't bother with my Sherlock level explanation of the possibility that he could still be mafia since I feel like that's just me overthinking.
Deez: Though he did seem a bit anti town in day 1 it's pretty safe to assume he is town at this point even counting out the fact that he wasn't active in chat he voted for cAKE when cAKE was already at 3 votes.
Corvid: There is a possibility that he is just shy or something but he is my main suspect.
1. How little he has said has struck me as suspicious.
2. His second post is something I have seen several time when playing mafia. He was almost completely silent said something against the mafia then went back to being silent until the next vote. From my experience about 80% of the time that this scenario happens they end up being mafia.
3. I found it kind of odd how he never told us how much experience he has had with the game when everyone else was also stating their experience closing himself off from the rest of the group. Though I do admit this argument is a bit weaker, it would have been a perfect chance to slip in with the town but instead he decided not to and made his silence even more know.
4. He only started posting things that could be seen as attached to the group when he was being accused of being mafia.
5. He has only voted against town members.
6. In the night that invis was healed Invisi would be the logical person to kill for Corvid as he had been on Maribro's case for so long. It would look even more suspicious if he killed Maribro at this point so he went for invisi the second most trusted person.
Jlo: He has been really hasty to vote on people being one of the first to bandwagon on cAKE when there was no evidence shown. Voting away from cAKE would only make him suspicious when cAKE was actually taken down but it doesn't completely prove anything either.
To be completely honest I don't feel like we have enough information to kill anyone off yet apart from Corvid so I'm not voting on him yet to make sure we continue the discussion.
02/06/2016 04:13:39
Corvid has received a second strike for inactivity.
02/07/2016 11:35:56
02/07/2016 11:35:56
"From beyond the grave"
My sacrifice was hopefully not in vain.
02/07/2016 12:41:03
My sacrifice was hopefully not in vain.
02/07/2016 12:41:03
What sacrifice it provided no evidence for them
02/07/2016 13:06:00
02/07/2016 13:06:00
Can dead players stop posting please... final warning.
02/07/2016 14:18:21
02/07/2016 14:18:21
Vote Windkeeper
02/08/2016 01:05:41
02/08/2016 01:05:41