Okay so back at the start of day 2, I wanted to get discussion rolling by voting for cAKE. Having lost the town cop it is pivotal we are smart about who we are voting for and I was entirely satisfied by my somewhat erroneous vote's outcome. Through it I have learnt some things. For all this to make sense, you must believe that I am a townsolk. Given that killing a villager today is paramount to losing the game (assuming there are 3 mafia, this hasn't been confirmed or denied and I honestly have no idea if there are or not).
1) JLo is a townie. When 4 people had voted for me, JLo had a clear opportunity to kill me off, and possibly win the game for the mafia (if he was one). His voting stance did not change and as such I have to assume he is pro town.
2) Windkeeper0 is probably a townie as well. Also having the ability to vote me to death when given the chance and being unsure of the number of mafia (a number that would only be known to them as Dean has said nothing on the matter thus far)
3) Invisi is a townie. If Invisi was mafia, he wouldn't care what I'm posting about now. His behaviour has been largely pro town and I don't think he's mafia.
This leaves us with Barrydabusdriver, Deez, cAKE and Corvid as the potential mafia people. If there are 3 people who are mafia then the trio is definitely Barry, cAKE and Corvid, as Deez isn't stupid and wouldn't vote for one of his own to be lynched. If there are 2 mafia the possible pairings are as follows
Barry + cAKE
Deez + Corvid
Deez + Barry
Barry + Corvid
Corvid + cAKE
I'm not especially confident on which of these scenarios is the correct one but these are the possible mafia team alignments.
I'd like to change my vote for now
Vote: Undecided
02/02/2016 11:54:59
With eight players alive, it takes five to lynch!
Votes:
JLo (0)
Maribro (3) - Barrydabusdriver, cAKE, Corvid
Corvid (0)
Deez (0)
cAKE (2) - JLo, Deez
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (3) - Windkeeper0, Invisi, Maribro
More changes than little macs gimp counter
02/02/2016 12:09:28
Votes:
JLo (0)
Maribro (3) - Barrydabusdriver, cAKE, Corvid
Corvid (0)
Deez (0)
cAKE (2) - JLo, Deez
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (3) - Windkeeper0, Invisi, Maribro
More changes than little macs gimp counter
02/02/2016 12:09:28
Maribro said:
Okay so back at the start of day 2, I wanted to get discussion rolling by voting for cAKE. Having lost the town cop it is pivotal we are smart about who we are voting for and I was entirely satisfied by my somewhat erroneous vote's outcome. Through it I have learnt some things. For all this to make sense, you must believe that I am a townsolk. Given that killing a villager today is paramount to losing the game (assuming there are 3 mafia, this hasn't been confirmed or denied and I honestly have no idea if there are or not).
1) JLo is a townie. When 4 people had voted for me, JLo had a clear opportunity to kill me off, and possibly win the game for the mafia (if he was one). His voting stance did not change and as such I have to assume he is pro town.
2) Windkeeper0 is probably a townie as well. Also having the ability to vote me to death when given the chance and being unsure of the number of mafia (a number that would only be known to them as Dean has said nothing on the matter thus far)
3) Invisi is a townie. If Invisi was mafia, he wouldn't care what I'm posting about now. His behaviour has been largely pro town and I don't think he's mafia.
This leaves us with Barrydabusdriver, Deez, cAKE and Corvid as the potential mafia people. If there are 3 people who are mafia then the trio is definitely Barry, cAKE and Corvid, as Deez isn't stupid and wouldn't vote for one of his own to be lynched. If there are 2 mafia the possible pairings are as follows
Barry + cAKE
Deez + Corvid
Deez + Barry
Barry + Corvid
Corvid + cAKE
I'm not especially confident on which of these scenarios is the correct one but these are the possible mafia team alignments.
I'd like to change my vote for now
Vote: Undecided
What is this reasoning with the people lol. JLO couldn't have had time to finish you off bc you had 4 votes for like a second. And do you immediately think that whoever votes for you is automatically Mafia? Literally everyone you think is Mafia has voted for you Sorry that sounded a bit mean just inquiring
02/02/2016 12:10:16
well wind keeper and JLo both had opportunities to kill me but didn't.
If I'm killed all this will be corroborated and the mafia will be exposed
02/02/2016 12:15:43
If I'm killed all this will be corroborated and the mafia will be exposed
02/02/2016 12:15:43
Vote update: look at ThatLaggyPerson's post.
Activity update: everyone posted today.
I'm not disclosing the number of mafia.
ThatLaggyPerson as you're not involved in the game I have to ask you keep your post count in this thread to a minimum.
02/02/2016 13:12:19
Activity update: everyone posted today.
I'm not disclosing the number of mafia.
ThatLaggyPerson as you're not involved in the game I have to ask you keep your post count in this thread to a minimum.
02/02/2016 13:12:19
Okay, re-reading through the whole thread, I'm like 90% confident that cAKE and Barry are mafia. They've been subtly backing each other up without even questioning each other. Also, they way they defend themselves is suuuuper suspicious. If there's a third, I have no idea who it is, but I'm preeeetty confident those two are mafia.
vote: cAKE Note: If there's a doctor in this game, pls save me or Maribro <3 Note 2: I'm kinda suspicious of Maribro, except for the fact that he's like definitely not on the cAKE + Barry team because of how much he's been at odds with them, which makes him town by default. Note 3: I came to that conclusion independently of what Maribro wrote. He was like "Oh, these people must be town, that leaves only these guys who happened to be the ones voting for me".
My reasoning is more like "The way these guys back each other up is super suss, and they happen to be targeting Maribro together so Maribro must be town"
02/02/2016 13:42:22
vote: cAKE Note: If there's a doctor in this game, pls save me or Maribro <3 Note 2: I'm kinda suspicious of Maribro, except for the fact that he's like definitely not on the cAKE + Barry team because of how much he's been at odds with them, which makes him town by default. Note 3: I came to that conclusion independently of what Maribro wrote. He was like "Oh, these people must be town, that leaves only these guys who happened to be the ones voting for me".
My reasoning is more like "The way these guys back each other up is super suss, and they happen to be targeting Maribro together so Maribro must be town"
02/02/2016 13:42:22
Vote: cAKE
I'm gonna go back to cAKE. I've been suspicious of this partnership for some time.
Let's see cAKE actually defend himself and not rely on Barry to do it for him by turning the town on me.
02/02/2016 13:42:52
I'm gonna go back to cAKE. I've been suspicious of this partnership for some time.
Let's see cAKE actually defend himself and not rely on Barry to do it for him by turning the town on me.
02/02/2016 13:42:52
Note 4: When I said I re-read the whole thread, I mean the whole thread. Those two have been backing each other up from day 1.
02/02/2016 13:46:59
02/02/2016 13:46:59
Invisi is a cop. The reason i say this is why did he make a poat about what the hell the cop does. Like seriously, why would you ask this here instead of PM'ing Dean. Literally gave it away
02/02/2016 19:41:39
02/02/2016 19:41:39
I have already stated numerous times Maribros stupid reasoning for voting for me so go back and read that. Invisi you really didn't give much evidence or examples, just saying that Barry and I were in the Mafia, which I can tell you we're not. Also I was quite suspicious of Barry on day 1 and I have no idea what his role is.
This is exactly what you, Maribro and a couple of bandwagoners are doing. Targeting me. Barry only stepped in because Maribro just used Pazx's non-evidential shirt looking first vote. Barry didn't want to go off that. We haven't been "backing each other up".
02/02/2016 20:43:20
Invisi said:
My reasoning is more like "The way these guys back each other up is super suss, and they happen to be targeting Maribro together so Maribro must be town"
This is exactly what you, Maribro and a couple of bandwagoners are doing. Targeting me. Barry only stepped in because Maribro just used Pazx's non-evidential shirt looking first vote. Barry didn't want to go off that. We haven't been "backing each other up".
02/02/2016 20:43:20
There are 8 pages of examples for people to go back and read at their own leisure. In particular, Barry has been very defensive of cAKE and far too eager to point out that accusations against him were random and baseless. They may have been to start, but by you two backing each other up so strongly, they no longer are.
Of particular noteworthiness is the lack of distrust between Barry and cAKE - at no point did either of them distrust the other besides the odd clarifying "I can't be sure of his motives but I trust him for now". Neither questioned the other at any point, they just seemed to come to a mutual trusting relationship and must've been communicating outside this thread. C'mon guys, we just need one other townsperson to lynch cAKE, and when he is indeed revealed to be mafia we can turn on Barry tomorrow!
02/03/2016 04:29:08
Of particular noteworthiness is the lack of distrust between Barry and cAKE - at no point did either of them distrust the other besides the odd clarifying "I can't be sure of his motives but I trust him for now". Neither questioned the other at any point, they just seemed to come to a mutual trusting relationship and must've been communicating outside this thread. C'mon guys, we just need one other townsperson to lynch cAKE, and when he is indeed revealed to be mafia we can turn on Barry tomorrow!
02/03/2016 04:29:08
dean party pooper
02/03/2016 07:38:26
02/03/2016 07:38:26
Invisi said:
There are 8 pages of examples for people to go back and read at their own leisure. In particular, Barry has been very defensive of cAKE and far too eager to point out that accusations against him were random and baseless. They may have been to start, but by you two backing each other up so strongly, they no longer are.
Of particular noteworthiness is the lack of distrust between Barry and cAKE - at no point did either of them distrust the other besides the odd clarifying "I can't be sure of his motives but I trust him for now". Neither questioned the other at any point, they just seemed to come to a mutual trusting relationship and must've been communicating outside this thread. C'mon guys, we just need one other townsperson to lynch cAKE, and when he is indeed revealed to be mafia we can turn on Barry tomorrow!
I never distrusted you, JLO, Pazx, Corvid so Barry isn't the only one I don't think is the Mafia. I don't go around accusing literally everyone. Also Barry only defended me because he didn't see any logic in Maribros vote, that's all. You seem awfully close to Maribro lately, pretty much going on his decisions. Could you be? No you couldn't be the Mafia because you said so and your trying to get attention on me off Maribros vote. You're only damaging the town of you lynch me.
02/03/2016 07:55:09
You may notice that invisi voted for me. If we were on a team together would he risk killing one of his own?
Invisi has come to his own conclusions the same way I have but entirely independently to the way I did.
Game over bro you've been rustled
02/03/2016 08:11:21
Invisi has come to his own conclusions the same way I have but entirely independently to the way I did.
Game over bro you've been rustled
02/03/2016 08:11:21
I'm confident enough that Maribro isn't mafia at this point. He was drawing way to much attention to himself and saying things that were way to suspicious to be mafia. I'm probably a bit slow but I only realised what he was doing just after I posted my last post, but that was probably a good thing as I gave Barry confidence that I would follow what he was saying and in turn Corvid broke his silence.
I didn't want to vote against cAKE before because it would be a baseless vote but now it's a bit different. Looking through the forum I agree that Barry and cAKE do seem to be working together and Barry has been sketchy with just how hard he is trying to shift the votes from cAKE to Maribro, without considering the possibility that he was trying to be suspicious to draw out the mafia. It could be that I'm being played right now but I am sure enough with my vote now.
Vote cAKE
02/03/2016 08:15:05
I didn't want to vote against cAKE before because it would be a baseless vote but now it's a bit different. Looking through the forum I agree that Barry and cAKE do seem to be working together and Barry has been sketchy with just how hard he is trying to shift the votes from cAKE to Maribro, without considering the possibility that he was trying to be suspicious to draw out the mafia. It could be that I'm being played right now but I am sure enough with my vote now.
Vote cAKE
02/03/2016 08:15:05
AND WITH THAT LADIES AND GENTLEMAN, CAKE HAS BEEN LYNCHED!
02/03/2016 08:16:07
02/03/2016 08:16:07
A majority has been reached! cAKE, Mafia Godfather, has been lynched!
Night 2 begins. Those with night actions please get them into me as soon as possible.
Final day 2 votes:
JLo (0)
Maribro (3) - Barrydabusdriver, cAKE, Corvid
Corvid (0)
Deez (0)
cAKE (5) - JLo, Deez, Invisi, Maribro, Windkeeper0
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (0) Night 2: no deaths!
Day 3 begins: with seven alive, it takes four to lynch!
02/03/2016 10:08:27
Night 2 begins. Those with night actions please get them into me as soon as possible.
Final day 2 votes:
JLo (0)
Maribro (3) - Barrydabusdriver, cAKE, Corvid
Corvid (0)
Deez (0)
cAKE (5) - JLo, Deez, Invisi, Maribro, Windkeeper0
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
Invisi (0)
No lynch (0)
Not yet voted (0) Night 2: no deaths!
Day 3 begins: with seven alive, it takes four to lynch!
02/03/2016 10:08:27
Vote: Barrydabusdriver
02/03/2016 10:12:19
02/03/2016 10:12:19
*throws hands in the air* WAITTTTTTTTT!!!!
02/03/2016 10:13:24
02/03/2016 10:13:24
Vote: Barrydabusdriver
I don't think it needs an explanation.
02/03/2016 10:14:03
I don't think it needs an explanation.
02/03/2016 10:14:03
I agree I made a mistake a really big mistake I was deceived and fooled, I trusted someone without questioning there motives at all and that was a very big mistake on my part but I am not with cAKE!
02/03/2016 10:16:28
02/03/2016 10:16:28
Invisi! YOU DIDNT DIE LASTNIGHT! OKAY YOU DIDNT! Just please calm down and think, I made a mistake okay!
02/03/2016 10:18:27
02/03/2016 10:18:27
Vote: Barry
Soz man, you've been exposed
02/03/2016 10:20:36
Soz man, you've been exposed
02/03/2016 10:20:36
INVISI DIDNT DIE!, HOW DO YOU THINK I KNOW THAT! WITH THE FACT THAT NO ONE DIED LASTNIGHT! IM THE DOCTOR I SAVED HIM! PLEASE SOMEONE UNVOTE OR THE MAFIA WILL KILL ME!
02/03/2016 10:25:10
02/03/2016 10:25:10
Barrydabusdriver said:
INVISI DIDNT DIE!, HOW DO YOU THINK I KNOW THAT!
Because you chose for him to die then he didn't
02/03/2016 10:34:05