Are we going to go through with lynching Windkeeper today? Any thoughts/feelings on it?
Windkeeper's claim sounds crazy which definitely benefits them if they are Mafia because of the roles we've seen so far such as 2-shot strongman etc. If they flip Mafia, I'll be just as surprised as I would if they flipped town.
8 years ago
Occam's Razor is telling me that the most likely explanation for this fiasco is:
- Windkeeper is lying, and
- Hydro is memeing (but not necessarily lying)
We are caught in yet another position where town is hesitant to lynch a proven scum hit. Perhaps I'm in no position to speak since I was on the other side of this argument yesterday, but seeing as how the day eventually played out, why won't we go for the simplest and best play? Think about it, the outcomes of today if Windkeeper is miller is:
- We lynch him, he flips miller. We lose a townie which sucks, but we're far ahead enough atm that it's not a major loss. Plus, being miller, he should've been aware that he was going to get lynched sooner or later, more sooner than later. And why didn't he claim early?
- We don't lynch him, I guess we keep a townie(?). Unless he lucks out with his night guesses, he's as good as a VT.
But if he's mafia:
- We lynch him, he flips scum. Best outcome in this scenario
- We don't lynch him. Worst outcome possible, we just let a scum live for one more night.
Extra and Dean mentioned earlier that the risk/reward is skewed towards a Windkeeper lynch. I know how much you guys love taking risks (/s) so why are you hesitating now to take the least risky play? Also it's amazing how Windkeeper's convoluted explanations conveniently lines up for his defense. Like cmon really?
8 years ago
- Windkeeper is lying, and
- Hydro is memeing (but not necessarily lying)
We are caught in yet another position where town is hesitant to lynch a proven scum hit. Perhaps I'm in no position to speak since I was on the other side of this argument yesterday, but seeing as how the day eventually played out, why won't we go for the simplest and best play? Think about it, the outcomes of today if Windkeeper is miller is:
- We lynch him, he flips miller. We lose a townie which sucks, but we're far ahead enough atm that it's not a major loss. Plus, being miller, he should've been aware that he was going to get lynched sooner or later, more sooner than later. And why didn't he claim early?
- We don't lynch him, I guess we keep a townie(?). Unless he lucks out with his night guesses, he's as good as a VT.
But if he's mafia:
- We lynch him, he flips scum. Best outcome in this scenario
- We don't lynch him. Worst outcome possible, we just let a scum live for one more night.
Extra and Dean mentioned earlier that the risk/reward is skewed towards a Windkeeper lynch. I know how much you guys love taking risks (/s) so why are you hesitating now to take the least risky play? Also it's amazing how Windkeeper's convoluted explanations conveniently lines up for his defense. Like cmon really?
8 years ago
JLo said:
- We don't lynch him, I guess we keep a townie(?). Unless he lucks out with his night guesses, he's as good as a VT.
He's as good as a lurking, quiet VT come to think of it.
VOTE: Windkeeper Though I will say that he has been posting a bit more oftenly now.
8 years ago
JLo makes a good point. I'm happy to go back on the train.
Vote: Windkeeper0
8 years ago
Vote: Windkeeper0
8 years ago
Windkeeper's posts do sound believable/solid (compared to Hydro) but that's probably because the dude's good at the game like there's a reason he hasn't been lynched in any games yet and Hydro's been lynched in like all of them.
I'll chuck a vote on when I get home from work.
8 years ago
I'll chuck a vote on when I get home from work.
8 years ago
I'm going to put him on L-1. Make sure you read this before you vote him @dean. We don't want any accidental hammers.
VOTE: Windkeeper0
8 years ago
VOTE: Windkeeper0
8 years ago
I'll save you guys the trouble and just lynch myself. Vote:Windkeeper
8 years ago
8 years ago
Windkeeper0 said:
I'll save you guys the trouble and just lynch myself. Vote:Windkeeper
Do you have any scum suspicions or anything you'd like to add before you're lynched? It could help town if you really are aligned with them.
8 years ago
A majority has been met!
Thread will be closed in 30 mins. :)
8 years ago
Thread will be closed in 30 mins. :)
8 years ago
Oh dear Wind is pulling an Aero from last game RIP.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Would it be a good option for JLo to investigate Hydro tonight, or will we find out based on whatever Windkeeper flips?
8 years ago
8 years ago
Dw wind, we will win for you and keep your win record on 100%
8 years ago
8 years ago
Seriously, can people stop hammering themselves? Lol @ Bijou, do you really believe his claim?
8 years ago
8 years ago
He will probably flip town considering he hammered himself Happy to be wrong though
8 years ago
8 years ago
Well at least I'm dead for a legitimate reason this time, I didn't think I would last that long on my defense though.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Windkeeper0 said:Are you saying you didn't like the Vote Thief + Actor combo?
Well at least I'm dead for a legitimate reason this time, I didn't think I would last that long on my defense though.
8 years ago
Windkeeper0 said:Neither did I. I'm surprised so many people bought it. Well played sir.
Well at least I'm dead for a legitimate reason this time, I didn't think I would last that long on my defense though.
8 years ago
It's been an hour.
8 years ago
8 years ago

Don't make me start a riot...
8 years ago
It was day 4 and everything started out normally as usual, no deaths were incurred the previous night.
During the day one of the members in town randomly combusted, no one knew what happened because of his inactivity in town.
With pressure on trump cards were pulled and more roles revealed.
"I'm a Miller Bookie"
A feasible role indeed.
"Wtf no that's my role"
Was his plan foiled or was he just being memed?
Town decided to go with their gut feeling and lynched the "safe" option.
"I'm a nice guy, I'll save you the trouble of trying to decide to lynch me or not over the next two weeks."
Windkeeper, Mafia "Alolan Persian" 2-Shot Vanillerizer/Traitor has been lynched!
"Oh well, I never liked that Pokemon anyway," Aero said. Votes:
Not Voted (4) - cAKE, Luminescent, Cjeccjec, Bijou
LuminousLucas (1) - ThatLaggyPerson
JLo (1) - Ghostbone
Windkeeper (9) - JLo, Extra, Invisi, Hydropimp, Spacejam, Maribro, LuminousLucas, Autumnwind, Windkeeper
ThatLaggyPerson (1) - Dean
8 years ago
During the day one of the members in town randomly combusted, no one knew what happened because of his inactivity in town.
With pressure on trump cards were pulled and more roles revealed.
"I'm a Miller Bookie"
A feasible role indeed.
"Wtf no that's my role"
Was his plan foiled or was he just being memed?
Town decided to go with their gut feeling and lynched the "safe" option.
"I'm a nice guy, I'll save you the trouble of trying to decide to lynch me or not over the next two weeks."
Windkeeper, Mafia "Alolan Persian" 2-Shot Vanillerizer/Traitor has been lynched!
"Oh well, I never liked that Pokemon anyway," Aero said. Votes:
Not Voted (4) - cAKE, Luminescent, Cjeccjec, Bijou
LuminousLucas (1) - ThatLaggyPerson
JLo (1) - Ghostbone
Windkeeper (9) - JLo, Extra, Invisi, Hydropimp, Spacejam, Maribro, LuminousLucas, Autumnwind, Windkeeper
ThatLaggyPerson (1) - Dean
8 years ago
Day 5 commences, with 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch!
8 years ago
8 years ago
We back? No one dead?
Mm very interesting.
8 years ago
Mm very interesting.
8 years ago
Wow, good stuff to all those with night actions. Another successful night for town.
8 years ago
8 years ago
"Cjeccjec is indicated to have targeted no one" Get him.
VOTE: cjeccjec
8 years ago
VOTE: cjeccjec
8 years ago
hmmmm, interesting night. So I'd like to start some discussion based on the voting patterns yesterday.
Windkeeper was a mafia traitor. Despite mafia not knowing who the traitor was, they were aware of his presence as Bijou was hit by the Vanilleriser.
Put it this way, they had no way of knowing if Windkeeper's claim was true or not. So throwing a vote on them would make them seem less suspicious. I'm listing the names of those who I do not really trust, in no particular order.
Spacejam
Extra
Maribro
Invisi (Might be just me but, a fire fighter claim with no arsonist sound very convenient.)
I'll start with Spacejam.
Vote: Spacejam
@Kiwifruit, Cjeccjec didn't do anything last night why does that warrant a vote?
8 years ago
Windkeeper was a mafia traitor. Despite mafia not knowing who the traitor was, they were aware of his presence as Bijou was hit by the Vanilleriser.
Put it this way, they had no way of knowing if Windkeeper's claim was true or not. So throwing a vote on them would make them seem less suspicious. I'm listing the names of those who I do not really trust, in no particular order.
Spacejam
Extra
Maribro
Invisi (Might be just me but, a fire fighter claim with no arsonist sound very convenient.)
I'll start with Spacejam.
Vote: Spacejam
@Kiwifruit, Cjeccjec didn't do anything last night why does that warrant a vote?
8 years ago