Mafia, Smashbox V edition - game over; VIC and NSW mafia win!

Switch: SW-3299-6796-0489

Maribro said:
Longshot is suss because of the way he hammered Laggy. Laggy was hammered while he was defending himself and also at a point when he was L-1. He gave no warning and in the prior post showed no instance of wanting to kill laggy. Despite this, he posted 10 mins later, killing him which was super suspicious when laggy then flipped town. He also made a vague post suggesting a serial killer when nothing thus far would suggest anything like this exists.

Ah, I hadn't really noticed this, so thanks for pointing that out. Again, I still say we hear him out, but yea that's fairly suss.

9 years ago

CubT

92+ tourneys

Wii U: DiscordianFate

3DS: 1521-3834-9377

Invisi said:
I don't know how these bus driver deflector roles work, couldn't CubT have been given an anti-town result from Pazx, but then be told the result was for cAKE?

Yeah, because it wasn't exactly explained over the course of the last 5 pages....

9 years ago

Switch: SW-3299-6796-0489

Maribro said:

Invisi said:
I don't know how these bus driver deflector roles work, couldn't CubT have been given an anti-town result from Pazx, but then be told the result was for cAKE?

No

Bus driver means that instead of investigating Pazx, he investigated cAKE
but it came up anti town as the bus driver moved the frame from Pazx to cAKE

So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Not gonna lie, most of my assumption was based on you and Pazx being super suss in backing each other up consistently.

9 years ago

Wii U: Oceanblue44

Invisi said:

Maribro said:

Invisi said:
I don't know how these bus driver deflector roles work, couldn't CubT have been given an anti-town result from Pazx, but then be told the result was for cAKE?

No

Bus driver means that instead of investigating Pazx, he investigated cAKE
but it came up anti town as the bus driver moved the frame from Pazx to cAKE

So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Not gonna lie, most of my assumption was based on you and Pazx being super suss in backing each other up consistently.

Absolutely 0.

Everything thus far points to CubT, myself and Pazx being town.

9 years ago

Wii U: BattleDolphin

3DS: 5429-8245-2326

Is Longshot still responding or nah?

9 years ago

Ghostbone

336+ tourneys

Wii U: FreeGothitelle

Invisi said:
This could explain the reason that CubT was returned an anti-town result, but more importantly, Pazx and Maribro seem to be working together. Someone pointed it out a number of pages ago, and in what I've read since then it's only gotten stronger.

Pazx's role wouldn't have affected the role that cake returned upon investigation.

Tbh your whole post seems to be pinning the blame on decidedly pro-town players thus far with little reasoning, which reflects badly on you, and trying to defend longshot is questionable too.
It doesn't make sense to turn on Pazx or Maribro if CubT is telling the truth, as then Pazx at least is basically well in the clear (since he was targeted by both mafia factions). Lynching CubT is just a horrible plan in general since he's claimed PR, so we're just giving the mafia a free kill (and even if he is mafia, the other mafia faction doesn't know that and will want to knock him out as he's a guaranteed town PR or enemy maf).

VOTE: LtLongshot

At this point it seems likely that longshot is mafia, and if he's mafia that puts invisi under a lot of scrutiny as well (gives us someone to lynch tomorrow or the other mafia might try to knock him out), so lynching longshot is the best line of play in my eyes.

This thread moves way too fast lmao

9 years ago

Switch: SW-3299-6796-0489

Maribro said:

Invisi said:So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Absolutely 0.

@Dean Can you confirm or deny this?

9 years ago

CubT

92+ tourneys

Wii U: DiscordianFate

3DS: 1521-3834-9377

Can someone explain to me the logic that Maribro must be town?

He was backing up a lot of Pazx statements, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they are both town. Isn't there the possibility that Maribro could be mafia and wants us to believe he is confirmed town?

9 years ago

Wii U: BattleDolphin

3DS: 5429-8245-2326

VOTE : LtLongshot

Kinda just motivation to post really, but I don't see my opinion on him changing

9 years ago

Urisk

91+ tourneys

Invisi said:

Maribro said:

Invisi said:So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Absolutely 0.

@Dean Can you confirm or deny this?

Dean wouldn't confirm or deny it because this is a closed game. I agree with others you're play seems suss and pretty sloppy if you had actually read the thread correctly. Imo it's very reminiscent of how you played as a mafia in the previous game.

9 years ago

Pazx

216+ tourneys

Switch: SW-7769-5972-0967

Wii U: Pazx13

Invisi said:

Maribro said:

Invisi said:
I don't know how these bus driver deflector roles work, couldn't CubT have been given an anti-town result from Pazx, but then be told the result was for cAKE?

No

Bus driver means that instead of investigating Pazx, he investigated cAKE
but it came up anti town as the bus driver moved the frame from Pazx to cAKE

So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Not gonna lie, most of my assumption was based on you and Pazx being super suss in backing each other up consistently.

When have I backed up Maribro?

I've noticed he was "buddying the cop" so to speak, Aero did this last game and it nearly won the game for the mafia, so I was conscious of it and I don't think I've actually contributed to it whatsoever.

9 years ago

Wii U: BattleDolphin

3DS: 5429-8245-2326

Yeah I think Maribro can still definitely be town if he wants. He's played no actual role in the PR's or anything. With that being said that just justifies he isn't 100% pro-town, not that he's maf or anything

9 years ago

Wii U: Oceanblue44

CubT said:
Can someone explain to me the logic that Maribro must be town?

He was backing up a lot of Pazx statements, but that doesn't necessarily mean that they are both town. Isn't there the possibility that Maribro could be mafia and wants us to believe he is confirmed town?

Evidence I'm town

1) I was the first to believe you and was the person to try and take heat away from you with my theory
2) I tried to save laggy (townie) but was too late because I was asleep
3) I've generally played to try and inform the town as much as possible.

9 years ago

Switch: SW-3299-6796-0489

If Dean confirms, then admittedly I must've been wrong in my assumption, and then Pazx is most likely town as you say, I remember someone saying it's unlikely for multiple mafia to target him if he's mafia himself which makes sense.

Though I didn't see where you all got on board with CubT's story, everyone was suspicious of him a few pages ago. What happened there?

Sorry, I've been super busy and really haven't had time to keep up with and think through the goings on of this thread.

9 years ago

Wii U: Oceanblue44

Urisk said:

Invisi said:

Maribro said:

Invisi said:So there's no way for an investigator to investigate someone and receive their result but be told it was for someone else? That's kinda what I figured had happened.

Absolutely 0.

@Dean Can you confirm or deny this?

Dean wouldn't confirm or deny it because this is a closed game. I agree with others you're play seems suss and pretty sloppy if you had actually read the thread correctly. Imo it's very reminiscent of how you played as a mafia in the previous game.

Precisely what I was thinking.

9 years ago

Switch: SW-8346-1530-3039

Wii U: LtLongshot

Wholy shit this is taking longer than expected. Im just making sure that everything im assuming is correct and quoted properly while i create my shit calm down.

9 years ago

Wii U: BattleDolphin

3DS: 5429-8245-2326

Of course Maribro (assuming you flip town) you'd be a good townie, however it isn't actual HARD SOLID evidence.. it's just your posting. Not accusing you of anything at all, js

9 years ago

Switch: SW-8346-1530-3039

Wii U: LtLongshot

I will post a teaser of what i am writing just so you guys don't do anything FUCKING stupid

9 years ago

dean

81+ tourneys

Wii U: dean7599

3DS: 1435-4425-6023

Invisi said:
@Dean Can you confirm or deny this?

There are no standard roles that can do this that I'm aware of.
I wouldn't say it's necessarily impossible depending on how much of a bastard I am with my roles though.

9 years ago

Switch: SW-8346-1530-3039

Wii U: LtLongshot

Just some note taking I’m just gonna bold all player names I use, for my convenience. Also i planned on Pheonix Wright gifs but fuck you guys and your preasure.

So I have been under some flak for the events that occurred on day 1 and day 2. Firstly I’m going to start on the events on day 2 as it would help to explain day 1. So I said this

LtLongshot said:
Well pretty much all of the special roles are still alive.

Although there were only 2 deaths that night, which means the Doc managed to protect someone, or there is no serial killer, or one of the mafia families didn't kill someone, and probably the vigilante didn't kill (probably the first one).

We could have had alot more deaths if there was a serial killer.

How I probably worded it would have probably have started all of this rambling, honestly yes I expected another death that night, Day 1 I had assumed there was a SK in the game (Which i shall explain why shortly). Now this had taken quite the turn on my image which I have to say was harsher than I would have liked (also gonna explain), which made both Pazx and ClubT to harass my butt. I went quiet because I wanted to see how both Pazx and ClubT would continue to harass me. Unfortunately they had started to keep going back to me hammering Laggy day 1. And regarded my day 2 post as me thinking someone didn’t die that night. So in regard to that comment, that was me fucking up…. notice

(probably the first one)

within the quote, that was actually a setting out mistake. I meant for

there is no serial killer

to be the first suggestion, but I was distracted by LEF’s Corrin counters in the Buttonmash stream so I fucked up there. Proof of my fuck up can be found, if you have eyes

We could have had a lot more deaths if there was a serial killer

9 years ago

CubT

92+ tourneys

Wii U: DiscordianFate

3DS: 1521-3834-9377

tfw Longshot freaks out

9 years ago

Switch: SW-8346-1530-3039

Wii U: LtLongshot

and yes i am still writing so calm ya farms

9 years ago

Switch: SW-3299-6796-0489

Hm, I suppose it's more likely that the deflector/bus driver roles would work more how you've described than how I thought.

I mostly tried to defend Longshot because he recently posted that he's got a wall of text incoming, and even though he seems to be the best mafia candidate right now, I think we need to hear him out.

9 years ago