Oh crap yeah. I forgot that CubT watched Maribro.
03/13/2016 01:08:14
Even though I semi-trust Mr.L. There is still a high possibility he is Mafia and I believe him to be Mafia Governor.
So here is what I think has happened. Maribro was gonna get lynched Day 2. Mr.L saw this and protected him so we would lynch him the next day because of how suss it made him look. Giving the Mafia free kills at night 2 and Night 3. We are just lucky Night 2 had no deaths it didn't work that effectively.
03/13/2016 01:24:45
So here is what I think has happened. Maribro was gonna get lynched Day 2. Mr.L saw this and protected him so we would lynch him the next day because of how suss it made him look. Giving the Mafia free kills at night 2 and Night 3. We are just lucky Night 2 had no deaths it didn't work that effectively.
03/13/2016 01:24:45
HydroPimp said:But obviously that plan failed as night 2 didn't have any kills. Its quite far-fetched scheme but i feel as if we do have a town governor
Even though I semi-trust Mr.L. There is still a high possibility he is Mafia and I believe him to be Mafia Governor.
So here is what I think has happened. Maribro was gonna get lynched Day 2. Mr.L saw this and protected him so we would lynch him the next day because of how suss it made him look. Giving the Mafia free kills at night 2 and Night 3. We are just lucky Night 2 had no deaths it didn't work that effectively.
03/13/2016 01:28:12
HydroPimp said:I don't think a mafia governor would waste a save on a townie when they could save one of their own. Mr L could still be mafia but a mafia governor isn't very likely at all anymore.
Even though I semi-trust Mr.L. There is still a high possibility he is Mafia and I believe him to be Mafia Governor.
So here is what I think has happened. Maribro was gonna get lynched Day 2. Mr.L saw this and protected him so we would lynch him the next day because of how suss it made him look. Giving the Mafia free kills at night 2 and Night 3. We are just lucky Night 2 had no deaths it didn't work that effectively.
03/13/2016 01:34:32
LtLongshot said:What does the bold, itlaics and underline mean again?
My list of suspects for those who are interested
HydroPimp
SpaceJam
LEF
Urisk
Wooy
Ghostbone
Windkeeper0
Jezmo
LtLongshot
MrL
BattleDolphin
Pazx
Invisi
Same formatting at maribro's list invisi is meant to be underline -_-
Sorry I have a terrible mem
03/13/2016 01:34:51
Bold is who i believe is town
Underline is people im sus of
Italics is people i believe are maf
03/13/2016 01:36:31
Underline is people im sus of
Italics is people i believe are maf
03/13/2016 01:36:31
MrL said:
LtLongshot said:What does the bold, itlaics and underline mean again?
My list of suspects for those who are interested
HydroPimp
SpaceJam
LEF
Urisk
Wooy
Ghostbone
Windkeeper0
Jezmo
LtLongshot
MrL
BattleDolphin
Pazx
Invisi
Same formatting at maribro's list invisi is meant to be underline -_-
Sorry I have a terrible mem
Bold is town, underline is unsure and italics is suspicious. Unfortunately this list is basically the exact same as Maribro's list with changes being things that we already know. (HydroPimp is town). The only change I see here is Invisi being possible Mafia.
03/13/2016 01:36:40
Wooy said:Honestly yeah, Mari has had the same line of thinking as me which is why i didn't vote either time for him.
MrL said:
LtLongshot said:What does the bold, itlaics and underline mean again?
My list of suspects for those who are interested
HydroPimp
SpaceJam
LEF
Urisk
Wooy
Ghostbone
Windkeeper0
Jezmo
LtLongshot
MrL
BattleDolphin
Pazx
Invisi
Same formatting at maribro's list invisi is meant to be underline -_-
Sorry I have a terrible mem
Bold is town, underline is unsure and italics is suspicious. Unfortunately this list is basically the exact same as Maribro's list with changes being things that we already know. (HydroPimp is town). The only change I see here is Invisi being possible Mafia.
03/13/2016 01:44:30
well you should probably look over it again as Pazx is pretty much confirmed town and Jezmo hasn't posted enough for us to say he is confirmed town. The rest of it I can see where you're coming from.
03/13/2016 01:47:53
03/13/2016 01:47:53
wait so how is Pazx pretty much confirmed town?
03/13/2016 01:48:45
03/13/2016 01:48:45
LtLongshot said:Cheers :)
Bold is who i believe is town
Underline is people im sus of
Italics is people i believe are maf
Wooy said:Yeah but it's interesting to see corroborating views.
MrL said:
LtLongshot said:What does the bold, itlaics and underline mean again?
My list of suspects for those who are interested
HydroPimp
SpaceJam
LEF
Urisk
Wooy
Ghostbone
Windkeeper0
Jezmo
LtLongshot
MrL
BattleDolphin
Pazx
Invisi
Same formatting at maribro's list invisi is meant to be underline -_-
Sorry I have a terrible mem
Bold is town, underline is unsure and italics is suspicious. Unfortunately this list is basically the exact same as Maribro's list with changes being things that we already know. (HydroPimp is town). The only change I see here is Invisi being possible Mafia.
Do you have a list of suss/town people?
03/13/2016 01:49:23
In the first day CubT investigated Pazx but got an anit town result from cAKE instead. cAKE was also murdered that night so it means that both mafia were against him as it would be stupid to frame and kill the same person. We have confirmed there was a bus driver so that is why CubT got a result for cAKE instead of Pazx.
03/13/2016 01:51:17
03/13/2016 01:51:17
Oops i forgot to change the pazx situation now that CubT was confirmed not insane/lying
03/13/2016 01:53:21
03/13/2016 01:53:21
Windkeeper0 said:If he got an anti town from cake where cake and pazx were swapped doesn't that mean that pazx would've given an anti town report?
In the first day CubT investigated Pazx but got an anit town result from cAKE instead. cAKE was also murdered that night so it means that both mafia were against him as it would be stupid to frame and kill the same person. We have confirmed there was a bus driver so that is why CubT got a result for cAKE instead of Pazx.
03/13/2016 01:53:47
Vote:Pazx
03/13/2016 01:55:36
03/13/2016 01:55:36
Guys think for a second pazx isn't maf because he was targeted by both of the mafia. One for the kill and one for the frame. Why would the Maf waste a frame on their own mafia member?
03/13/2016 01:57:41
03/13/2016 01:57:41
Windkeeper0 said:
Here are my thoughts on everyone at the moment:
SpaceJam- I have no clue of what to think of him at the moment, going from defending Maribro to lynching him seemed odd to me. I don't know whether it means anything but he also convinced Wooy to kill Maribro before Pazx had returned.
LEF- Has been sporadically voting and hasn't done anything helpful for the town yet.
Urisk- Hasn't been leading the town as much as the last game and has been agreeing more as well. It could be because there was still 2 active pro town members in the last day but this still raises suspicions.
Wooy- Hasn't done anything that lights up as anti town to me yet.
Ghostbone- Hasn't posted much but hasn't done anything anti town.
Jezmo- Hasn't posted much. Brought up that it would be smarter for the mafia to remain silent and has been doing that. Probably a coincidence but still interesting.
LtLongshot- He is most likely town due to his claims and him not being dead yet.
MrL- Has been agreeing with most decisions and lead the second try of lynching Maribro. He is one of the most suspicious people.
BattleDolphin- Was completely silent until I called him out. He has since been posting at a reasonable amount. He was the 2nd person in the lead of Maribro's second lynch. Not quite as sus as Mr L but still up there for me.
Pazx- Semi-confirmed town.
Invisi- He has soft claimed an odd role. He hammered Maribro the first time. I'm not sure about him at the moment, I'll be keeping my eye on you.
HydroPimp- Confirmed town.
To clear my own name, I was fairly busy while day 3 took place. I did attempt to make additions to the conversation and see where things were going. Posting theories and requesting input from Pazx who was our most confirmed townie at the time but a lot of what I said seems to have been drowned out in the shouting of others such as Mr.L and the bandwagon.
SpaceJam - Definitely seems to have piped up late day 2/ is now talking a lot in day 3. Suggests he baited Wooy into hammering? I'm not getting a strong mafia feel from him
LEF- Uhhh where do I start, dean can you mod replace him?
Wooy- Seems to be going with the town flow which is how he played in the previous game.
Ghostbone- Seems to be following town and providing good insight, notably requested by another player (I forgot who) alongside Pazx when discussing maribro.
Jezmo- Windkeeper raises a good point here that Jezmo hasn't said much and claimed it was mafia type play. I also overheard him and LT discussing the thread at FNS 39. I didn't hear anything incriminating from either player but his [Jezmo's] words suggested that he is indeed upto date with the going ons in the thread
LtLongshot- You suggest that he's town because he hasn't died yet but could well be part of the mafia. It should be noted that CubT, someone who was directly opposing LT's claims died last night.
MrL- By far the most aggressive play he's made was to try and get Maribro killed. Prior to this merely agreed. Could be using the "safety" of Maribro's ambiguity to hammer the nail in his coffin.
BattleDolphin- Followed the lynch train day 2, is either in league with Mr.L as mafia or was using Mr.L as a buffer to not be found out as mafia but still get his agenda through (Maribro's death)
Pazx- Semi-confirmed town.
Invisi- Claimed he had a time based role beneficial to the town. Potential options in my head are either Backup or possibly bomb. Claim was glazed over and we ended up lynching Maribro that day.
HydroPimp- Townie
Windkeeper- Coming to the forefront, was quite earlier on but it's good to see you making more posts. Could be indicative of mafia though if you consider yourself to now be "safe" at least from the town.
03/13/2016 01:57:54
MrL said:If he got an anti town from cake where cake and pazx were swapped doesn't that mean that pazx would've given an anti town report?
No, Pazx and Cake were swapped so he tried to investigate Pazx but investigated Cake instead. Cake is confirmed townie, so the anti-town result of the investigation is due to a framer.
Only circumstances that Pazx isn't town are, one mafia framed and killed Pazx (pretty dumb, technically not impossible), or Pazx was targeted for being framed or killed by his own mafia (completely nonsense play).
03/13/2016 01:59:10
As for me and Jezmo talking about the thread. It was me telling Jezmo that Maribro got lynched and he was town. We were very careful that we didn't discuss anything incriminating.
03/13/2016 01:59:23
03/13/2016 01:59:23
Why vote Pazx?
cAKE was framed (Mafia 1)
cAKE was killed (Mafia 2)
Bus driver swapped Pazx and cAKE
Unless if a mafia team is actually god then its assumed Pazx is townie.
03/13/2016 01:59:52
cAKE was framed (Mafia 1)
cAKE was killed (Mafia 2)
Bus driver swapped Pazx and cAKE
Unless if a mafia team is actually god then its assumed Pazx is townie.
03/13/2016 01:59:52
LtLongshot said:Unless the same mafia framed and killed.
Guys think for a second pazx isn't maf because he was targeted by both of the mafia. One for the kill and one for the frame. Why would the Maf waste a frame on their own mafia member?
03/13/2016 02:00:11
If we are facing god mode mafia then I will willingly accept defeat.
03/13/2016 02:01:49
03/13/2016 02:01:49
SpaceJam said:The fact that neither mafia has lost a person it wouldn't be unreasonable to assume the mafia is god lmao.
Why vote Pazx?
cAKE was framed (Mafia 1)
cAKE was killed (Mafia 2)
Bus driver swapped Pazx and cAKE
Unless if a mafia team is actually god then its assumed Pazx is townie.
Idk how the other games have gone though. Have mafia typically died fairly quickly or do mafias usually remain intact until the end?
03/13/2016 02:02:35
MrL said:
LtLongshot said:Unless the same mafia framed and killed.
Guys think for a second pazx isn't maf because he was targeted by both of the mafia. One for the kill and one for the frame. Why would the Maf waste a frame on their own mafia member?
I should lynch you just for saying that, that is by far the most insane comment I've seen in this thread, and LEF is in here as well.
03/13/2016 02:03:04
Urisk said:xD
MrL said:
LtLongshot said:Unless the same mafia framed and killed.
Guys think for a second pazx isn't maf because he was targeted by both of the mafia. One for the kill and one for the frame. Why would the Maf waste a frame on their own mafia member?
I should lynch you just for saying that, that is by far the most insane comment I've seen in this thread, and LEF is in here as well.
You never know >D: lmao.
I wasn't putting it forward as legitimate pool of thought but just putting it out there as technically possible.
Ghostbone said:Thanks for clearing it up :D
MrL said:If he got an anti town from cake where cake and pazx were swapped doesn't that mean that pazx would've given an anti town report?
No, Pazx and Cake were swapped so he tried to investigate Pazx but investigated Cake instead. Cake is confirmed townie, so the anti-town result of the investigation is due to a framer.
Only circumstances that Pazx isn't town are, one mafia framed and killed Pazx (pretty dumb, technically not impossible), or Pazx was targeted for being framed or killed by his own mafia (completely nonsense play).
I should look into how framer works and stuff (if there is anything more to it than just swapping results). Sorry for still being a bit nooby with some things.
03/13/2016 02:12:24