Hello, I'm alive. From what I've read, everyone seems to be voting based on past games and with this being my second game, I don't have much to add. Also, about what InsertName said about how killing Luminous seems like something I would do, that's actually wrong. I would definitely be trying to kill Maribro because he's definitely one of the strongest people here.
11/15/2016 06:50:17
Corvid deflecting mentions of his lurking and strange behaviour. I think someone said invisi had a similar tactic when he was mafia.
Ghost and Insertname both sharing the same vibes as to who is mafia, with ghost saying insertname is town. Odd behaviour, potential blunder? Too early to say.
dyna_hole acting weird and not being helpful, especially after it has been stressed that people should try to help town as much as possible.
Aero had a significant change in behaviour; either finally acting the part or trying to brush any suspicion under the rug.
The people giving me the biggest maf vibes are cAKE, aero, invisi, ghost and insertname.
Corvid, Battledolphin and Maribro too, but to a lesser extent.
Basty, Battledolphin, Invisi, Windkeeper, Hydro, Dyna, CJ, Corvid, Autumnwind, LachlanF and Duon all need to talk more.
11/15/2016 07:13:09
Ghost and Insertname both sharing the same vibes as to who is mafia, with ghost saying insertname is town. Odd behaviour, potential blunder? Too early to say.
dyna_hole acting weird and not being helpful, especially after it has been stressed that people should try to help town as much as possible.
Aero had a significant change in behaviour; either finally acting the part or trying to brush any suspicion under the rug.
The people giving me the biggest maf vibes are cAKE, aero, invisi, ghost and insertname.
Corvid, Battledolphin and Maribro too, but to a lesser extent.
Basty, Battledolphin, Invisi, Windkeeper, Hydro, Dyna, CJ, Corvid, Autumnwind, LachlanF and Duon all need to talk more.
11/15/2016 07:13:09
I can see why Maribro was so against day one ending so quickly, and why a couple of people were so strongly to end it quick so I'm not really feeling that it makes people suspicious by itself. It may become important later but for now not so much.
I don't think I have enough to go off right now to make a full list of suspicions so I'll leave that until towards the end of day 2 but I'm feeling like Maribro and MrL are giving me a stronger town vibe than anyone else. Aero is playing pretty much the same that he normally does.
11/15/2016 07:15:29
I don't think I have enough to go off right now to make a full list of suspicions so I'll leave that until towards the end of day 2 but I'm feeling like Maribro and MrL are giving me a stronger town vibe than anyone else. Aero is playing pretty much the same that he normally does.
11/15/2016 07:15:29
MrL said:I can't talk more when all the reasong is "Oh, he gives me maf vibes." or "Oh, he's acting the same way as last time." There's literally nothing to add to a conversation full of people like this. Surely we can be smarter about the way we play, right?
Corvid deflecting mentions of his lurking and strange behaviour. I think someone said invisi had a similar tactic when he was mafia.
Ghost and Insertname both sharing the same vibes as to who is mafia, with ghost saying insertname is town. Odd behaviour, potential blunder? Too early to say.
dyna_hole acting weird and not being helpful, especially after it has been stressed that people should try to help town as much as possible.
Aero had a significant change in behaviour; either finally acting the part or trying to brush any suspicion under the rug.
The people giving me the biggest maf vibes are cAKE, aero, invisi, ghost and insertname.
Corvid, Battledolphin and Maribro too, but to a lesser extent.
Basty, Battledolphin, Invisi, Windkeeper, Hydro, Dyna, CJ, Corvid, Autumnwind, LachlanF and Duon all need to talk more.
11/15/2016 07:21:43
ike sdi multiplier
11/15/2016 07:25:39
11/15/2016 07:25:39
Autumnwind, that's how you have to play at first. You need to observe other players' behaviours and try to analyse what they've said, whether it's why they've said something, or what their actions could indicate.
You also have to be mindful to not become fixed on a train of thought, especially when everything is up in the air.
Lack of communication is an anti-town behaviour, it minimises town's progress and does not contribute to the discussion. Anything is better than silence, even postulation. So long as that alone does not drive you to a conclusion.
11/15/2016 07:36:09
You also have to be mindful to not become fixed on a train of thought, especially when everything is up in the air.
Lack of communication is an anti-town behaviour, it minimises town's progress and does not contribute to the discussion. Anything is better than silence, even postulation. So long as that alone does not drive you to a conclusion.
11/15/2016 07:36:09
InsertName said:I literally just made a very serious post about my thoughts. Also I haven't avoided shots at all.
I've been a bit quiet recently because a lot of people are throwing shots around with the argument "They're playing like they did when they were Mafia" which I can't really get behind. Right now in regards to the Luminous lynch I can see people like Corvid or perhaps Autumn getting behind it. Duon did point me out but as he stated I'd be a bit more reserved with my kill. For people who I think are a bit suss right now are Hydro because I'm 95% sure he was lurching and people have pointed out that Mafia can remain quite for now, and Aero because of anti town behaviour and he keeps trying to avoid all shots at him and even memeing around.
Vote: Aero
This game makes me so mad sometimes.
11/15/2016 07:37:00
im surprised duon thinks if insert was mafia he would kill some rando. He isnt a dumbass, Insert would think about it for like a week and hit somebody like maribro if he was mafia, this isnt his fist game.
11/15/2016 07:44:11
11/15/2016 07:44:11
MrL said:That's a fair point, but I still don't know how people want me to make a contribution. I don't know how most of the people normally behave, and if that's what we're basing this on, then my contributions will be as good as garbage. Anyway, why are people who were pushing the Laggy lynch sus automatically? Because they wanted the day to end quicker? No, they saw his as useless, so they used their votes on who they thought would be the best option to lynch. That's not sus, that's people wanting to get rid of unhelpful players, which is pro-town IMO. him*
Autumnwind, that's how you have to play at first. You need to observe other players' behaviours and try to analyse what they've said, whether it's why they've said something, or what their actions could indicate.
You also have to be mindful to not become fixed on a train of thought, especially when everything is up in the air.
Lack of communication is an anti-town behaviour, it minimises town's progress and does not contribute to the discussion. Anything is better than silence, even postulation. So long as that alone does not drive you to a conclusion.
11/15/2016 07:51:16
Corvid said:
I've always thought that you would much rather take someone with a considerable amount of skill early, which doesn't really show in the mafia's choice last night, and I only see it as trick to call out on of the players with less experience as mafia.
Because there's probably some sort of healing role?
11/15/2016 07:52:38
HydroPimp said:
im surprised duon thinks if insert was mafia he would kill some rando. He isnt a dumbass, Insert would think about it for like a week and hit somebody like maribro if he was mafia, this isnt his fist game.
Maribro confirmed maf
One of the big lads have to be maf I think theyd be dead by now if they werent.
Someone just claim doctor tbh
11/15/2016 07:55:13
^
11/15/2016 07:56:43
11/15/2016 07:56:43
EIS-DUON said:Potentially...?
HydroPimp said:
im surprised duon thinks if insert was mafia he would kill some rando. He isnt a dumbass, Insert would think about it for like a week and hit somebody like maribro if he was mafia, this isnt his fist game.
Maribro confirmed maf
One of the big lads have to be maf I think theyd be dead by now if they werent.
Someone just claim doctor tbh
I mean Mafia might have just gone with a safer option night 1 but you're right. If none of them were Mafia then they have a 66% chance of hitting someone who was unprotected. If 1 of them was Mafia then they have a 50% chance still assuming the doctor didn't protect the one who was Mafia. They probably could have just risked it for the biscuit night 1. The Mafia likely has some form of strongman as well, whether that be one or two shot I don't know. I'm against the doctor claiming T B H
I don't see the reason for them to make themselves a target on day 2.
11/15/2016 08:09:01
even the obvious meme. wanting the doctor to claim is very anti-town.
11/15/2016 08:09:51
11/15/2016 08:09:51
Even if we assume mafia went for a safe option, is it unlikely that there are 2 killing factions?
I'd find it very weird if one of the stronger players wasn't targeted.
11/15/2016 08:23:24
I'd find it very weird if one of the stronger players wasn't targeted.
11/15/2016 08:23:24
Ghostbone said:
Even if we assume mafia went for a safe option, is it unlikely that there are 2 killing factions?
I'd find it very weird if one of the stronger players wasn't targeted.
I wouldn't be surprised if there was a serial killer or independent type of role.
There's 20 people, after all.
That's assuming our protection role saved someone who was obvious for a kill.
Here's what I can chalk up for night 1 (this is just based off luminous' death, so don't take this as truth or anything because I know as much as you guys)
Here's our possibilities of what happened:
1. Mafia kills luminous, no third party, doctor misses (most likely atm)
2: Mafia/ Independent (one or the other) role kills LuminousLucas
Mafia/Independent role targets someone pro town
Town Doctor saves pro town person (kind of likely)
3. Third party exists, the doctor missed, and maybe town has some sort of bulletproof man or something (unlikely, that's more of a mafia role to have)
4. Third party exists but can't kill? (least likely, might be a survivor or something but thats really out of the question)
11/15/2016 08:36:24
It's not as likely but there could also have been a bus driver as Aero joked earlier. The only problem with the theory, assuming that the bus driver switched one of the strong players with Luminous, is that it would have been much smarter to switch the strong player with a less useful player.
11/15/2016 09:18:12
11/15/2016 09:18:12
Aerodrome said:
OK so people are calling for a post of substance from me and this is what I think:
Maribro: Seems to be going out of his way to attack me (IM TOWN BAKA) which leads me to say maybe Mafia. Or he could just be really wrong. Probably just a poor misguided townie, but we'll see what happens. Main argument from him seems to be "YOU WANTED LAGGY DEAD AND INVISI AND GHOST ARE KINDA SUSPICIOUS TOO FOR WANTING LAGGY DEAD" but really like Invisi said we just don't want the most boring part of the game lasting for 2 weeks.
His early reads are usually very correct, but not so this game apparently if he's continuing to accuse me.
It's more than just the Laggy stuff. Just generally getting a lot of dodgy vibes from you based on how you've handled previous games. The way the mafia played night 1 feels very similar to how you and Invisi played it with a kind of "oh look something weird happened last night, hopefully someone reveals something so we can kill you!" Just this time I'm not being an idiot and falling for the trap. RE Ghost/Invisi/Aero idk just seems like you guys' posts are suspiciously close together. Maybe I'm just tripping but ye.
Aerodrome said:
Dyna_Hole: Jumped REALLY fast onto Maribro's wagon on me before he'd even given a reason. Probably mafia or a rly stupid townie. I'd like to suggest he be a day 2 lynch option to be honest.
I do think it was weird he wagoned off me without actually saying anything as to why? If you're gonna vote at least explain yoself smh.
Aerodrome said:
Invisi: No opinion. If he's mafia that will become clear within a few in game days because of his incredibly strong town play usually.
Cheeky bit of dismissing pressure for your boy here, gotta admire it :).
Aerodrome said:
Windkeeper0: Town. 100%. HE'S PLAYING EXACTLY LIKE HE DOES WHEN HE'S A TOWN POWER ROLE LOL. Probably the cop or doctor or something.
Why would you draw attention to this? What were you thinking?
---
Don't really understand Insert's reasoning for voting Aero, just feels like a bandwagon and that's not really good play on someone like Aero. He ain't havin none of that.
Dyna_Hole said:
Aerodrome said:
Dyna_Hole: Jumped REALLY fast onto Maribro's wagon on me before he'd even given a reason. Probably mafia or a rly stupid townie. I'd like to suggest he be a day 2 lynch option to be honest.
I mean... you could play it that way, yeah. I don't have proof to say i didn't bandwagon, but, i didn't banwaggon.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Plz try and say stuff with more substance. If you didn't bandwagon what was it specifically that made you suspect Aero?
Dyna_Hole said:
I am now wondering if it's actually possible for me to play a game such as mafia with my shitty personality.
Don't sweat the small stuff fam <3 <3 <3
Windkeeper0 said:
Aero is playing pretty much the same that he normally does.
Aero's only been town once.
Aerodrome said:
InsertName said:I literally just made a very serious post about my thoughts. Also I haven't avoided shots at all.
I've been a bit quiet recently because a lot of people are throwing shots around with the argument "They're playing like they did when they were Mafia" which I can't really get behind. Right now in regards to the Luminous lynch I can see people like Corvid or perhaps Autumn getting behind it. Duon did point me out but as he stated I'd be a bit more reserved with my kill. For people who I think are a bit suss right now are Hydro because I'm 95% sure he was lurching and people have pointed out that Mafia can remain quite for now, and Aero because of anti town behaviour and he keeps trying to avoid all shots at him and even memeing around.
Vote: Aero
This game makes me so mad sometimes.
Agreed, terrible call out from you Insert, smh.
EIS-DUON said:
HydroPimp said:
im surprised duon thinks if insert was mafia he would kill some rando. He isnt a dumbass, Insert would think about it for like a week and hit somebody like maribro if he was mafia, this isnt his fist game.
Maribro confirmed maf
One of the big lads have to be maf I think theyd be dead by now if they werent.
Someone just claim doctor tbh
From an objective standpoint it's very likely one of myself/Invisi/Ghostbone/Aero is maf. Maybe even two. Doesn't necessarily mean that one of us would be dead by that stage because we're also more likely to be Doctord.
Also remember how I said I was an idiot and fell into a maf trap? I tried to push Doc to reveal because Maf chose not to kill night one. Got us in a big mess and I nearly handed the game to maf because I didn't think. Doc reveal is a big no. Same goes for any other reveal at this stage.
cAKE said:I have screwed up the final part of a very long post.
cAKE and Duon movin up in my suss list. Smh you boys I had hope you weren't just scum.
^
End me.
11/15/2016 09:53:14
Dyna_Hole said:the entire post about voting for Aero, i was sussing around the same time as hydro, so i did not feel the need to post an entire paragraph. I also forgot Maribro voted, if anybody is willing to believe that. also, how the hell did i mis-spell 'conclusion'? >.>
HydroPimp said:i have come to this conclosion with my terrible skills of conjecture as Aero semi-agressively spoke to luminous about lynching laggy And with that, I say VOTE: Aerodrome
Hey, im not lurking. I have better things to do with my time. I check back on the thread every so often and say some things. i guess ill be 'protown' and pretty much pretending to be a good player but am actually just saying the obvious and not actually adding anything.
Laggy was a VT who was lynched day one. This can be just dismissed as a meme lynch, but people like aero were really pushing that. I'm not saying he's mafia but there's no doubt that was suspicious.
LuminousLucas was also a VT who died Night 1. Nothing really that surprising here. He wasn't a bad player who was pro town and likely not to be protected. Makes sense for mafia to do that, I guess.
11/15/2016 10:07:23
@Maribro
I said '^' to the first part of Insert's post, before I refreshed the page and saw the 'doctor should just claim now' second post. I agree that's a shit idea *duon's post i mean And also explain why I am regarded as 'suss'? I have literally said 'why didn't laggy defend himself' and the rest of the game I've been trying to push discussion
11/15/2016 10:55:14
I said '^' to the first part of Insert's post, before I refreshed the page and saw the 'doctor should just claim now' second post. I agree that's a shit idea *duon's post i mean And also explain why I am regarded as 'suss'? I have literally said 'why didn't laggy defend himself' and the rest of the game I've been trying to push discussion
11/15/2016 10:55:14
Duon and Aero are at the top of my sus list right now. Duon saying the doctor should reveal themself and Aero pointing out that WindKeeper probably has an important role are my main reasons. Also, I agree with cAKE. Why is everyone saying he's sus? The only arguments everyone's come up with is, "He asked why Laggy didn't defend himself." which doesn't even make any sense, and "He gives me maf vibes." cAKE was a really helpful town player in Lachlan's Smash player themed game on Discord.
11/15/2016 11:13:00
11/15/2016 11:13:00
I doubt you'd be that obvious about your defense of Cake if you were mafia together, so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, though it looks pretty suss.
11/15/2016 11:15:06
11/15/2016 11:15:06
Ghostbone said:He's 9, don't underestimate 9 year olds.
I doubt you'd be that obvious about your defense of Cake if you were mafia together, so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, though it looks pretty suss.
11/15/2016 11:15:57
Aero says the truth for once :^)
11/15/2016 11:24:18
11/15/2016 11:24:18
Oh boy there is a whole lot to read and interpret. I don't even know what to do with myself.
11/15/2016 11:35:41
11/15/2016 11:35:41