Mafia is Back | game over, mafia win

Switch: SW-6707-1685-3201

Wii U: Supertickles

Can we not lynch Lachlan till 9pm? I finish work and would like to read everything again

11/20/2016 05:40:23

LachlanF

67+ tourneys

Switch: SW-6629-2203-1611

Wii U: lachlanfirth96

3DS: 0232-8657-5660

Sorry guys been at the hospital with my best friend so not as responsive as I would have liked today.
When all I've said appears true in a few hours please strike those that rallied against me.
Unfirtunatly this lynching me will likely give the mafia a huge lead, so I hope it was worth it to do.

11/20/2016 05:54:23

cjeccjec

311+ tourneys

Wii U: cjeccjec

3DS: 0018-1766-9226

LachlanF said:
Sorry guys been at the hospital with my best friend so not as responsive as I would have liked today.
When all I've said appears true in a few hours please strike those that rallied against me.
Unfirtunatly this lynching me will likely give the mafia a huge lead, so I hope it was worth it to do.

Why will it give the mafia a huge lead

11/20/2016 06:08:36

Aerodrome

96+ tourneys

cjeccjec said:

LachlanF said:
Sorry guys been at the hospital with my best friend so not as responsive as I would have liked today.
When all I've said appears true in a few hours please strike those that rallied against me.
Unfirtunatly this lynching me will likely give the mafia a huge lead, so I hope it was worth it to do.

Why will it give the mafia a huge lead

He's lying, it won't give the Mafia a huge lead because he is Mafia.

11/20/2016 07:12:42

Switch: SW-2890-3115-0043

Wii U: Benjamin01

Checking something.

Vote: Unvote

11/20/2016 07:23:23

LachlanF

67+ tourneys

Switch: SW-6629-2203-1611

Wii U: lachlanfirth96

3DS: 0232-8657-5660

Well assuming that there is about 4/5 mafia members, unless other night kills occur we loose 1 town during the day, 1 more at night.
Leaving 16 people alive (with 2ish being very inactive so probs about 14 town in reality), which if there is 4/5 mafia they will be in a much better position, to have more say in the lycnhings until they have enough people that they win by majority, which will then by night 5 they win. I won't be active again until I'm dead so good luck town, you dun stuffed up day 2

11/20/2016 07:24:29

Switch: SW-2890-3115-0043

Wii U: Benjamin01

Sorry lachlan, you have to admit your defences have been poor, although I'm not exactly getting much of a mafia vibr from you.

In the event lachlan flips town, I'd like to focus on Aero the next day.

If it is true that Lachlan has a town power role; ironically that's great. Depending on the role, we can take what he's said so far for its word.

Furthermore, if he's a power role, I'd like to propose thr idea that Aero may be a mafia Role Cop. It explains his particular aggression toward Lachlan being mafia. Although role cop does not provide the allignment, if he is mafia he will know that lachlan was town, which may or may not be backed up by the outcome of lynching Lachlan (whether or not he is town / has a power role or not).

If Lachlan does have a town power role, I suggest our first move is to pressure aero. Alot. Hopefully other night actions provide us with alot of info.

Vote: LachlanF

11/20/2016 07:45:12

Aerodrome

96+ tourneys

If I was a mafia role cop I'd just night kill him lol.

I've been aggressive towards him because of his opinion change of me from being "aero can do no wrong" to "aero is mafia" as soon as suspicion went on me.

He did a similar thing to Invisi.

11/20/2016 07:55:07

Maribro

188+ tourneys

Wii U: Oceanblue44

Whether or not Lachlan flips maf or not shouldn't change our perception of the circumstances. Given Lachlan's history, the maf could well have set up an elaborate bussing to get them onto our side.

Don't trust anyone guys.

Lachlan also currently at L-1 so if there are no complaints I will hammer him in an hour.

11/20/2016 08:04:02

Switch: SW-6707-1685-3201

Wii U: Supertickles

Yeah I have a complaint you cuck I said wait till 9pm. Give me 2 hours

11/20/2016 08:07:40

KiwifruitKoala

52+ tourneys

cjeccjec said:

AutumnWind said:
Hang on, why are we voting Lachlan? All it will reveal is whether he's a townie with certain opinions and suspicions or a member of the Mafia with certain opinions and suspicions.

Also, no one say that Lachlan and I are both Mafia because Lachlan said himself that we should lynch him and take the information we can from which role he has, which is clearly pro-town behavior anyway.

We are voting Lachlan because of the exact reason you've stated. What Lachlan has said to defend himself makes sense. But remember even Mafia would say that. Why would we then associate you with being Mafia? If Lachlan does turn out to be Mafia then you might be next on ten chopping board.
The chopping board*

I said for no one to say that we were both Mafia because I figured that people wouldn't pay close enough attention to Lachlan's post and start trying to point suspicion in my direction like what happened when I was defending cAKE. Also, I was one of the first people to say that we should consider lynching Lachlan anyway.

Anyway, now that you've established that Lachlan could still be Mafia anyway, especially now that he claimed a power role but isn't saying which one, I'd like to consider ending the day on a Lachlan lynch, but I'd also like to hear everyone's final thoughts on lynching Lachlan.

11/20/2016 08:12:09

Maribro

188+ tourneys

Wii U: Oceanblue44

SpaceJam said:
Yeah I have a complaint you cuck I said wait till 9pm. Give me 2 hours

Treat me like that and you'll be lucky if I give you 1.

11/20/2016 08:14:58

Switch: SW-2890-3115-0043

Wii U: Benjamin01

We've pretty much heard everyone's thoughts. We're waiting for 2 hours for Spacejam to have his say.

Don't hammer until Spacejam has said his piece. Even then, it's safer to let Maribro hammer.

@Autumnwind

11/20/2016 08:15:42

Rhyno

26+ tourneys

Switch: SW-2480-4766-7898

Wii U: ShadowRhyno

3DS: 2921-9105-5321

Vote: Unvote

I will revote later I guess once Dale has read it.

11/20/2016 08:17:30

KiwifruitKoala

52+ tourneys

MrL said:
We've pretty much heard everyone's thoughts. We're waiting for 2 hours for Spacejam to have his say.

Don't hammer until Spacejam has said his piece. Even then, it's safer to let Maribro hammer.
@Autumnwind

Don't worry, I read what people say.

Oh, what were you checking before MrL?

11/20/2016 08:22:09

Switch: SW-2890-3115-0043

Wii U: Benjamin01

I was just looking into various mafia roles and seeing what could fit well with what has happened so far.

That's why I thought it could be a possibility that one of the mafia (if not Aero [assuming he's mafia]) could be a role cop.

Which reminds me of aero saying that if he was role cop, he would've just killed lachlan.

Mafia could easily choose to not kill for a night; as the first kill being a power role would arouse suspicion that the mafia knew that they were a power role; practically giving away that one of them are role cop. It's much easier to try and get them lynched and let town do the damage; which then lets you say that they were just acting scummy. That was made even easier by it being lachlan.

We'll see though. If Lachlan flips mafia, do you have any ideas on what to do next?

11/20/2016 08:49:33

KiwifruitKoala

52+ tourneys

MrL said:
I was just looking into various mafia roles and seeing what could fit well with what has happened so far.

That's why I thought it could be a possibility that one of the mafia (if not Aero [assuming he's mafia]) could be a role cop.

Which reminds me of aero saying that if he was role cop, he would've just killed lachlan.

Mafia could easily choose to not kill for a night; as the first kill being a power role would arouse suspicion that the mafia knew that they were a power role; practically giving away that one of them are role cop. It's much easier to try and get them lynched and let town do the damage; which then lets you say that they were just acting scummy. That was made even easier by it being lachlan.

We'll see though. If Lachlan flips mafia, do you have any ideas on what to do next?

No, but I'll obviously let everyone know if something comes to mind.

11/20/2016 09:07:30

Switch: SW-2890-3115-0043

Wii U: Benjamin01

oh the last bit was meant for aero my b

11/20/2016 09:11:32

Switch: SW-6707-1685-3201

Wii U: Supertickles

So Ive been re-reading everything.

Basically if Lachlan flips town people will be going after Aero/Invisi. Else AutumnWind is gonna have a badddd time.

At the moment I'm agreeing with what Mr L said, that if we hit Lachlan and he flips town then it is less of a loss than Invisi/Aero flipping town. Lachlan claiming a power role and not revealling it is also pretty suspect. Like why not reveal it? You either get lynched and reveal it or you get called out for lying? Saying "its a huge loss" is pretty silly.

Am I right with my line of thinking of how people are voting though? Also Maribro is not a cuck. It was a spur of the moment rude choice. I actually think he is a lovely person.

11/20/2016 09:21:03

JEANS

84+ tourneys

Switch: SW-5485-9707-1496

wait so are we lycnhing lachlan now?

11/20/2016 09:46:52

Switch: SW-6707-1685-3201

Wii U: Supertickles

I'm trying to get a picture of who should be looked at depending on how he flips before lynching him. Also trying to make sure I understand everyones reasons for lynching

11/20/2016 09:49:08