Mafia, Smashbox V edition - game over; VIC and NSW mafia win!

Ghostbone said:
So, Urisk is claiming there's a roleblocker on his team, MrL claims there is a rolestopper on his team.

We obviously want the mafia to take each other out too, and for that to happen they need to know who is on the other team.

Currently, unless MrL knows other members of Urisk's team, lynching Urisk just prevents that from happening. Urisk's team is likely to try and kill either MrL or Invisi, while MrL's team is likely to kill BattleDolphin as a confirmed PR.
Which means our best line of play is to lynch MrL or Invisi today imo, and if there's still confirmed mafia alive tomorrow, we obviously lynch them. This is because we have a chance to take out the rolestopper, which is a stronger role than the roleblocker as it lets longshot have a chance to kill someone. And tonight, Battledolphin watches Urisk, and we get to see who protects Urisk.

Does this make sense to other townies? (Mainly Pazx/Hydropimp)

LtLongshot said: Other way around

Pazx said:

MrL said:
Focusing on my team still leaves 3 unknowns across the two factions.

If you know two of my team, you can kill us at any time. What you can't do is target urisk's team because we still need to figure out who they are.

Kill my team will ensure your loss. They will kill you and you won't know who has done it. You know 2 of our team.

I won't target town if you don't target me. All I want is for the other mafia team to be heavily damaged. Lynch urisk, you take out their leader. Then we can figure out his two allies. Get them down to 1. Then you can take invisi and I out. It'll leave 1 on each. If you do what urisk is saying it'll leave one of us and all of them.

You won't target town anyway, you can't afford to do that, neither mafia can afford it. You don't even know who is in the other mafia. We know you're not actually trying to help us.

Urisk said:

Pazx said:

MrL said:
Focusing on my team still leaves 3 unknowns across the two factions.

If you know two of my team, you can kill us at any time. What you can't do is target urisk's team because we still need to figure out who they are.

Kill my team will ensure your loss. They will kill you and you won't know who has done it. You know 2 of our team.

I won't target town if you don't target me. All I want is for the other mafia team to be heavily damaged. Lynch urisk, you take out their leader. Then we can figure out his two allies. Get them down to 1. Then you can take invisi and I out. It'll leave 1 on each. If you do what urisk is saying it'll leave one of us and all of them.

You won't target town anyway, you can't afford to do that, neither mafia can afford it. You don't even know who is in the other mafia. We know you're not actually trying to help us.

Exactly. Hence youf best bet is to lower 1 mafia team as quickly as possible i.e lynch the two known mafia members to kill off one team as fast as possible.

LtLongshot said:
ANYONE WHO HAS VOTED FOR MRL PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD UNVOTE WE NEED TO THINK TODAY OUT

Ghostbone said:
So, Urisk is claiming there's a roleblocker on his team, MrL claims there is a rolestopper on his team.

We obviously want the mafia to take each other out too, and for that to happen they need to know who is on the other team.

Currently, unless MrL knows other members of Urisk's team, lynching Urisk just prevents that from happening. Urisk's team is likely to try and kill either MrL or Invisi, while MrL's team is likely to kill BattleDolphin as a confirmed PR.
Which means our best line of play is to lynch MrL or Invisi today imo, and if there's still confirmed mafia alive tomorrow, we obviously lynch them. This is because we have a chance to take out the rolestopper, which is a stronger role than the roleblocker as it lets longshot have a chance to kill someone. And tonight, Battledolphin watches Urisk, and we get to see who protects Urisk.

Does this make sense to other townies? (Mainly Pazx/Hydropimp)

LEF said:

LtLongshot said:
ANYONE WHO HAS VOTED FOR MRL PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD UNVOTE WE NEED TO THINK TODAY OUT

Why not just kill a mafia member, isnt that the goal of the Lynch before they then kill us at night?

Windkeeper0 said:
So our options are to either have each mafia lose 1 member with us getting rid of the role blocker an important role for Mr L's group or we have Mr L's mafia lose 2 members. So what is our goal to get rid of a whole group of weaken both groups?

Ghostbone said:
@longshot, I'm pretty sure my plan is the best way to figure out who the other mafia members are, do you think otherwise?

Ghostbone said:
We get information out of Battledolphin in regards to who's protecting Urisk, with the bonus benefit of YOU being able to take a mafia member out since MrL won't be able to roleblock you (assuming you're actually vigi)

Except it's looking more and more likely that you're the 3rd member of the MrL/Invisi mafia lol.

LtLongshot said:
Ok think about it, We follow ghost's plan, Yay we kill some mafia members, But we are still in the exact same position that we are currently in Nothing changes apart from a few less people can talk. And that is it. We would still need to figure out who the rest of the mafia are at that point, it will be the exact same list as we have today. NOTHING will change. Please use your heads.

LEF said:

LtLongshot said:
Ok think about it, We follow ghost's plan, Yay we kill some mafia members, But we are still in the exact same position that we are currently in Nothing changes apart from a few less people can talk. And that is it. We would still need to figure out who the rest of the mafia are at that point, it will be the exact same list as we have today. NOTHING will change. Please use your heads.

The point of mafia is to kill the mafia. For those who dont understand what my last comment meant.