I think if Varous knew the thread was open he'd have posted at least once? No use pressuring someone who's not even checking the thread. May as well just wait 24 hours for the mods to shout at him / kick him out.
On the other hand voting for lurkers is always good! (low post count / content but are obviously checking the thread). Lurking is anti-town; don't do it.
UNVOTE; it's not JEANS's birthday anymore. Will choose who to vote for when I get home and have a proper read of the thread.
Tasmanians always hold these games up I swear.
01/22/2019 04:57:37
dean said:
I think if Varous knew the thread was open he'd have posted at least once? No use pressuring someone who's not even checking the thread. May as well just wait 24 hours for the mods to shout at him / kick him out.
On the other hand voting for lurkers is always good! (low post count / content but are obviously checking the thread). Lurking is anti-town; don't do it.
UNVOTE; it's not JEANS's birthday anymore. Will choose who to vote for when I get home and have a proper read of the thread.
Tasmanians always hold these games up I swear.
its like tasmanians dont exist, aye
insert triggered tassies
01/22/2019 05:14:17
vote: unvote
really isnt much to go off, no one seems overly aggressive. i would also like to think that there is a third party in this game with this many people but i doubt it would be something like a jester.
vote: mrL
01/22/2019 05:25:01
really isnt much to go off, no one seems overly aggressive. i would also like to think that there is a third party in this game with this many people but i doubt it would be something like a jester.
vote: mrL
01/22/2019 05:25:01
Woah varous is in this game
Defs voting for him tasmanian children must be defeated
Vote: Varous
01/22/2019 05:30:03
Defs voting for him tasmanian children must be defeated
Vote: Varous
01/22/2019 05:30:03
Wow, you got me JEANS, how did you figure out our foolproof mafia plan of making sure we are all active in chat at the same time? Clearly the best play as mafia is to draw attention to yourself. How did you see through it so easily?
01/22/2019 05:36:54
01/22/2019 05:36:54
Dean wouldn’t varous make for a better policy lynch, if he continues to not post?
That way we’ll only lose 1 person day one, instead of him getting booted and then policy lynching. Makes sense to me but maybe I’m just bad Is there any particular reason why you’ve revoted for me jonchee? It’d make sense to vote for players to post more, rather than try to make a bandwagon and cut discussion short
01/22/2019 06:04:05
That way we’ll only lose 1 person day one, instead of him getting booted and then policy lynching. Makes sense to me but maybe I’m just bad Is there any particular reason why you’ve revoted for me jonchee? It’d make sense to vote for players to post more, rather than try to make a bandwagon and cut discussion short
01/22/2019 06:04:05
Did you want to lynch him in the next 24 hours?
If he's inactive then he'd probably be replaced rather than killed, if there were any interested players that haven't signed up.
I also don't believe that Day 1 is a "true" policy lynch; we don't have any hard evidence no, but I'd rather back my instincts on who to lynch, based off the posts so far (see who seems nervous, out of character, grouping up, etc.), than take the ~20% chance or so that Varous is mafia, as we have LITERALLY zero information on him (apart from that he doesn't seem very interested in the game).
01/22/2019 06:55:21
If he's inactive then he'd probably be replaced rather than killed, if there were any interested players that haven't signed up.
I also don't believe that Day 1 is a "true" policy lynch; we don't have any hard evidence no, but I'd rather back my instincts on who to lynch, based off the posts so far (see who seems nervous, out of character, grouping up, etc.), than take the ~20% chance or so that Varous is mafia, as we have LITERALLY zero information on him (apart from that he doesn't seem very interested in the game).
01/22/2019 06:55:21
Vote:Boozer
Sounds like a loser
01/22/2019 07:03:29
Sounds like a loser
01/22/2019 07:03:29
OK, now we can vote for him.
01/22/2019 07:13:55
01/22/2019 07:13:55
Varous said:
Vote:Boozer
Sounds like a loser
sigh
01/22/2019 07:21:51
Fair call dean, it might be a bit early to ask, but what would your shortlist be atm of people falling into that category (or rather not say yet to see if the trend develops?)
01/22/2019 07:30:58
01/22/2019 07:30:58
Even if we agree on a lynch wouldnt it be in our best interest to hold off until the end of the day?
01/22/2019 08:03:14
01/22/2019 08:03:14
MrL said:I think it's interesting that the three Vics I called out in my last post (Boozer, formerDuon and Insie) have posted little content but all responded reasonably quickly after my post. Lurking? There's a couple of others (Invisi's posted mostly nothing but fluff so far). How about you Benjamin? I trust you're up to date with the thread.
Fair call dean, it might be a bit early to ask, but what would your shortlist be atm of people falling into that category (or rather not say yet to see if the trend develops?)
@Varous have you read the whole thread? That's a very disappointing first contribution.
01/22/2019 08:07:42
dean said:
Did you want to lynch him in the next 24 hours?
What for? I don't mind speeding the game up or anything but rushing a lynch right at the moment doesn't seem like a great idea considering the discussion thus far has been surprisingly good for day 1.
01/22/2019 09:07:03
It sounded like MrL wanted to lynch Varous before he was kicked out due to inactivity so that only one person died this day phase.
01/22/2019 09:08:35
01/22/2019 09:08:35
I would like to congratulate everyone. There has been more discussion in this mafia so far than the entirety of the last one.
01/22/2019 09:18:39
01/22/2019 09:18:39
Against my better judgment: Vote: Varous
01/22/2019 09:19:19
01/22/2019 09:19:19
What does your better judgement suggest Aero?
01/22/2019 09:23:08
01/22/2019 09:23:08
my better judgement suggests that varous is town and just uninteresting in the game, but maybe piling some votes on him will bring forth some info
01/22/2019 09:38:26
01/22/2019 09:38:26
Fair enough. If Varous is jester, I’m going to cry.
01/22/2019 09:48:30
01/22/2019 09:48:30
Historically inactive players have been replaced rather than killed off where possible as Dean has already said, so I don't think rushing a lynch will be necessary.
Incidentally, can anyone ever give me an example of a game where a mafia member literally didn't post anything at all? I'd say it's hella unlikely that Varous is anti-town given it took him like three days to post anything at all.
And hey, so far everything Varous has posted is confirmed to be true so there's no reason not to trust him. If you want to pile a bit of pressure on him to post more content though then I'm not against that idea.
Vote: Varous
Contribute to the discussion a little my dude and I'll unvote you. I get that it can be kinda awkward to work your way into the game when you've already missed like 6-7 pages but if you're town then I'd rather not policy lynch you if you feel like you can make a solid contribution to the game.
01/22/2019 09:50:37
Incidentally, can anyone ever give me an example of a game where a mafia member literally didn't post anything at all? I'd say it's hella unlikely that Varous is anti-town given it took him like three days to post anything at all.
And hey, so far everything Varous has posted is confirmed to be true so there's no reason not to trust him. If you want to pile a bit of pressure on him to post more content though then I'm not against that idea.
Vote: Varous
Contribute to the discussion a little my dude and I'll unvote you. I get that it can be kinda awkward to work your way into the game when you've already missed like 6-7 pages but if you're town then I'd rather not policy lynch you if you feel like you can make a solid contribution to the game.
01/22/2019 09:50:37
i revoted you mrL cos you keep mentioning policy day one lynching. just like how we're trying to get information out of varous by piling votes i was trying to get some info too other than "this is silly its just policy lynching"
sad contribution from varous, if you're town at least try a lil more!!!
01/22/2019 10:00:29
sad contribution from varous, if you're town at least try a lil more!!!
01/22/2019 10:00:29
My only thoughts so far are: Fuck! Have many times do we have to go over the whole no lynch day 1 being awful. I want to policy lynch no lynchers, that'll learn em
01/22/2019 10:30:13
01/22/2019 10:30:13
No lynch seems like a good idea if you don't think it through properly. I understand why the question is asked every game.
01/22/2019 10:58:25
01/22/2019 10:58:25
interested to hear from the following people. what do you guys think of the current Situation?
Maribro
Insie
THatlaggyperson
01/22/2019 11:07:11
Maribro
Insie
THatlaggyperson
01/22/2019 11:07:11