As I said I'm a jack of all trades. I get one shot uses of different things.
I'd like to hear from Barry so I'm gonna vote him.
Vote: Barry
9 years ago
A no lynch is just a wasted day phase imo, we should only be no lynching if the doctor or another important power role claims when they're about to be lynched. Otherwise we're just giving the Mafia opportunities to kill us.
9 years ago
9 years ago
HydroPimp said:
We dont have much information cause we dont know who the docor saved and its not worth accidentally killing the doctor knowing that they played smart and saved somebody, they seem too valuable to risk.
VOTE: No Lynch
I disagree with a no lynch vote. We have such an advantage right now. TBQH the chances of hitting doctor are basically 0. As I have previously said they are playing smart and so there shouldn't be any obvious marks against them. More votes to lynch should at least claw out information from more special roles and anyone who doesn't claim one under pressure is either mafia or a townie and are thus useless to us. If someone does claim one then we can press this towards our advantage.
9 years ago
Urisk said:
Aerodrome said:
I had like a two hour nap and we're literally no closer to being on a resolution on this topic, so I'm going to just casually cast a soft vote here on JLo. I don't really want to see a two week argument on if the doctor should reveal himself or not.
VOTE: JLo Neither Maribro nor cAKE are scum imo, so I don't think LEF or Urisk should be voting for them.
Like I said my vote for Maribro was a soft one and it does seem to have made him crack a fair bit. I'm leaving my vote on cause we have no one better to go for right now. Also please utilize the mutex lock.
I don't quite understand how the mutex lock works. Yaw not the boss of me.
9 years ago
You post "I'm voting"
This updates the thread and if anyone else has posted "I'm voting" you don't vote until they have made their vote and then you report "I'm voting"
This is just a programming tool to make things thread safe and ensures that we don't end up with people voting in quick succession so that they overlap. This allows us town members to have more time to analyse each vote.
9 years ago
This updates the thread and if anyone else has posted "I'm voting" you don't vote until they have made their vote and then you report "I'm voting"
This is just a programming tool to make things thread safe and ensures that we don't end up with people voting in quick succession so that they overlap. This allows us town members to have more time to analyse each vote.
9 years ago
Urisk said:
HydroPimp said:
We dont have much information cause we dont know who the docor saved and its not worth accidentally killing the doctor knowing that they played smart and saved somebody, they seem too valuable to risk.
VOTE: No Lynch
I disagree with a no lynch vote. We have such an advantage right now. TBQH the chances of hitting doctor are basically 0. As I have previously said they are playing smart and so there shouldn't be any obvious marks against them. More votes to lynch should at least claw out information from more special roles and anyone who doesn't claim one under pressure is either mafia or a townie and are thus useless to us. If someone does claim one then we can press this towards our advantage.
very good point. I'm still gonna wait before voting, dont wanna add too much pressure onto somebody, see how they react to a few so that when they go on they dont have like 7 votes them and dont stand a chance.
Vote:No Vote
9 years ago
Alright, I'll do that if I remember.
9 years ago
9 years ago
HydroPimp said:
very good point. I'm still gonna wait before voting, dont wanna add too much pressure onto somebody, see how they react to a few so that when they go on they dont have like 7 votes them and dont stand a chance.
to be quite honest that's one of the best places to put someone because it means they're mildly safe from mafia voting for them if they aren't mafia them selves. you can see this in how I chose to put laggy to l-1. as such
"I'm Voting" Vote: Jlo
9 years ago
HydroPimp said:
Urisk said:
HydroPimp said:
We dont have much information cause we dont know who the docor saved and its not worth accidentally killing the doctor knowing that they played smart and saved somebody, they seem too valuable to risk.
VOTE: No Lynch
I disagree with a no lynch vote. We have such an advantage right now. TBQH the chances of hitting doctor are basically 0. As I have previously said they are playing smart and so there shouldn't be any obvious marks against them. More votes to lynch should at least claw out information from more special roles and anyone who doesn't claim one under pressure is either mafia or a townie and are thus useless to us. If someone does claim one then we can press this towards our advantage.
very good point. I'm still gonna wait before voting, dont wanna add too much pressure onto somebody, see how they react to a few so that when they go on they dont have like 7 votes them and dont stand a chance.
Vote:No Vote
Hydro, I know you're new and all, but your all your statements so far have sounded very scum like. You post medium-size paragraphs on occasion basically going with the flow. They say nothing constructive or new to stay out of suspicion. This is classic mafia play and I've got my eye on you. Also, yes, I know I've done it but going back on your vote as soon as someone objects it (to try not getting on their bad side and noticing you) is a little scummy too.
9 years ago
cAKE I think we can jot that down to him just being bad at mafia games, not necessarily being mafia in itself. I have a tournament in like 30 mins so I'mma go to that.
9 years ago
9 years ago
LEF said:
Vote: Unvote
Vote: cAKE
elaborate
9 years ago
I think he think's ur scum, cAKE!
9 years ago
9 years ago
Also to quote the man himself,
Vote: JLo
yes but why
9 years ago
JLo said:
In that case, one ticket for the bandwagon please
Vote: cAKE
Vote: JLo
Aerodrome said:
I think he think's ur scum, cAKE!
yes but why
9 years ago
Alright Maribro you wanted to hear from me here is what I have to say, sorry I've been bit busy but I have been keeping good track of the game. I think currently the doctor holds considerable power in this game after last night, but for him to reveal himself now would be bad as he would only have a limited impact. As you know I was the doctor last game so I know how it works, the doctor can save one person per night so I think we should wait one more night before the doctor should be encouraged to reveal themselves.
9 years ago
9 years ago
im still at a tourney (and im mad salty) but i have 2 cents
$0.01 - doctor revealing himself is a bad play, instead the doctor/mafia should be playing a 50/50 between targeting the same person as last night and targeting maribro
$0.02 - this "i am voting" thing seems kinda unnecessary, but what would be good is an "intent to hammer" style post, so that if you are going to be the final vote on the lynch you have to announce it, and we can agree that not indicating your intent is a very scummy play
full thoughts later, maybe tomorrow
9 years ago
$0.01 - doctor revealing himself is a bad play, instead the doctor/mafia should be playing a 50/50 between targeting the same person as last night and targeting maribro
$0.02 - this "i am voting" thing seems kinda unnecessary, but what would be good is an "intent to hammer" style post, so that if you are going to be the final vote on the lynch you have to announce it, and we can agree that not indicating your intent is a very scummy play
full thoughts later, maybe tomorrow
9 years ago
Barrydabusdriver said:
Alright Maribro you wanted to hear from me here is what I have to say, sorry I've been bit busy but I have been keeping good track of the game. I think currently the doctor holds considerable power in this game after last night, but for him to reveal himself now would be bad as he would only have a limited impact. As you know I was the doctor last game so I know how it works, the doctor can save one person per night so I think we should wait one more night before the doctor should be encouraged to reveal themselves.
Agreed, I don't want to lynch anyone right now but i'm happy to apply pressure. Maribro played suboptimally and outed himself but we should not let his mistakes be to the detriment of the group.
9 years ago
ok, FIRST THING
the doctor SHOULD NOT reveal themselves, that would be a fucking stupid idea, first of all we have no way of proving that whoever says they are the doctor is actually the doctor, and second it'll just get him killed.
We DO NOT WANT the mafia to know who the power roles are, thats a really bad idea.
Go back and read over the last few pages, anyone pressuring the doctor to reveal himself, trying really hard to get it to happen should INSTANTLY be on everyones suspicion radar because the doctor revealing himself would be a really good thing to happen for the mafia's side.
Secondly we've already talked about why a no-lynch is bad, the only way the town can win the game is through lynching, a no lynch is just fucking dumb and any 'we should be careful while we are ahead' argument is a very poor one.
tl:dr, anyone trying to get the doctor to reveal himself, and anyone trying to get people to no lynch (both really bad plays for the town side), should be on your radars as suspicious and we should start putting them under pressure.
This is my third ever game of mafia and last time I played was like 2009, dont put too much faith in me to carry the game. also obligatory get rekt laggy post.
Fucking dean, I'm sure he saw the pre-game 'lets kill laggy' banter and made him a mafia because of that, never misses a chance for a good chuckle.
9 years ago
the doctor SHOULD NOT reveal themselves, that would be a fucking stupid idea, first of all we have no way of proving that whoever says they are the doctor is actually the doctor, and second it'll just get him killed.
We DO NOT WANT the mafia to know who the power roles are, thats a really bad idea.
Go back and read over the last few pages, anyone pressuring the doctor to reveal himself, trying really hard to get it to happen should INSTANTLY be on everyones suspicion radar because the doctor revealing himself would be a really good thing to happen for the mafia's side.
Secondly we've already talked about why a no-lynch is bad, the only way the town can win the game is through lynching, a no lynch is just fucking dumb and any 'we should be careful while we are ahead' argument is a very poor one.
tl:dr, anyone trying to get the doctor to reveal himself, and anyone trying to get people to no lynch (both really bad plays for the town side), should be on your radars as suspicious and we should start putting them under pressure.
Aerodrome said:I'm so glad we listened to Atyeo to lynch day 1. And Pazx too for starting the vote. With you guys the town is assured victory! ✌
Aerodrome said:
Atyeo, Invisi, Pazx are prime night kill candidates imo. They're the smartest players here by far.
This is my third ever game of mafia and last time I played was like 2009, dont put too much faith in me to carry the game. also obligatory get rekt laggy post.
Fucking dean, I'm sure he saw the pre-game 'lets kill laggy' banter and made him a mafia because of that, never misses a chance for a good chuckle.
9 years ago
Atyeo said:
ok, FIRST THING
the doctor SHOULD NOT reveal themselves, that would be a fucking stupid idea, first of all we have no way of proving that whoever says they are the doctor is actually the doctor, and second it'll just get him killed.
We DO NOT WANT the mafia to know who the power roles are, thats a really bad idea.
Go back and read over the last few pages, anyone pressuring the doctor to reveal himself, trying really hard to get it to happen should INSTANTLY be on everyones suspicion radar because the doctor revealing himself would be a really good thing to happen for the mafia's side.
Secondly we've already talked about why a no-lynch is bad, the only way the town can win the game is through lynching, a no lynch is just fucking dumb and any 'we should be careful while we are ahead' argument is a very poor one.
tl:dr, anyone trying to get the doctor to reveal himself, and anyone trying to get people to no lynch (both really bad plays for the town side), should be on your radars as suspicious and we should start putting them under pressure.Aerodrome said:I'm so glad we listened to Atyeo to lynch day 1. And Pazx too for starting the vote. With you guys the town is assured victory! ✌
Aerodrome said:
Atyeo, Invisi, Pazx are prime night kill candidates imo. They're the smartest players here by far.
This is my third ever game of mafia and last time I played was like 2009, dont put too much faith in me to carry the game. also obligatory get rekt laggy post.
Fucking dean, I'm sure he saw the pre-game 'lets kill laggy' banter and made him a mafia because of that, never misses a chance for a good chuckle.
Who's been asking for a Day 2 No lynch? Also, the doctor revealing himself has its benefits but you can discuss that with Maribro. But yes it does have a massive downside
9 years ago
other than us not lynching him, what benefits?
9 years ago
9 years ago
As Maribro stated, we can figure out who protected and that would give us insight into the mafia. Chances are the doctor is speaking among us and is active right now.
9 years ago
9 years ago
we cant guarantee we can figure anything out because we have no way of knowing if someone is telling the truth when they reveal they are the doctor, you would be using that knowledge as a point of reference to figure other shit out, but if that point of reference was a lie you're gonna go down shitstreet.
Unless I've missed something big, right now the mafia shouldn't have any idea who the doctor is, and we want it to stay that way.
What your suggesting is too big of a risk without any real reward.
As for your other question about how wants a no lynch, go back and read for yourself I'm not going to do your reading for you.
9 years ago
Unless I've missed something big, right now the mafia shouldn't have any idea who the doctor is, and we want it to stay that way.
What your suggesting is too big of a risk without any real reward.
As for your other question about how wants a no lynch, go back and read for yourself I'm not going to do your reading for you.
9 years ago
Oh yeah hydropimp thats right
9 years ago
9 years ago
Are you saying that Maribro is potentially scum? I wonder if he's lying about his power role.
9 years ago
9 years ago
I also agree that not revealing doctor would be a much better play than the mutual Maribro/doc protect at night. Since night 1 was a success for town, the doc can hold off revealing himself until Day 3 or 4, when the effects of the power roles are more prominent.
Seems like there's 5 votes for me to get lynched (including my vote kek). If you guys are able to gain an advantage with the lynch, I'll take the hit for the town as a mislynch doesn't affect town as much early on in the game. Also, lying about your power role is an incredibly risky play, especially early into this game and especially if you are Mafia, when it can return to bite you back in the ass once more information is available early on. I have no reason atm to believe Maribro is lying about his power role.
9 years ago
Seems like there's 5 votes for me to get lynched (including my vote kek). If you guys are able to gain an advantage with the lynch, I'll take the hit for the town as a mislynch doesn't affect town as much early on in the game. Also, lying about your power role is an incredibly risky play, especially early into this game and especially if you are Mafia, when it can return to bite you back in the ass once more information is available early on. I have no reason atm to believe Maribro is lying about his power role.
9 years ago
With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!
Votes:
JLo (4) - JLo, Aerodrome, Urisk, cAKE
Wooy (0)
Aerodrome (0)
cAKE (1) - LEF
Deez (0)
Atyeo (0)
Maribro (0)
LEF (0)
Barrydabusdriver (2) - Wooy, Maribro
Pazx (0)
Corvid (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
HydroPimp (0)
Invisi (0)
Urisk (0)
No lynch (0)
Not voted (8) - Deez, Atyeo, Barrydabusdriver, Pazx, Corvid, Windkeeper0, Invisi, HydroPimp
9 years ago
Votes:
JLo (4) - JLo, Aerodrome, Urisk, cAKE
Wooy (0)
Aerodrome (0)
cAKE (1) - LEF
Deez (0)
Atyeo (0)
Maribro (0)
LEF (0)
Barrydabusdriver (2) - Wooy, Maribro
Pazx (0)
Corvid (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
HydroPimp (0)
Invisi (0)
Urisk (0)
No lynch (0)
Not voted (8) - Deez, Atyeo, Barrydabusdriver, Pazx, Corvid, Windkeeper0, Invisi, HydroPimp
9 years ago