Hello friends,
My computer is working momentarily so that's good.
I don't have a lot else to say at the moment until other people talk.
But my highest suspects are MrL, Battledolphin and cAKE at the moment.
12/26/2018 01:15:17
only got like 2 days left better get shit moving
voting cake cause of previous post
vote:cake
12/26/2018 07:15:25
voting cake cause of previous post
vote:cake
12/26/2018 07:15:25
i vote cAKE now
Vote: cAKE
12/26/2018 09:09:17
Vote: cAKE
12/26/2018 09:09:17
We still have like 3 days left.
So I'm going to Unvote: cAKE for now until a couple more people contribute.
12/26/2018 11:11:48
So I'm going to Unvote: cAKE for now until a couple more people contribute.
12/26/2018 11:11:48
I'm waiting for cAKE to have some sort of input before I make any decisions but I generally find myself agreeing with a fair bit of what's being said. Everybody seems at least slightly suspicious here, cAKE hasn't input anything since day 1 and it honestly looks like he's the next on the lynch list based on what has been said both day 1, and today. I'm also wary of this Exist fellow. He's probably just pretending he doesn't know how to play these sorts of games.
12/26/2018 14:09:52
12/26/2018 14:09:52
Went back and had a read, the whole 'they could have killed glace because of this list but it just seems too stupid and bad of a play for anyone to make' argument I agreed with at the time. But now that I've had a bit of a think about it, these games have always been rife with next level retarded plays and stupid shit.
So I'm kinda leaning on the side of maybe we shouldn't overthink it and that the mafia just did a bad play, we've talked about it being bad enough so I'll be interested to see their course correction and who they decide to go for next, that should be a big tell I think.
But as to where we are at right now, MrL thinks that bd and cake are mafia and bd is suspicious of MrL. So I dont just wanna hear from cake, specifically I want to hear cakes opinion on those two. They seem the most suspicious but at the same time those 3 are targeting each other, are they just trying to distance each other from one another in case we get a mafia lynch? I'm sure there is mafia in there but based on that behavior it seems pretty unlikely that they are all mafia.
Anyway cake you are up, please lets have something a little more convincing then the now standard 'I cant prove I am town just kill me'
12/26/2018 23:55:54
So I'm kinda leaning on the side of maybe we shouldn't overthink it and that the mafia just did a bad play, we've talked about it being bad enough so I'll be interested to see their course correction and who they decide to go for next, that should be a big tell I think.
But as to where we are at right now, MrL thinks that bd and cake are mafia and bd is suspicious of MrL. So I dont just wanna hear from cake, specifically I want to hear cakes opinion on those two. They seem the most suspicious but at the same time those 3 are targeting each other, are they just trying to distance each other from one another in case we get a mafia lynch? I'm sure there is mafia in there but based on that behavior it seems pretty unlikely that they are all mafia.
Anyway cake you are up, please lets have something a little more convincing then the now standard 'I cant prove I am town just kill me'
12/26/2018 23:55:54
Alternatively I could be meta-gaming myself.
But with how inactive cAKE has been I couldn't see him being mafia.
But, at the moment he is a best course of action for town to lynch, since he isn't really participating. Ideally I'd like to hear something, but we've got 2 days left and he might have just went on a Christmas holiday.
Although if we just keep lynching inactive people we are surely just gonna die a slow death. I think I'm going to be too busy tomorrow to check this game.
So Vote:cAKE.
And hopefully he says something tomorrow and town can make another decision.
12/27/2018 23:18:26
But with how inactive cAKE has been I couldn't see him being mafia.
But, at the moment he is a best course of action for town to lynch, since he isn't really participating. Ideally I'd like to hear something, but we've got 2 days left and he might have just went on a Christmas holiday.
Although if we just keep lynching inactive people we are surely just gonna die a slow death. I think I'm going to be too busy tomorrow to check this game.
So Vote:cAKE.
And hopefully he says something tomorrow and town can make another decision.
12/27/2018 23:18:26
Hey guys, just read through the thread. I'm going to message everyone who hasn't posted since Christmas to hopefully get this back on track. Again, due to the holiday season I'm happy to extend the deadline if you guys feel you need more time.
12/28/2018 01:30:52
12/28/2018 01:30:52
That would be nice ty.
12/28/2018 04:43:43
12/28/2018 04:43:43
Yes please.
I'd like everyone to post at least once before we decide on a lynch.
Unvote:cAKE
12/28/2018 06:39:19
I'd like everyone to post at least once before we decide on a lynch.
Unvote:cAKE
12/28/2018 06:39:19
Hey guys
Sorry, I forgot about this game over christmas etc., I'll definitley get more active.
Anyway, with this wagon on me I'd like to claim townie. If this lynch happens, we will be four townies down tomorrow and likely in LyLo. (Even if there's only 2 mafia its still a pretty bad spot for town).
I will defend my claim to the grave because it's true and I don't want mafia winning this game due to my inactivity.
Some thoughts. I'd like to point out some notably anti town behaviour from our friend Aerodrome. He doesn't input very much into discussion, (which I admit I'm guilty of) but usually starts or follows wagons on the reasoning of there isn't much time left of the day or sometimes just no reasoning at all. Jeans does the same shit. On the other hand, aero plays like this all the time regardless of faction.
@Glace As for MrL and BD I'll have to read the thread more and I'll get back to you in a couple hours about that, but right now MrL seems more scummy to me than BD.
Probs town: Glace, Exist, Rhyno
Scummy: MrL, Aero
Idk: Atyeo, BD, Jeans
Glace and Rhyno both make often insightful posts and get discussion moving, which I appreciate and is better than just taking shots in the dark or punishing inactivity. Exist is just a hunch but seems to be trying to hunt scum and giving his opinions on events.
Aero is explained above and MrL doesn't really seem ti be actively trying to scum-hunt, more or less just diveritng attention away from himself when it is shined upon him, and then going back to lurking.
Idk about bd and atyeo ill read more wait glace fucking diEd
12/28/2018 07:16:04
Sorry, I forgot about this game over christmas etc., I'll definitley get more active.
Anyway, with this wagon on me I'd like to claim townie. If this lynch happens, we will be four townies down tomorrow and likely in LyLo. (Even if there's only 2 mafia its still a pretty bad spot for town).
I will defend my claim to the grave because it's true and I don't want mafia winning this game due to my inactivity.
Some thoughts. I'd like to point out some notably anti town behaviour from our friend Aerodrome. He doesn't input very much into discussion, (which I admit I'm guilty of) but usually starts or follows wagons on the reasoning of there isn't much time left of the day or sometimes just no reasoning at all. Jeans does the same shit. On the other hand, aero plays like this all the time regardless of faction.
@Glace As for MrL and BD I'll have to read the thread more and I'll get back to you in a couple hours about that, but right now MrL seems more scummy to me than BD.
Probs town: Glace, Exist, Rhyno
Scummy: MrL, Aero
Idk: Atyeo, BD, Jeans
Glace and Rhyno both make often insightful posts and get discussion moving, which I appreciate and is better than just taking shots in the dark or punishing inactivity. Exist is just a hunch but seems to be trying to hunt scum and giving his opinions on events.
Aero is explained above and MrL doesn't really seem ti be actively trying to scum-hunt, more or less just diveritng attention away from himself when it is shined upon him, and then going back to lurking.
Idk about bd and atyeo ill read more wait glace fucking diEd
12/28/2018 07:16:04
I hope you got all the gifts, my gift to you is that I think you're pretty much 100% town now.
Also if that Glace is dead thing is an act, you've got play of the game from me and I'd hate you. (Only if you're mafia)
I like that analysis by the way.
I'm on the fence about Aero at the moment. But doesn't provide a lot of basis behind his actions, not that he really has to I guess. Days ending, better lynch kind of ordeal.
I'm pretty suss of the scuffle between BD and MrLand would like to hear more from both of them. Not going to chuck a vote at the moment since I've voted and then unvoted like 50 times in the past 3 days.
12/28/2018 07:25:22
Also if that Glace is dead thing is an act, you've got play of the game from me and I'd hate you. (Only if you're mafia)
I like that analysis by the way.
I'm on the fence about Aero at the moment. But doesn't provide a lot of basis behind his actions, not that he really has to I guess. Days ending, better lynch kind of ordeal.
I'm pretty suss of the scuffle between BD and MrLand would like to hear more from both of them. Not going to chuck a vote at the moment since I've voted and then unvoted like 50 times in the past 3 days.
12/28/2018 07:25:22
yay cake actually responded :] very glad because that was another LachlanF situation and no thx
I don't rly have anything more to say about MrL, his defense was fine in my book, im still sus af of him (from the stuff i said still) but like that's about it - I could chuck a vote on him but like it doesn't really mean anything rn
Interesting that you said Aero always does that stuff regardless of faction, where jeans doesnt? but then you only had Aero in scummy and not jeans? just seemed weird idk, and lmao ye rip glace
cAKE seems town :]
I guess i'll go over my thoughts on everyone?
Rhyno: Basically leading the pack atm (or at least was), which is always scary when someone is, but it seems somewhat genuine and townlike?
cAKE: is above
Aerodrome: I rly don't like how you play these games LMAO and it's the same for this one, you're always just spamming votes (which is ok i guess) but they're usually with like one word comments which makes me reee. you tend to get active towards the later parts in the game tho and make big plays (for whichever side you're on) so idk what to think D:
Ateyo: You're either town and somewhat busy as of late (aren't we all lmao) or an intelligent mafia who posts well just when is needed, which is scary. I'm probably more leaning toward town tho based on what you say?
MrL: do i need to explain lel, still think he's scum
Exist: definitely town and is just super making sure you dont overstep and seem suss, which is understandable, honestly if you're mafia idm losing to you, you earned it LOOL
Jeans: had like a single good starting analysis of glaces death, and then basically nothing since, pls read everything and then talk <3
My suss list
Suss: MrL
Slightly less suss: Ateyo, jeans
More less suss: Aero, rhyno
seems ok: cake, exist
12/28/2018 12:40:37
I don't rly have anything more to say about MrL, his defense was fine in my book, im still sus af of him (from the stuff i said still) but like that's about it - I could chuck a vote on him but like it doesn't really mean anything rn
Interesting that you said Aero always does that stuff regardless of faction, where jeans doesnt? but then you only had Aero in scummy and not jeans? just seemed weird idk, and lmao ye rip glace
cAKE seems town :]
I guess i'll go over my thoughts on everyone?
Rhyno: Basically leading the pack atm (or at least was), which is always scary when someone is, but it seems somewhat genuine and townlike?
cAKE: is above
Aerodrome: I rly don't like how you play these games LMAO and it's the same for this one, you're always just spamming votes (which is ok i guess) but they're usually with like one word comments which makes me reee. you tend to get active towards the later parts in the game tho and make big plays (for whichever side you're on) so idk what to think D:
Ateyo: You're either town and somewhat busy as of late (aren't we all lmao) or an intelligent mafia who posts well just when is needed, which is scary. I'm probably more leaning toward town tho based on what you say?
MrL: do i need to explain lel, still think he's scum
Exist: definitely town and is just super making sure you dont overstep and seem suss, which is understandable, honestly if you're mafia idm losing to you, you earned it LOOL
Jeans: had like a single good starting analysis of glaces death, and then basically nothing since, pls read everything and then talk <3
My suss list
Suss: MrL
Slightly less suss: Ateyo, jeans
More less suss: Aero, rhyno
seems ok: cake, exist
12/28/2018 12:40:37
cmon Cake you really gonna pull the whole
"what he's reallly dead wow I thought he was aliveee (cant be scum because I wouldve known he was dead btw :) )"
I mean like come the fuck on pretty much 6 posts in a row were all the exact same thing about how glace dying makes certain people suss, which is btw how you got your votes?
How did he miss that?, i'm calling bs this is some cheese meta strats to try and save yourself (either town or mafia might pull this strat btw)
Anyway think of that as you will.
If Day isnt extended then it ends today, hopefully gets extended as I feel way more discussion needs to be made rn and we pretty much had 2 days of zero activity
Ill too do a big write up to get my thoughts out there smile.
Aerodrome-Probably said the least of any player in the game? posts pretty often but says nothing in the them of worth. Is probs under the radar rn in terms of sus levels.
Atyeo- Really he has just asked people to talk a lot and hasnt made much of his own meaningful observations, he's trying to get discussion started which Is good but I'd like to see more original thoughts from him.
BattleDolphin-do people actually think this cutie is mafia? Im yet to see reasonable evidence other than stuff along the lines of 'he's TOO town'
he's budget rhyno pretty much.
cAKE-all his defense was claiming town and calling out aero. he also compares me to aero when I've posted double the text as him and ive only voted twice while aero has voted 5 times? I'd also like to point out he says aero (and me??) bandwagon for no reason. With aero looking through his post history I can see this making sense, but for me not really. I voted lachlan because he's always inactive and unclear, and I gave an entire post before I voted on cake.
Honestly this whole 'jeans does the same shit' is way too cryptic and I dont know what's directed and me and what's direct at aero. Please be more clear with allocations next time and um read the thread also.
Exist-Like I said earlier I hate 'meta' strats but despite this I cant see him not being town.
Mr L-going after budget rhyno is pre ballsy tbh but he also thinks cake is mafia so either they're trying to distance each other (which I cant really see tbh) or the more likely scenario only one of them is mafia and they're trying to get the other most looking sus player killed . It's weird though because both are so sus from doing it, ugh.
Rhyno-towner
12/28/2018 21:31:34
"what he's reallly dead wow I thought he was aliveee (cant be scum because I wouldve known he was dead btw :) )"
I mean like come the fuck on pretty much 6 posts in a row were all the exact same thing about how glace dying makes certain people suss, which is btw how you got your votes?
How did he miss that?, i'm calling bs this is some cheese meta strats to try and save yourself (either town or mafia might pull this strat btw)
Anyway think of that as you will.
If Day isnt extended then it ends today, hopefully gets extended as I feel way more discussion needs to be made rn and we pretty much had 2 days of zero activity
Ill too do a big write up to get my thoughts out there smile.
Aerodrome-Probably said the least of any player in the game? posts pretty often but says nothing in the them of worth. Is probs under the radar rn in terms of sus levels.
Atyeo- Really he has just asked people to talk a lot and hasnt made much of his own meaningful observations, he's trying to get discussion started which Is good but I'd like to see more original thoughts from him.
BattleDolphin-do people actually think this cutie is mafia? Im yet to see reasonable evidence other than stuff along the lines of 'he's TOO town'
he's budget rhyno pretty much.
cAKE-all his defense was claiming town and calling out aero. he also compares me to aero when I've posted double the text as him and ive only voted twice while aero has voted 5 times? I'd also like to point out he says aero (and me??) bandwagon for no reason. With aero looking through his post history I can see this making sense, but for me not really. I voted lachlan because he's always inactive and unclear, and I gave an entire post before I voted on cake.
Honestly this whole 'jeans does the same shit' is way too cryptic and I dont know what's directed and me and what's direct at aero. Please be more clear with allocations next time and um read the thread also.
Exist-Like I said earlier I hate 'meta' strats but despite this I cant see him not being town.
Mr L-going after budget rhyno is pre ballsy tbh but he also thinks cake is mafia so either they're trying to distance each other (which I cant really see tbh) or the more likely scenario only one of them is mafia and they're trying to get the other most looking sus player killed . It's weird though because both are so sus from doing it, ugh.
Rhyno-towner
12/28/2018 21:31:34
Alright, a few people want to see more discussion so I'm extending the day to New Years day (Tuesday).
12/28/2018 23:17:30
12/28/2018 23:17:30
btw mafia my birthday is on the 2nd so if you kill me overnight on my birthday imma be real sad :[
12/29/2018 00:40:32
12/29/2018 00:40:32
god can i just vote for cAKE JEANS BD and MrL at once Unvote because I don't think cAKE is mafia for now, I think he's just a townie not paying attention
If you want my opinion of least suspect to most suspect it's probably:
S (probably town) Tier: Rhyno, Atyeo
A (probably town, but airheaded) Tier: cAKE, Exist
B (trying their best) Tier: BD, JEANS
MrL Tier: MrL
If I HAD to pick a lynch target I would say probably BD or MrL. I don't like the way BD is playing but that's just my gut with no solid reasoning.
12/29/2018 01:35:12
If you want my opinion of least suspect to most suspect it's probably:
S (probably town) Tier: Rhyno, Atyeo
A (probably town, but airheaded) Tier: cAKE, Exist
B (trying their best) Tier: BD, JEANS
MrL Tier: MrL
If I HAD to pick a lynch target I would say probably BD or MrL. I don't like the way BD is playing but that's just my gut with no solid reasoning.
12/29/2018 01:35:12
cAKE said:
Some thoughts. I'd like to point out some notably anti town behaviour from our friend Aerodrome. He doesn't input very much into discussion, (which I admit I'm guilty of) but usually starts or follows wagons on the reasoning of there isn't much time left of the day or sometimes just no reasoning at all. Jeans does the same shit. On the other hand, aero plays like this all the time regardless of faction.
Glace and Rhyno both make often insightful posts and get discussion moving, which I appreciate and is better than just taking shots in the dark or punishing inactivity. Exist is just a hunch but seems to be trying to hunt scum and giving his opinions on events.
Aero is explained above and MrL doesn't really seem ti be actively trying to scum-hunt, more or less just diveritng attention away from himself when it is shined upon him, and then going back to lurking.
Idk about bd and atyeo ill read more wait glace fucking diEd
my own thoughts about this defense, the 'whoops glace died' is either a stupid play or him actually being stupid and not reading anything which is not really how you want to town to play, and it also strengthens my previous post about people doing dumb shit, so really the whoops glace died thing makes me think we were spot on with having noob mafia who dont know what they are doing.
On top of that, literally every single thing he said about each player was exactly what everyone else said and nothing new was added in at all. Thats a pretty classic mafia 'safe' redirection strategy.
All he did was say a lot of words that really meant nothing or added nothing of value, is that all it takes to take the heat off the most suspicious person so far?
As for Aero, he is deffs under the rader and pretty suss there is a decent chance he is mafia, however he's played enough of these to know that if you start being super active smart and useful at the start you get killed off by the mafia, so maybe he is trying to lay low for the first part of the game so that if nothing else he at least gets to play for a bit. I was also quite suspicious of his random voting at first too, that seems like a mafia strat but over the course of this game I've realized that as long as that person has a low vote count so they cant just be insta bandwagon killed, it might actually be beneficial to do this as it targets and puts pressure on a player who might be a mafia, making people squirm under the spotlight is a good way to bait out some mafia slip ups. Just straight up random voting with no explanation isn't good though, and voting them without saying something that they have to defend probably means your pressure vote actually puts no pressure on them at all. If it were on another player doing this I'd be more annoyed but at least we know aero has a brain so it could be based on private observations that he doesn't want to share lest he put a target on himself, but thats the way the game works, you cant win without risk so you should start dropping those observation bombs aero otherwise the case against you is gonna grow pretty quick.
So just to be clear I am not exonerating that behavior based on that, I am just saying that is a possible explanation so lets not jump to conclusions, but I am also saying that Aero needs to stop doing this right now if he is actually town otherwise I am going back on all this.
I would say that Jeans also doing this is way more suspicious because he isnt a sharp minded observer like Aero, except that I actually know absolutely nothing about him, I had never even heard of him before this game, and now that I think about it I dont think he has actually contributed anything at all (previous posts are just reiterating things that have already been said), until just now, so lets look at that shall we because I disagree with a fair portion of his post.
JEANS said:
cmon Cake you really gonna pull the whole
"what he's reallly dead wow I thought he was aliveee (cant be scum because I wouldve known he was dead btw :) )"
I mean like come the fuck on pretty much 6 posts in a row were all the exact same thing about how glace dying makes certain people suss, which is btw how you got your votes? How did he miss that?
This is a good point and is why I think it was a stupid play as I said above.
JEANS said:
Aerodrome-Probably said the least of any player in the game? posts pretty often but says nothing in the them of worth. Is probs under the radar rn in terms of sus levels.
same argument being rehashed again, also I just talked about this a bit in my post just now.
JEANS said:
Atyeo- Really he has just asked people to talk a lot and hasn't made much of his own meaningful observations, he's trying to get discussion started which Is good but I'd like to see more original thoughts from him.
Every single one of my posts has had meaningful observation and original thoughts so... dont know where you are going with that one.
JEANS said:
cAKE-all his defense was claiming town and calling out aero. he also compares me to aero when I've posted double the text as him and ive only voted twice while aero has voted 5 times? I'd also like to point out he says aero (and me??) bandwagon for no reason. With aero looking through his post history I can see this making sense, but for me not really. I voted lachlan because he's always inactive and unclear, and I gave an entire post before I voted on cake.
Honestly this whole 'jeans does the same shit' is way too cryptic and I dont know what's directed and me and what's direct at aero. Please be more clear with allocations next time and um read the thread also.
just throwing it out there I thought 'Jeans does the same shit' is pretty clear and in no way cryptic??? He is saying you dont post often and when you do its just the same thing already being said and nothing new is added, whats cryptic about that?
JEANS said:
Exist-Like I said earlier I hate 'meta' strats but despite this I cant see him not being town.
Its a big stretch for it to be an actual strat, and even if it is it its not necessarily a mafia strat, a good way to keep yourself from getting killed early is to convince the mafia that you are not dangerous and the town that you are not mafia. (I still stand by thought that if he is a mafia he is next level and I will eat my proverbial hat). But going back and looking over he also has kinda just mirrored thoughts and not really said much of anything which is what has made other people stand out as suspicious so why is that behavior only suss on certain people but not others?
JEANS said:
Mr L-going after budget rhyno is pre ballsy tbh but he also thinks cake is mafia so either they're trying to distance each other (which I cant really see tbh) or the more likely scenario only one of them is mafia and they're trying to get the other most looking sus player killed . It's weird though because both are so sus from doing it, ugh.
I do think that if cake is innocent then MrL is almost certainly mafia so I'm with you there, but mafia distancing themselves from each other is exactly what mafia should be doing so I'm not sure why you think that that is unlikely. Budget rhyno is BD, why is that ballsy, reading back over the thread a lot of people were fingering BD, Mr L and cAKE because they were the three that didn't vote day 1, and lots of people mentioned he is suspicious so how is that a ballsy play. Do you know something I dont?
JEANS said:
BattleDolphin-do people actually think this cutie is mafia? Im yet to see reasonable evidence other than stuff along the lines of 'he's TOO town'
he's budget rhyno pretty much.
him not posting night 1 and saying some stock generic town stuff might not be reasonable evidence but this early on there really isn't much of that so any evidence is evidence. But if you are looking for something more, after cake posted what I feel like was a pretty poor defense, he immediately decided that cake is cool and is deffs a townie.
JEANS said:
Rhyno-towner
isn't this exactly the kind of response and reasoning we just just reamed aero for? (I am now dubbing this aeroposting) Furthermore, rhyno also straight away after cakes (imo poor) defense was like oh ok nah cake is cool, kinda suss.
Alright to sum up some thoughts in case tl;dr and to be fair I did let that post get a little messy.
Cake's defense was terrible, his whoops glace thing is unbelievable given that "I mean like come the fuck on pretty much 6 posts in a row were all the exact same thing about how glace dying makes certain people suss, which is btw how you got your votes?" and also that its a totally stupid play, and there has been thoughts in the air of noob mafia who do stupid stuff so that just makes him look worse. Not only that, but his defense was just saying the same stock standard stuff about others, lots of words with no real substance.
the next 2 posts after that were bd (who has been thrown around as a mafia suspect) and rhyno straight away jumping to this bad defense saying that they are now convinced he is town, this is suuuuper suss to me, like what? I find it hard to believe that they thought cakes defensive was genuinely good, so if cake is mafia these two stick out super hard and if he is innocent.
So, if we lynch cake and he is mafia then I think we have got this pretty down pat, and if he is innocent I think that paints MrL as the next likely target.
Also if cake is telling the truth and truly didn't realize glace died then he is either really dumb or just not bothering to read, both of which are not helpful to us in the least.
So yeah I dunno about you but I was already gonna vote cake and his defense has just made me want to do it more, if you feel I am wrong please tell me how his defense exonerates him.
12/29/2018 01:59:59
Wtf I just woke up and there's so many things to read through.
The reason his defense makes me believe he's town is because I don't think he's good enough to make that kind of play. (I know mafia is a 2 man team but the post legit is spaced out in such a way that it seems like he did it on his own after finally reading back on the thread)
He literally did the same thing in another game where he forgot he had to use his night powers and that was his defense. He got killed by the way, turned up town and also had those powers.
So like I said, if he isn't town and actually did it on purpose I'd be pretty shocked and cAKE just earn't a play of the game as mafia.
Also just calling me a pro-towner is a little odd. I'd like maybe a little more analysis on me if anything, I don't really know how to answer that right now other than, thanks?
BD also super scares me, his play is so natural honestly and it's hard to get a good grasp on him. (Happens in previous games too)
But MrL is definitely my most suss at the moment, although he isn't really posting. He kind of just brushed off claims and then went to the next story.
@Atyeo JEANS is Hydropimp if you remember that name better.
Also stop calling people budget Rhyno. >:( I think everyone plays their own unique way.
12/29/2018 02:35:12
The reason his defense makes me believe he's town is because I don't think he's good enough to make that kind of play. (I know mafia is a 2 man team but the post legit is spaced out in such a way that it seems like he did it on his own after finally reading back on the thread)
He literally did the same thing in another game where he forgot he had to use his night powers and that was his defense. He got killed by the way, turned up town and also had those powers.
So like I said, if he isn't town and actually did it on purpose I'd be pretty shocked and cAKE just earn't a play of the game as mafia.
Also just calling me a pro-towner is a little odd. I'd like maybe a little more analysis on me if anything, I don't really know how to answer that right now other than, thanks?
BD also super scares me, his play is so natural honestly and it's hard to get a good grasp on him. (Happens in previous games too)
But MrL is definitely my most suss at the moment, although he isn't really posting. He kind of just brushed off claims and then went to the next story.
@Atyeo JEANS is Hydropimp if you remember that name better.
Also stop calling people budget Rhyno. >:( I think everyone plays their own unique way.
12/29/2018 02:35:12
yeah i just reckon cake definitely forgot about the game and also barely read the damn thread but just wanted to post something
LMAOOO i dont remember this game? my personal reasoning was more leaning towards the game where he had all the mafias names (i was one of them that game) and decided to just call of us out like an idiot LOOL
I highly highly doubt he's mafia, dont get me wrong the defense is crap for a defense i was just happy because confirmed townies are very good :] (i guess he is not as confirmed as i thought lmao)
dang reading through cakes post again again, he says like literally nothing that shows he's read past day 1 lmfao (until the glace died comment obv)
I guess that crap post could be made by mafia but like i doubt the other mafia member would let that slide without anything more, while also not getting him to post for like a week LOL
12/29/2018 05:23:44
Rhyno said:
He literally did the same thing in another game where he forgot he had to use his night powers and that was his defense. He got killed by the way, turned up town and also had those powers.
LMAOOO i dont remember this game? my personal reasoning was more leaning towards the game where he had all the mafias names (i was one of them that game) and decided to just call of us out like an idiot LOOL
I highly highly doubt he's mafia, dont get me wrong the defense is crap for a defense i was just happy because confirmed townies are very good :] (i guess he is not as confirmed as i thought lmao)
dang reading through cakes post again again, he says like literally nothing that shows he's read past day 1 lmfao (until the glace died comment obv)
I guess that crap post could be made by mafia but like i doubt the other mafia member would let that slide without anything more, while also not getting him to post for like a week LOL
12/29/2018 05:23:44
Lynch cake so you’ll be suss of me and then I activate my trap card and you then vote for BD the real mafia by default 😇
Can do a write-up of what I think when I get home but I don’t think I’d add much if anything plus it’d just be seen as a way to deflect the train of thought or something
Might’ve missed something but how is cake confirmed town? and also bd defending him 🤔 not dumb enough to do that if they’re both mafia tho. I think if cake comes up town, bd is mafia and bd isnt mafia if cake is but im bad at this so eh
12/30/2018 06:14:21
Can do a write-up of what I think when I get home but I don’t think I’d add much if anything plus it’d just be seen as a way to deflect the train of thought or something
Might’ve missed something but how is cake confirmed town? and also bd defending him 🤔 not dumb enough to do that if they’re both mafia tho. I think if cake comes up town, bd is mafia and bd isnt mafia if cake is but im bad at this so eh
12/30/2018 06:14:21
Okay, I have not much to input as far as cAKE goes that hasn't been already said. Terrible defence, the wait, Glace is dead tells me that he was unaware of the content of the messages said by players on day 2. This coupled with the fact that he is throwing shade at aero and JEANS(who I now know is hydropimp) while having not read anything from day 2 seems anti-town. This doesn't mean he's mafia. Honestly seems like a terrible mafia play to me, but it's definitely an active detriment to town.
I wish I was mafia at this point. So many people saying that I couldn't possibly be... I do agree with what Atyeo said though. A fair bit of what I've been saying has been the same as what others have said. The cases where I did this, I couldn't fault the logic behind the original post and I felt it necessary to acknowledge that. My question now is why has this not been mentioned until now? What am I saying that makes it so clear that I'm town? That way I can do it when I'm actually mafia.
I'm not sure what to make of the Mr L vs BD situation. Since they are in conflict, my intuition says one of them is likely mafia (this may be Secret Hitler doing the talking so correct me if I'm wrong) but I can't for the life of me figure out which one it is.
I will hold off from my vote for now but I feel like one of these three should definitely be our next choice.
12/30/2018 11:27:38
I wish I was mafia at this point. So many people saying that I couldn't possibly be... I do agree with what Atyeo said though. A fair bit of what I've been saying has been the same as what others have said. The cases where I did this, I couldn't fault the logic behind the original post and I felt it necessary to acknowledge that. My question now is why has this not been mentioned until now? What am I saying that makes it so clear that I'm town? That way I can do it when I'm actually mafia.
I'm not sure what to make of the Mr L vs BD situation. Since they are in conflict, my intuition says one of them is likely mafia (this may be Secret Hitler doing the talking so correct me if I'm wrong) but I can't for the life of me figure out which one it is.
I will hold off from my vote for now but I feel like one of these three should definitely be our next choice.
12/30/2018 11:27:38
I agree that his defense was horrible by the way. I just think it was so silly that he couldn't possibly be mafia kind of thing. (He could probably still be, but yeah.)
MrL feels like he's kind of given up on the game?
But I'd like to ideally see his analysis anyways since it'll give us something to go off of, we have like a day to decide so tomorrow we should decide on someone.
At the moment my list is MrL > cAKE > BD in terms of lynch order since at the moment cAKE and BD seem more willing to play, but some of cAKES messages are just silly at the same time so BD is more assisting to town if he is a townie.
12/30/2018 13:18:07
MrL feels like he's kind of given up on the game?
But I'd like to ideally see his analysis anyways since it'll give us something to go off of, we have like a day to decide so tomorrow we should decide on someone.
At the moment my list is MrL > cAKE > BD in terms of lynch order since at the moment cAKE and BD seem more willing to play, but some of cAKES messages are just silly at the same time so BD is more assisting to town if he is a townie.
12/30/2018 13:18:07
Been busy and no laptop is a pain in the ass, will try to find time tomorrow
12/30/2018 14:34:44
12/30/2018 14:34:44
I'll Vote:MrL for the moment until he does his write-up.
With his laptop broken it seems he won't be able to commit much to the game and he has been showing signs of anti-town.
If his write up is good however I'll change my mind to cAKE since he already has 3 votes and doesn't offer a lot to the game in terms of play. FYI I might not be around tonight to commit to a vote.
And if it goes late until tomorrow I won't be around till like 2pm+ probably. Nvm cAKE only has 1 vote now. Didn't realise.
12/31/2018 04:03:54
With his laptop broken it seems he won't be able to commit much to the game and he has been showing signs of anti-town.
If his write up is good however I'll change my mind to cAKE since he already has 3 votes and doesn't offer a lot to the game in terms of play. FYI I might not be around tonight to commit to a vote.
And if it goes late until tomorrow I won't be around till like 2pm+ probably. Nvm cAKE only has 1 vote now. Didn't realise.
12/31/2018 04:03:54