Vote: No lynch
So someone is mafia but we might as well guess with 3 people left rather than 4 people left right.
8 years ago
Did you figure out was Lucas is at all Ghost? i dont remember
VOTE: No lynch either way i totally agree
8 years ago
VOTE: No lynch either way i totally agree
8 years ago
I don't think Ghost ever investigated me so I'm curious if you have
8 years ago
8 years ago
Yea Lucas is vanilla, investigated him last night.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Hmm ok, it is kinda weird that the mafia is probably vanilla, because that means the mafia basically relies on their JOAT for any powers during the night, so that makes me lean towards ghost being mafia (not voting him now ofc tomorrow is crunch time :| )
but then also the fact that he pushed Hydro quite hard yesterday makes me think he's not mafia
but then also also there's the fact that hydro didn't really defend so maybe the plan was ghost just carry through this sequence because he seems super innocent by lynching hydro as i said above, and ghost is well capable of this play imo
just my thoughts rly we should only do no lynch today anyway
8 years ago
but then also the fact that he pushed Hydro quite hard yesterday makes me think he's not mafia
but then also also there's the fact that hydro didn't really defend so maybe the plan was ghost just carry through this sequence because he seems super innocent by lynching hydro as i said above, and ghost is well capable of this play imo
just my thoughts rly we should only do no lynch today anyway
8 years ago
Will make a post later about what battledolphin said
8 years ago
8 years ago
Ooh exciting
8 years ago
8 years ago
BattleDolphin said:
Ooh exciting
8 years ago
??
8 years ago
8 years ago
Still waiting on Maribro's post...
8 years ago
8 years ago
ikr lol
8 years ago
8 years ago
He really did mean later
8 years ago
8 years ago
Alright I'm tired and it's late so I'm gonna do this post.
Given that town had the following:
Gunsmith (basically a cop given there's no SK, possible there's some jank investigation proofing going on)
Masons (basically two confirmed townies)
Watcher (OP af role but Aerodrome is self-confirmed bad)
Courier (if JLo played his cards right he coulda easily confirmed himself town but ended up killing himself with his claim instead)
Odd night Doc
Mafia:
JoaT
Vanilla
Backup (basically vanilla until JOAT dies and is essentially just a vanilla if they die before JoaT)
It just seems like a fairly unfavourable setup for Mafia. Would make way more sense if they had a rolecop… It's possible maf just has some weird OP role with rolecop investigation proofing or something but it's probably more likely that Ghost is a mafia rolecop. Only thing I don't like is that BD brought this up today rather than tomorrow cos before saying that, imo Ghost was the most likely person to be targeted by mafia. Would have been setting off alarm bells if he lived this night if it were me and so he would have been the obvious lynch. Now it's more of a 50/50. Vote: No Lynch
8 years ago
Given that town had the following:
Gunsmith (basically a cop given there's no SK, possible there's some jank investigation proofing going on)
Masons (basically two confirmed townies)
Watcher (OP af role but Aerodrome is self-confirmed bad)
Courier (if JLo played his cards right he coulda easily confirmed himself town but ended up killing himself with his claim instead)
Odd night Doc
Mafia:
JoaT
Vanilla
Backup (basically vanilla until JOAT dies and is essentially just a vanilla if they die before JoaT)
It just seems like a fairly unfavourable setup for Mafia. Would make way more sense if they had a rolecop… It's possible maf just has some weird OP role with rolecop investigation proofing or something but it's probably more likely that Ghost is a mafia rolecop. Only thing I don't like is that BD brought this up today rather than tomorrow cos before saying that, imo Ghost was the most likely person to be targeted by mafia. Would have been setting off alarm bells if he lived this night if it were me and so he would have been the obvious lynch. Now it's more of a 50/50. Vote: No Lynch
8 years ago
A majority has been met.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Gonna write a reasonable post in my defense hopefully thread doesn't close lol
8 years ago
8 years ago
Well I'm a nice guy so Ghost's next post will be the last of the day
8 years ago
8 years ago
If we're going into game balance, my role isn't actually that effective considering I can't prove anyone is mafia or not (aside from doctor once we know there's no SK, and probably courier can be assumed town), and I'm sure the mods considered that.
Plus if laggy wasn't mafia and didn't just instantly die mafia would have been inherently in a much stronger position all game. So I think our perspectives on what's a fair distribution of power roles is probably off.
A bit more in my defense is that a gunsmith is basically a cop clone without a town cop or vig to make the role slightly less effective. However it's true that town doesn't actually know whether they have a vig or cop or not so mafia can claim these roles in response to an accusation (while Miller roles are the equivalent for regular cop), so I guess it comes down to whether you think the mods are trying to mindgame us or not.
Plus if I was mafia then it's strange they mostly hit vanillas before everyone claimed. (A mafia with rolecop probably wouldn't waste extra kills firing blindly night 1). Since I investigated MrL night 1 it would have been easy to kill him night 2 or just let him get himself lynched day 3 which was the probable outcome considering all his inconsistencies. (And you can tell I was trying to nudge people away from voting MrL for a while before I had to claim)
8 years ago
Plus if laggy wasn't mafia and didn't just instantly die mafia would have been inherently in a much stronger position all game. So I think our perspectives on what's a fair distribution of power roles is probably off.
A bit more in my defense is that a gunsmith is basically a cop clone without a town cop or vig to make the role slightly less effective. However it's true that town doesn't actually know whether they have a vig or cop or not so mafia can claim these roles in response to an accusation (while Miller roles are the equivalent for regular cop), so I guess it comes down to whether you think the mods are trying to mindgame us or not.
Plus if I was mafia then it's strange they mostly hit vanillas before everyone claimed. (A mafia with rolecop probably wouldn't waste extra kills firing blindly night 1). Since I investigated MrL night 1 it would have been easy to kill him night 2 or just let him get himself lynched day 3 which was the probable outcome considering all his inconsistencies. (And you can tell I was trying to nudge people away from voting MrL for a while before I had to claim)
8 years ago
Day 6 has concluded. No lynch has taken place.
Night 6 begins. Those with night actions, please send them to a moderator as quickly as possible. Night 6 has concluded. No deaths have taken place.
Day 7 begins. With 4 alive it takes 3 to lynch.
8 years ago
Night 6 begins. Those with night actions, please send them to a moderator as quickly as possible. Night 6 has concluded. No deaths have taken place.
Day 7 begins. With 4 alive it takes 3 to lynch.
8 years ago
Man someone is memeing hard right now and Idk who it is. Still, optimal play is to
Vote: No lynch
8 years ago
Vote: No lynch
8 years ago
Vote: No lynch
I agree with Maribro
8 years ago
I agree with Maribro
8 years ago
Lol if both the mafia and town want to win this will technically never end right
it's still the play tho
Vote: No Lynch
8 years ago
it's still the play tho
Vote: No Lynch
8 years ago
A majority had been met. Day 7 has concluded. No lynch has taken place.
Night 7 begins. Those with night actions, please send them to a moderator as quickly as possible. Night 7 had concluded. No kill has taken place.
As such, we have reached a stalemate where it's in town's best interests to not lynch during the day and it's in mafia's best interests to not kill during the night.
I did a bit of research on the situation, and we would like to suggest the following:
We will offer the players an opportunity for a draw. Please message a moderator as to whether or not you will accept a draw.
If a majority will not accept a draw and would like to see the game conclude, we will randomly force either town or mafia to make a kill to break this stalemate.
Please message us your decision as quickly as possible. Just one player we haven't heard from. Please message us as soon as you can. A majority was reached and the game ends in a draw. Everyone wins! Everyone loses? Town and mafia learn to hold hands and get along, ignoring the pile of bodies behind them.
Maribro, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
LuminousLucas, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
BattleDolphin, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
Ghostbone, Mafia Rolecop, has been endgamed.
Dead player chat: https://discord.gg/umrmX
Mafia chat: https://discord.gg/sXwaScH
Masonry: https://discord.gg/EJnD3MF
8 years ago
Night 7 begins. Those with night actions, please send them to a moderator as quickly as possible. Night 7 had concluded. No kill has taken place.
As such, we have reached a stalemate where it's in town's best interests to not lynch during the day and it's in mafia's best interests to not kill during the night.
I did a bit of research on the situation, and we would like to suggest the following:
We will offer the players an opportunity for a draw. Please message a moderator as to whether or not you will accept a draw.
If a majority will not accept a draw and would like to see the game conclude, we will randomly force either town or mafia to make a kill to break this stalemate.
Please message us your decision as quickly as possible. Just one player we haven't heard from. Please message us as soon as you can. A majority was reached and the game ends in a draw. Everyone wins! Everyone loses? Town and mafia learn to hold hands and get along, ignoring the pile of bodies behind them.
Maribro, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
LuminousLucas, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
BattleDolphin, Vanilla Townie, has been endgamed.
Ghostbone, Mafia Rolecop, has been endgamed.
Dead player chat: https://discord.gg/umrmX
Mafia chat: https://discord.gg/sXwaScH
Masonry: https://discord.gg/EJnD3MF
8 years ago
clapclapclapclapclapclap
8 years ago
8 years ago
ye okay it's my game time now so nobody try to still my show if you havn't played botw then you shouldnt care there wont be any 'major' spoilers.
8 years ago
8 years ago
A draw is as good as a loss
8 years ago
8 years ago