post tallies are good, but what's even better was the f word tally i was keeping
i don't really mind if it helps mafia because the more discussion the better, even if it is mafia driven deez was also shit and deserved to be lynched, so the post count indicates something
02/23/2016 08:32:14
Quality not quantity
02/23/2016 08:36:04
02/23/2016 08:36:04
Insane theory time:
There exists a vigilante and a serial killer. The vigilante has stale move negation the serial killer?
Must charge waft. That's my best guess for why there was no kill night one.
But that's just a theory... A smash Mafia game theory
02/23/2016 08:45:05
There exists a vigilante and a serial killer. The vigilante has stale move negation the serial killer?
Must charge waft. That's my best guess for why there was no kill night one.
But that's just a theory... A smash Mafia game theory
02/23/2016 08:45:05
okay enough theory, im the cop i investigated jlo last night and saw he was anti-town.
02/23/2016 08:48:17
02/23/2016 08:48:17
HydroPimp said:Did dean specify what faction he was part of or did he just say anti-town?
okay enough theory, im the cop i investigated jlo last night and saw he was anti-town.
02/23/2016 08:52:43
Windkeeper0 said:
HydroPimp said:Did dean specify what faction he was part of or did he just say anti-town?
okay enough theory, im the cop i investigated jlo last night and saw he was anti-town.
anti-town
02/23/2016 08:53:53
Oh.
02/23/2016 08:55:34
02/23/2016 08:55:34
and why do we believe you?
02/23/2016 08:55:44
02/23/2016 08:55:44
I am voting Shoutouts to Urisk
02/23/2016 08:56:17
02/23/2016 08:56:17
that's a shit claim, i'm out for a couple of hours pls don't lynch anyone
02/23/2016 09:06:05
02/23/2016 09:06:05
Vote: HydroPimp
You messed up fam.
You were always targeting me from the very start of the game, and maybe this would have led somewhere. But your latest post just screwed you over.
I've been doubtful of Maribro's claim as JOAT, but with this there's no doubt in my mind that you are Mafia. He claims that I didn't target anyone Night 1, and it's because I'm a Vanilla Townie.
The way you worded your post is peculiar: why not outright say that I am Mafia? Why say that I am anti-town? It's simple: because you are lying. Your accusation is very shaky, and calling the fake cop claim is a high risk play as I mentioned earlier. Unfortunately it's not going to work since there's more evidence corroborating my innocence than guilt.
You're going down fam
02/23/2016 09:08:23
You messed up fam.
You were always targeting me from the very start of the game, and maybe this would have led somewhere. But your latest post just screwed you over.
I've been doubtful of Maribro's claim as JOAT, but with this there's no doubt in my mind that you are Mafia. He claims that I didn't target anyone Night 1, and it's because I'm a Vanilla Townie.
The way you worded your post is peculiar: why not outright say that I am Mafia? Why say that I am anti-town? It's simple: because you are lying. Your accusation is very shaky, and calling the fake cop claim is a high risk play as I mentioned earlier. Unfortunately it's not going to work since there's more evidence corroborating my innocence than guilt.
You're going down fam
02/23/2016 09:08:23
Just in response of some people that are suspicious of my claim, and why I tried to kill Corvid on the first night:
I decided I wanted to help town and kill Corvid night 1. Corvid was being anti-town from the start of the game and I had 4 or 5 votes at one point. I was worried that someone would lynch me the next day or the Mafia would kill me and I wouldn't be able to use my power so I wouldn't help the town at all. I'm also not the best at Mafia although honestly this isn't really an excuse.
I had no way of knowing for sure that Laggy was Mafia, but if I was Mafia, why would I vote for my own team on Day 1 when he was so valuable?
02/23/2016 09:09:09
I decided I wanted to help town and kill Corvid night 1. Corvid was being anti-town from the start of the game and I had 4 or 5 votes at one point. I was worried that someone would lynch me the next day or the Mafia would kill me and I wouldn't be able to use my power so I wouldn't help the town at all. I'm also not the best at Mafia although honestly this isn't really an excuse.
I had no way of knowing for sure that Laggy was Mafia, but if I was Mafia, why would I vote for my own team on Day 1 when he was so valuable?
02/23/2016 09:09:09
With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch!
Votes:
JLo (0)
Wooy (0)
Aerodrome (0)
Maribro (0)
LEF (0)
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Pazx (0)
Corvid (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
HydroPimp (2) - LEF, JLo
Invisi (0)
Urisk (0)
No lynch (0)
Not voted (10) - Wooy, Maribro, Barrydabusdriver, Pazx, Corvid, Windkeeper0, HydroPimp, Invisi, Urisk, Aerodrome
02/23/2016 09:21:02
Votes:
JLo (0)
Wooy (0)
Aerodrome (0)
Maribro (0)
LEF (0)
Barrydabusdriver (0)
Pazx (0)
Corvid (0)
Windkeeper0 (0)
HydroPimp (2) - LEF, JLo
Invisi (0)
Urisk (0)
No lynch (0)
Not voted (10) - Wooy, Maribro, Barrydabusdriver, Pazx, Corvid, Windkeeper0, HydroPimp, Invisi, Urisk, Aerodrome
02/23/2016 09:21:02
Im sorry I haven't been talking much but I have been keeping up with the thread, I haven't been talking much because at this point I think everyone is abit hazy on whats going on and I honestly am not sure how to contribute because im confused myself. However I would like to point out that after Hydros claim, fake or real, Jlo immediately whent on the offensive shutting down his information with pazx shut down Hydros claim without a second thought saying, "that's a shit claim, i'm out for a couple of hours pls don't lynch anyone" respectively. In my eyes without even investigating the accusation further this comes off as abit suspicious.
02/23/2016 09:24:10
02/23/2016 09:24:10
@town
look very very closely at my first post on day one, and you will understand. full post soon. still wanna hear from corvid tho.
02/23/2016 09:24:19
look very very closely at my first post on day one, and you will understand. full post soon. still wanna hear from corvid tho.
02/23/2016 09:24:19
Hydro why would you claim cop when there is already an allegation going on between wooy and Corvid?
02/23/2016 09:27:46
02/23/2016 09:27:46
JLo said:
The way you worded your post is peculiar: why not outright say that I am Mafia? Why say that I am anti-town?
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Cop#Sample_Role_PM
Because i literally dont know if you are mafia or someother anti town role. Only 3 results are possible, Town, Antitown or No result.
02/23/2016 09:31:01
HydroPimp said:
JLo said:
The way you worded your post is peculiar: why not outright say that I am Mafia? Why say that I am anti-town?
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Cop#Sample_Role_PM
Because i literally dont know if you are mafia or someother anti town role. Only 3 results are possible, Town, Antitown or No result.
Hmm...
Interesting
02/23/2016 09:39:13
Corvid is probably just lurking, maybe he's mafia again and knows he's in trouble again and is just stalling for time.
Not sure what I think about HydroPimp's claim, but JLo's savage response indicates that he hit a nerve somewhere.
For the record I believe Wooy and Maribro are town.
02/23/2016 09:47:51
Not sure what I think about HydroPimp's claim, but JLo's savage response indicates that he hit a nerve somewhere.
For the record I believe Wooy and Maribro are town.
02/23/2016 09:47:51
Aerodrome said:
Corvid is probably just lurking, maybe he's mafia again and knows he's in trouble again and is just stalling for time.
Not sure what I think about HydroPimp's claim, but JLo's savage response indicates that he hit a nerve somewhere.
For the record I believe Wooy and Maribro are town.
I'm not usually this vocal, but when HydroPimp made his cop claim, I know he screwed and revealed to me that he's Mafia. I guess the issue is that I need to convince the rest of you guys that he's scum and I am what I claim I am (a townie).
If you're doubtful of my claim towards HydroPimp, a possible play here is that you lynch one of us and then Maribro/ Wooy shoots the other one if you end up lynching a townie. *he screwed up
dammit i really need to proofread my stuff
02/23/2016 09:56:55
I don't think we have enough information yet to say anything about Hydro/JLo apart from that they are clearly on opposite teams. Anything they say about each other isn't going to change this.
If Hydro is telling the truth, I'm not sure I agree with his play, but perhaps it could be due to inexperience. That said, if it gets the town to lynch a mafia and have the doctor protect him, perhaps it could be worth it?
If he's mafia, I'm not sure why he'd make that play - I don't know what the mafia would have to gain by singling out JLo, especially when he is most likely a vanilla townie with a number of power roles left.
I think we should wait in case there's someone who knows something about one of these two to chime in and help us break this deadlock.
02/23/2016 09:57:19
If Hydro is telling the truth, I'm not sure I agree with his play, but perhaps it could be due to inexperience. That said, if it gets the town to lynch a mafia and have the doctor protect him, perhaps it could be worth it?
If he's mafia, I'm not sure why he'd make that play - I don't know what the mafia would have to gain by singling out JLo, especially when he is most likely a vanilla townie with a number of power roles left.
I think we should wait in case there's someone who knows something about one of these two to chime in and help us break this deadlock.
02/23/2016 09:57:19
Who likes capital letters? I've bolded them for emphasis, and I can finally stop typing entirely in lowercase!
I am Pikachu, Town Cop.
Better yet, I have TWO living investigation results, one town and one anti town. Hydropimp is the anti town. Get rekt kiddo.
HERE'S WHAT I THINK WE SHOULD DO.
DAY THREE: we lynch somebody who is suspicious, like maaaaaybe CORVID? We shouldn't lynch Hydro, not yet, he's still valuable, as he can provide us with information about Wooy and Maribro.
NIGHT THREE: Doctor protects me, obviously. WOOY and MARIBRO both target Hydropimp, in an attempt to get him killed and bypass the mafia roleblocker (that probably exists, thanks to the wooy/corvid interaction). If Hydro is alive on day 4, we lynch Maribro/Wooy, but I think this is unlikely.
This game is as good as won. Ball's in Corvid's court.
02/23/2016 10:06:42
Pazx said:
@everyone please don't lynch yourself, unless you're mafia, in which case tyvm
my previous experience playing mafia is the previous game on this site, in which i didn't accomplish very much. hopefully everyone is a little more proactive this game, so we don't have strong town figures getting night killed straight away. I've also played werewolf which is similar to Mafia, but the version i played only had one day and one night.
Also, don't think the most useless towny is a good lynch for day 1, we certainly don't want them alive at the end of the game but we don't gain much out of lynching them just yet. Come day 2 or 3 ill be more interesting in lynching super bad town players, with 16 of us we probably have that sort of leeway. tl;dr if you don't want to die, be pro town.
pre-emptive "bad town" list (could be more could be less):
laggy
lef (soz)
deez ( Our hero, hammered the final mafioso last game)
cake
maybe corvid for similar reasons to lef, although his selfless sacrifice was very pro-town when you think about it
vote: invisi
i will unvote you if you come to canberra on sunday. bring elo : P
I am Pikachu, Town Cop.
Better yet, I have TWO living investigation results, one town and one anti town. Hydropimp is the anti town. Get rekt kiddo.
HERE'S WHAT I THINK WE SHOULD DO.
DAY THREE: we lynch somebody who is suspicious, like maaaaaybe CORVID? We shouldn't lynch Hydro, not yet, he's still valuable, as he can provide us with information about Wooy and Maribro.
NIGHT THREE: Doctor protects me, obviously. WOOY and MARIBRO both target Hydropimp, in an attempt to get him killed and bypass the mafia roleblocker (that probably exists, thanks to the wooy/corvid interaction). If Hydro is alive on day 4, we lynch Maribro/Wooy, but I think this is unlikely.
This game is as good as won. Ball's in Corvid's court.
02/23/2016 10:06:42
During the first night, I put Wooy to sleep for I am JigglyPuff. Each night I can use Rest to put someone to sleep and prevent them from completing their night action.
I didn't really have a reason to pick any specific player so I opted for wooy as he was one of the newer players who added at least slightly to the conversation day 1.
Well that's poor timing to come out as a town roleblocker :/
02/23/2016 10:10:07
I didn't really have a reason to pick any specific player so I opted for wooy as he was one of the newer players who added at least slightly to the conversation day 1.
Urisk said:
During the first night, I put Wooy to sleep for I am JigglyPuff. Each night I can use Rest to put someone to sleep and prevent them from completing their night action.
I didn't really have a reason to pick any specific player so I opted for wooy as he was one of the newer players who added at least slightly to the conversation day 1.
Well that's poor timing to come out as a town roleblocker :/
02/23/2016 10:10:07
LOL WTF PAZX and asif you get Cop twice in a row lol
02/23/2016 10:11:35
02/23/2016 10:11:35
everyone is just coming out
02/23/2016 10:16:27
02/23/2016 10:16:27