InsertName said:
ok, i have a role but i don't want to say
All good man, cheers for clarifying.
12/23/2016 08:44:55
All good man, cheers for clarifying.
12/23/2016 08:44:55
Since nobody is speaking up to say they don't have a role, it's very likely safe for us to assume that everyone does indeed have one.
Mafia likely had a strongman so they could go through the multiple protection rolls or NK immune rolls in this game, so as town we're probably in a very good position already. roles*
12/23/2016 12:53:05
Mafia likely had a strongman so they could go through the multiple protection rolls or NK immune rolls in this game, so as town we're probably in a very good position already. roles*
12/23/2016 12:53:05
Duon's always been this way (based on my little experience with him in the last Mafia game) but I'm not liking his aggressive reckless attitude. He's been fairly quiet not saying much, but he made sure to secure Lachlan at L1 before his hammer.
I would like to at least see more from you.
Vote: Duon
At the moment I'm still too inexperienced to know night kill options. However, I'd also say we are likely to have an SK who targetted Mr. L
Then Mafia didn't get a kill because of one of the many aforementioned reasons that people have been theorising.
Also here's a meme vote before switching back to Duon.
Vote: Whoever held up night phase for the full 48 hours
What a broken vote, easy win tbh, better nerf it mods ;)
12/23/2016 13:20:35
I would like to at least see more from you.
Vote: Duon
At the moment I'm still too inexperienced to know night kill options. However, I'd also say we are likely to have an SK who targetted Mr. L
Then Mafia didn't get a kill because of one of the many aforementioned reasons that people have been theorising.
Also here's a meme vote before switching back to Duon.
Vote: Whoever held up night phase for the full 48 hours
What a broken vote, easy win tbh, better nerf it mods ;)
12/23/2016 13:20:35
I'm pretty sure that MrL only really called out me so he could get Day 1 over with quickly by starting a bandwagon, which would also explain why he jumped onto LachlanF. I dont think seeing me as the SK is too big of a stretch but more than just him were banking on me getting Lynched Day 1, im being made to look like an SK because of MrL's actions the previous day. I'm not 100% sure about Murkiri and Insert being aligned town just yet, mainly for the fact that they could be mafia but its nothing more than a second thought.
12/23/2016 13:50:30
12/23/2016 13:50:30
Yes I'm very sure MrL only called you out so he could lynch someone random on Day 1.
But the point is the SK might have felt pressured by MrL, and the other people he targeted were Lachlan (dead), Murkiri (Town) and yourself.
Murkiri is almost certainly town btw, him and Insert would have to be mafia together otherwise, and MrL was mafia and was targeting Murkiri on day 1.
12/23/2016 14:07:47
But the point is the SK might have felt pressured by MrL, and the other people he targeted were Lachlan (dead), Murkiri (Town) and yourself.
Murkiri is almost certainly town btw, him and Insert would have to be mafia together otherwise, and MrL was mafia and was targeting Murkiri on day 1.
12/23/2016 14:07:47
I feel like Corvid is most likely the SK because of the reasoning that everyone has established, but I also feel like it's not concrete. If the SK isn't Corvid, it could very well be someone who tried to cover their tracks by killing off MrL so that it would look like Corvid is to blame. Either that or the SK isn't Corvid and this is just a big coincidence.
Also, in response to Corvid saying that MrL was starting bandwagons to get the day over with, that may be so, but you can't act like you're 100% clean either. You were being inactive and generally unhelpful. If you're town, you're gonna have to prove it by exhibiting more pro-town behavior.
12/24/2016 00:44:50
Also, in response to Corvid saying that MrL was starting bandwagons to get the day over with, that may be so, but you can't act like you're 100% clean either. You were being inactive and generally unhelpful. If you're town, you're gonna have to prove it by exhibiting more pro-town behavior.
12/24/2016 00:44:50
Agree that Insert and Murkiri are probably town at this stage, mostly because if one of them dies for any reason (not unlikely with a probable serial killer) the other is 100% confirmed mafia and I don't think maf would take this risk.
LuminescentLucas stuck out to me on the last page, apart from Corvid historically being an easy lynch and like usual lurking a lot there wouldn't have been any reason for MrL to go after Corvid in particular. No one had any information in Day 1.
What can I say, it feels like maf have crafted a theory that Corvid is SK after MrL's night death and have tried to crack down on him. When:
A) I would be surprised a serial killer exists that kills a player highly suspicious of them, since this paints them in a terrible light
2) I reckon we stand to gain much more from having a look at MrL's post history since he has guaranteed teammates, and
III) Serial killer isn't top priority for town right now, as although we have to lynch him at SOME stage they are harder to track and can also hit mafia (as proven by last night), but mafia would be very keen to lynch them as they usually have some degree of bulletproof so mafia can't kill them the usual way
BUT I'm probably reading too much into things once again.
12/24/2016 01:02:17
LuminescentLucas stuck out to me on the last page, apart from Corvid historically being an easy lynch and like usual lurking a lot there wouldn't have been any reason for MrL to go after Corvid in particular. No one had any information in Day 1.
What can I say, it feels like maf have crafted a theory that Corvid is SK after MrL's night death and have tried to crack down on him. When:
A) I would be surprised a serial killer exists that kills a player highly suspicious of them, since this paints them in a terrible light
2) I reckon we stand to gain much more from having a look at MrL's post history since he has guaranteed teammates, and
III) Serial killer isn't top priority for town right now, as although we have to lynch him at SOME stage they are harder to track and can also hit mafia (as proven by last night), but mafia would be very keen to lynch them as they usually have some degree of bulletproof so mafia can't kill them the usual way
BUT I'm probably reading too much into things once again.
12/24/2016 01:02:17
AutumnWind's new NewZealand Australian name confuses me :D
12/24/2016 01:20:03
12/24/2016 01:20:03
cjeccjec said:PM me if you actually care about why I changed my name because I'd rather not bother everyone in this thread.
AutumnWind's new NewZealand Australian name confuses me :D
12/24/2016 01:48:18
I agree that Murkiri and Insert are most likely town with how early it is in the game. I agree with Cj on Duon that he has been acting a bit odd. I want to see more from him at this point.
Vote:Duon
12/24/2016 02:08:35
Vote:Duon
12/24/2016 02:08:35
Windkeeper0 said:I agree.
I agree that Murkiri and Insert are most likely town with how early it is in the game. I agree with Cj on Duon that he has been acting a bit odd. I want to see more from him at this point.
Vote:Duon
VOTE: Duon
12/24/2016 02:40:38
dean said:
LuminescentLucas stuck out to me on the last page, apart from Corvid historically being an easy lynch and like usual lurking a lot there wouldn't have been any reason for MrL to go after Corvid in particular.
LuminescentLucas? C'mon dean...
I did say that MrL may of targeted Corvid just to get a mislynch. And now the Mafia have basically made them look like SK/third party killer.
12/24/2016 03:32:54
It seems I have been called out on some suspicious activity that I may have done.
Alas, friends I am here to clarify, and post my opinions on this rather interesting game.
Firstly, anything I said on day one was in frustration that the day hadn't ended yet. It simply got boring pointing fingers at the same people over and over again. I am happy with the result that the day has brought us, seeing as Lachlan was useless and a townie didn't die overnight, so I guess the 16 page day one wasn't a complete waste.
As for the whole "no townie death day 2" scenario we've been put into. I can't explain it LOL, I don't think anyone can rightfully look at this situation and do so (unless they were involved with the altercation i.e they role blocked a certain person) Its kinda damn lucky and also a shame because there are no major leads going into day two.
I actually have zero hard reads atm (I wasn't very good at it anyway LOL) but a few points I'd like to raise
- Insie is not a dumby, he knows this game and his decisions are thought out carefully. I don't think his "I don't have a role, oh wait yes I do" thing was a slip up, but this isn't entirely a normal process to go through when being asked if they have a role or not, kinda ehh I dunno, just an observation. Also would not be surprised if both Insie & Murkiri are maf. Mr L was not a stupid player. Aiming Murkiri day one to avoid suspicion later isn't something thats impossible.
- Bijou being kinda weird (similar to myself except more vocal)
- Laggys still alive, what a game
- The Corvid SK theory is looking pretty solid. Getting rid of corvid early wouldn't be a complete hindrance to the town, so that could be a safe lynch opportunity (remember we're already super ahead with the maf lynch + no towny loss)
I guess thats it, Ima pressure Corvid a bit more. Mods pls update votes, I didn't know I had 3 on me haha
Vote: Corvid
12/24/2016 03:39:49
Alas, friends I am here to clarify, and post my opinions on this rather interesting game.
Firstly, anything I said on day one was in frustration that the day hadn't ended yet. It simply got boring pointing fingers at the same people over and over again. I am happy with the result that the day has brought us, seeing as Lachlan was useless and a townie didn't die overnight, so I guess the 16 page day one wasn't a complete waste.
As for the whole "no townie death day 2" scenario we've been put into. I can't explain it LOL, I don't think anyone can rightfully look at this situation and do so (unless they were involved with the altercation i.e they role blocked a certain person) Its kinda damn lucky and also a shame because there are no major leads going into day two.
I actually have zero hard reads atm (I wasn't very good at it anyway LOL) but a few points I'd like to raise
- Insie is not a dumby, he knows this game and his decisions are thought out carefully. I don't think his "I don't have a role, oh wait yes I do" thing was a slip up, but this isn't entirely a normal process to go through when being asked if they have a role or not, kinda ehh I dunno, just an observation. Also would not be surprised if both Insie & Murkiri are maf. Mr L was not a stupid player. Aiming Murkiri day one to avoid suspicion later isn't something thats impossible.
- Bijou being kinda weird (similar to myself except more vocal)
- Laggys still alive, what a game
- The Corvid SK theory is looking pretty solid. Getting rid of corvid early wouldn't be a complete hindrance to the town, so that could be a safe lynch opportunity (remember we're already super ahead with the maf lynch + no towny loss)
I guess thats it, Ima pressure Corvid a bit more. Mods pls update votes, I didn't know I had 3 on me haha
Vote: Corvid
12/24/2016 03:39:49
Just a post to let everyone know I'm here. As I'm sure some of you have been aware, there's been some fairly major shit going down in the Perth smash community that I've been a fairly major part of so I haven't really been able/felt okay to post lately. I'll review everything that's happened again and try to write something half decent. Apologies for my inactivity but I'm sure you all understand.
12/24/2016 03:47:00
12/24/2016 03:47:00
I said i was vanilla townie because i thought it would just be simpler, but i forgot that people were also discussing whether or not most people have a role. i should have probably said nothing about my role
12/24/2016 03:51:01
12/24/2016 03:51:01
Maribro said:It's OK, don't sweat it.
Just a post to let everyone know I'm here. As I'm sure some of you have been aware, there's been some fairly major shit going down in the Perth smash community that I've been a fairly major part of so I haven't really been able/felt okay to post lately. I'll review everything that's happened again and try to write something half decent. Apologies for my inactivity but I'm sure you all understand.
12/24/2016 03:56:10
Hi all. I have just arrived at my grandparents' place where I will be spending Christmas. They don't have a computer or internet, so I'm on mobile. I'm not sure how long I'll be staying here, but probably will come home mid next week. I will be mostly inactive until then. Mobile QLDsmash keeps minimising my keyboard. Bear with me... Okay, I'm typing this in another program and copy-pasting, lol.
I read through the last page. I don't have much to say on Corvid because I still haven't had time to check anyone's post history.
Insert and Murkiri's story checks out so far. Insert claiming vanilla makes sense. Claiming to have a power role before you have any info to share does nothing except paint a target on your head for the mafia.
Insert's probably going to be a prime target now anyway, because he is likely town so his accusations hold more weight. (Subtle hint to the protective roles out there).
We also can't confirm them to be town just yet. An investigation on one of them would be useful since it's essentially a 2-for-1 result.
12/24/2016 04:47:32
I read through the last page. I don't have much to say on Corvid because I still haven't had time to check anyone's post history.
Insert and Murkiri's story checks out so far. Insert claiming vanilla makes sense. Claiming to have a power role before you have any info to share does nothing except paint a target on your head for the mafia.
Insert's probably going to be a prime target now anyway, because he is likely town so his accusations hold more weight. (Subtle hint to the protective roles out there).
We also can't confirm them to be town just yet. An investigation on one of them would be useful since it's essentially a 2-for-1 result.
12/24/2016 04:47:32
I think I updated all the votes, let me know if I missed anything. (was out all of yesterday and most of today)
12/24/2016 06:13:27
12/24/2016 06:13:27
Invisi you still havn't explained why you have a vote on me. Insert and Murkiri are very likely town but im afraid Murkiri will just use this as an excuse to never talk and add anything to the town. So it isn't exactly great news but i guess it's alright.
12/24/2016 06:26:33
12/24/2016 06:26:33
EIS-DUON
- Laggys still alive, what a game
Vote: Corvid
[/quote]
because aero aint playin it
12/24/2016 08:33:26
Hey guys, I'm interstate atm, staying at a holiday house without internet so my activity will be minimal (as if it wasn't minimal already lol).
I feel that with the current situation, lynching the SK would be less beneficial than lynching a mafia member. Yes, we need to take out the SK at some point, but if we dedicate Day 2 to hunting down MrL's killer, our Day 2 progress won't be that much farther than our Day 1 progress in terms of the mafia hunt.
I suggest reading over MrL's posts again and instead of finding out who wants him dead, we could further benefit from finding out as to who is he working with.
12/24/2016 09:10:59
I feel that with the current situation, lynching the SK would be less beneficial than lynching a mafia member. Yes, we need to take out the SK at some point, but if we dedicate Day 2 to hunting down MrL's killer, our Day 2 progress won't be that much farther than our Day 1 progress in terms of the mafia hunt.
I suggest reading over MrL's posts again and instead of finding out who wants him dead, we could further benefit from finding out as to who is he working with.
12/24/2016 09:10:59
I doubt theres very much interesting we can find from MrL's posts, I've already looked through them, he was just trying to go for easy lynches ending with lachlanF.
Obviously open to other people's analysis though.
In terms of targeting mafia or SK, lynching the SK would obviously be preferable as we go down to 1 town death each night (SK is most likely to hit townies while alive simply because there's more town than mafia).
Not that Corvid is 100% the SK, do we have any other leads though? (besides very vague accusations towards Duon, though I can't say I'm not suspicious of him either)
We'd need the potential roleblocker to claim and let us know who they roleblocked (if that's what prevented the mafia kill), any trackers/watchers probably can't give us much conclusive info because there's probably a bunch of townies with night roles.
12/24/2016 09:40:17
Obviously open to other people's analysis though.
In terms of targeting mafia or SK, lynching the SK would obviously be preferable as we go down to 1 town death each night (SK is most likely to hit townies while alive simply because there's more town than mafia).
Not that Corvid is 100% the SK, do we have any other leads though? (besides very vague accusations towards Duon, though I can't say I'm not suspicious of him either)
We'd need the potential roleblocker to claim and let us know who they roleblocked (if that's what prevented the mafia kill), any trackers/watchers probably can't give us much conclusive info because there's probably a bunch of townies with night roles.
12/24/2016 09:40:17
I know I don't have a formal vote on Duon but Imma do this anyway.
Vote: Unvote
I feel like Duon acting like he was/is is simply how he acts and I'm not too suspicious. He's said enough to keep him off my radar at least for now.
12/24/2016 10:08:22
Vote: Unvote
I feel like Duon acting like he was/is is simply how he acts and I'm not too suspicious. He's said enough to keep him off my radar at least for now.
12/24/2016 10:08:22
im also interstate (melbourne) so dont expect much from me also
12/24/2016 10:15:36
12/24/2016 10:15:36
I think I agree with Ghost's last point for the most part.
If anyone is 100% certain on information that they know because of their role, we could really use this. Information from the events of Night that would lead us to Mafia, SK or really help us with the structure of the game.
Only role claim if necessary though because we don't want easy Mafia targets.
I'm having trouble tryna feel out whether any of this is worth it because I'm not sure if Mafia killing off any important power roles is something we want. Like obviously we don't want it but I'm not sure whether it's worth it or whether there's a way to reduce the target on their head.
12/24/2016 10:20:44
If anyone is 100% certain on information that they know because of their role, we could really use this. Information from the events of Night that would lead us to Mafia, SK or really help us with the structure of the game.
Only role claim if necessary though because we don't want easy Mafia targets.
I'm having trouble tryna feel out whether any of this is worth it because I'm not sure if Mafia killing off any important power roles is something we want. Like obviously we don't want it but I'm not sure whether it's worth it or whether there's a way to reduce the target on their head.
12/24/2016 10:20:44