oh does that mean lynching also wont get us any information other than alignment?
01/29/2019 07:34:54
seems that way.
01/29/2019 07:53:37
01/29/2019 07:53:37
Duon's win condition was to be mod killed
01/29/2019 08:03:07
01/29/2019 08:03:07
Looking at Duon's character, Incineroar, the only neutral role that is jumping out at me is Arsonist. Thoughts?
01/29/2019 08:11:40
01/29/2019 08:11:40
Yeah definitely arsonist.
01/29/2019 08:17:52
01/29/2019 08:17:52
JonCheee said:
oh does that mean lynching also wont get us any information other than alignment?
This really limits the information we have to work with : /
Is there a role that searches dead bodies for info or something? I feel like that was a thing in a town of salem game I played in once.
Aerodrome said:
Yeah definitely arsonist.
If the game was balanced around two night killing roles and Duon was actually an arsonist then this game is going to take ages. I feel like the mods would have tried harder to replace an important role like this for game balance? Hey lookie what I found.
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Coroner
01/29/2019 08:39:20
if he really was a arson, then maybe a firefighter actually existed and this;
might actually be true.
01/29/2019 09:01:01
Blaze said:
So we have a 4 definite mafia, and 1 other possible killing roles, we have SK, Vig, Arso, and what else? (i assume those roles exist) I meant possible roles
might actually be true.
01/29/2019 09:01:01
well if thats the case, then maybe night might not prove as useful as once thought, expecially if theres a successful kill by mafia. getting info during the day is 10 billion times more important so having afk people sux.
unsure if the flavour text is supposed to give it away but arsonist would make sense. firefighter is now an "easy" role claim(?)
01/29/2019 09:11:31
unsure if the flavour text is supposed to give it away but arsonist would make sense. firefighter is now an "easy" role claim(?)
01/29/2019 09:11:31
Maybe we've gone full circle and there's an arsonist without a firefighter.
01/29/2019 09:17:28
01/29/2019 09:17:28
I looked up some roles on MafiaWiki before the game because I haven't played in a while and i remember that these games have a lot of random roles so i wanted to see if I should look out for any https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Hammerer Also obligatory "I was at the ranbat" and "I got an operation at the doctors today" *which is why im not at EBS*
01/29/2019 09:20:56
01/29/2019 09:20:56
JonCheee said:It's not an easy roleclaim unless there is no firefighter. I don't think there's any reason currently to believe there is no firefighter atm but idk things could change.
unsure if the flavour text is supposed to give it away but arsonist would make sense. firefighter is now an "easy" role claim(?)
01/29/2019 10:02:31
Windkeeper lowkey wanting ppl to think SK is dead so he can keep doing his thang :^)
01/29/2019 10:40:17
01/29/2019 10:40:17
Vote: Insie
01/29/2019 13:30:12
01/29/2019 13:30:12
Sorry I haven't said much. I've tried to analyse everything/everyone and DD was the scummiest to me until he didn't say anything in defence of himself. Now I have no idea what's going on tbh. It's very hard to analyse people when nobody even tries to defend themselves. Have not seen any real defence from any of the main lynch targets today.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I'll read through the last few pages since my big post and see if I can figure anything else out. I'm honestly frustrated at how long this day is dragging out
01/29/2019 14:00:56
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I'll read through the last few pages since my big post and see if I can figure anything else out. I'm honestly frustrated at how long this day is dragging out
01/29/2019 14:00:56
I think Duon flipping neutral doesn't really change anything about what we should be doing today. I agree it'll probably drag the game out, but that means we'll just have to kill the mafia quickly. =P
01/29/2019 21:50:38
01/29/2019 21:50:38
Yeah formerDuon's flip isn't important. He could have been an independent killer, a survivor or even a cultist trying to recruit Aero into his furry cult. In the end it's just a distraction from what we should actually be doing (lynching someone).
From yesterday's discussion, there isn't actually anyway to know there's four mafioso; both four and five are common in games of this size, as is having two mafia factions.
Anyway, I'm willing to be the bigger man and jump onto a different wagon if it means we get to the lynch, if I get a decent enough prod. My order of priority would probably be Insie (that's why I'm on it) > Blaze (I think Benjamin and Nicholas raised some valid points yesterday) > ThatLaggyPerson (don't really think he's mafia but I think we'd learn more from his flip than DD's) > DD (he's proving to be 100% useless to town discussion though)
I don't have anything extra to add to convince people to join the Insie train unless they thought his defence yesterday was lacklustre.
01/29/2019 23:00:52
From yesterday's discussion, there isn't actually anyway to know there's four mafioso; both four and five are common in games of this size, as is having two mafia factions.
Anyway, I'm willing to be the bigger man and jump onto a different wagon if it means we get to the lynch, if I get a decent enough prod. My order of priority would probably be Insie (that's why I'm on it) > Blaze (I think Benjamin and Nicholas raised some valid points yesterday) > ThatLaggyPerson (don't really think he's mafia but I think we'd learn more from his flip than DD's) > DD (he's proving to be 100% useless to town discussion though)
I don't have anything extra to add to convince people to join the Insie train unless they thought his defence yesterday was lacklustre.
01/29/2019 23:00:52
dean said:
Anyway, I'm willing to be the bigger man and jump onto a different wagon if it means we get to the lynch
Same, though my order is different to yours:
Laggy (for the reasons I already mentioned, plus since then he has been voting for the players with the highest number of votes on them with no explainations) > Insie (it's super suss that he brought up the hammerer role) > DD (I don't think he's anti town though saying he would make himself bait is a pretty suss thing to do) > Blaze (haven't seen enough to make me think he's anti town, don't think him saying about there maybe being 4 mafia is unusual)
01/29/2019 23:50:40
Also I'm back at work this week which means I'm constantly bored and checking the thread again. =D
Insie's at 7 votes now. Are we decided on that as a lynch? Also deadline is approaching this weekend so we should make our minds up soon.
01/30/2019 02:30:11
Insie's at 7 votes now. Are we decided on that as a lynch? Also deadline is approaching this weekend so we should make our minds up soon.
01/30/2019 02:30:11
Just lynch insie lmao
01/30/2019 02:44:05
01/30/2019 02:44:05
Okay, this day's gone long enough.
Vote: Insie
01/30/2019 02:45:25
Vote: Insie
01/30/2019 02:45:25
Hey Insie you want to do is a favour and reveal your role before you get lynched? Don't pull a MrL from last game if you have something useful for town. Vote: unvote
Don't want any knuckleheads speed lynching you until you get to tell us if you have a role / what the role is.
01/30/2019 03:27:35
Don't want any knuckleheads speed lynching you until you get to tell us if you have a role / what the role is.
01/30/2019 03:27:35
i'll hold off on voting for insie for the time being so bijou doesnt yell at me but i'm happy to contribute
01/30/2019 04:04:39
01/30/2019 04:04:39
Extra said:
i'll hold off on voting for insie for the time being so bijou doesnt yell at me but i'm happy to contribute
I'd never yell at you : (
01/30/2019 05:05:43
@dean any reason why im second on your priority list? Also why has insie voted for themselves?
01/30/2019 05:25:56
01/30/2019 05:25:56
Blaze said:
Also why has insie voted for themselves?
Looks like the mods wrote Insie instead of Exist by mistake
01/30/2019 05:37:21