The vote count on LuminousLucas should be at 6 since Dean and I have voted for him as well.
I think for tomorrow if we don't have another confirmed anti town member, keeping Dean around might be too risky in case he is bluffing or we mislynch too many people. I still stand by what I said earlier due to the situation that Insert has given us but we will need to get rid of him eventually anyway.
8 years ago
Murkiri said something like half a week a go saying he cant play for like a whole week. It was one of my reasons for wanting this day to go longer so we could wait for a 100% town to get back, despite how weak that player is...
8 years ago
8 years ago
Idk what to really think at the point to be honest, this entire day has just been fucked
VOTE: LuminousLucas
8 years ago
VOTE: LuminousLucas
8 years ago
if corvid actually had read the thread he woulda seen he is being kicked out of this game and is getting replaced. Shows how much he actually plays.
8 years ago
8 years ago
lmao corvid are you even a real person to add: i agree that lynching dean tomorrow is probably fine unless he puts in serious work. even then i think it's risky to let him run around with a killing ability, especially if we don't have any guaranteed targets.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Real thing is that I'm not a real person anymore, I've always been a lizardfucking bird
8 years ago
8 years ago
Kinda funny how a confirmed scum is less of a lynch priority than a lot of the townies here lol. Nonetheless, choo choo.
Vote:LuminousLucas
8 years ago
Vote:LuminousLucas
8 years ago
Sorry Corvid, you've been given ample chances and are being replaced.
8 years ago
8 years ago
My problem with having a lynch train on anyone else but dean right now is that we wouldn't realistically be doing this if it was any one BUT dean. Not lynching dean is putting an enormous amount of trust in someone who isn't town aligned. Sure, dean has been a great source of discussion for town and he will immediately be killed if he breaks our trust. But what does it matter if he does? Sure he can have fun trying to work out the maf/townsfolk and what not but he can also potentially cause mass chaos. I also feel that he is trying to buy himself time to do something. I'm not gonna be voting anyone else today.
I am glad that discussion has at least somewhat happened though and for once people are actually being decently pressured. Weird circumstances though that this is happening when we have a literal actual confirmed anti-town role but whatever. Discussion is discussion and I hope it continues.
my version of the #dean13, the #Maribro12
LuminousLucas
cjeccjec
ThatLaggyPerson (I don't think all of Lucas, cjeccjec and laggy are scum but I have a feeling one of them is)
Windkeeper0 (something about his play reminds me of when he was maf. Having said that, he definitely plays almost the same between games which makes it hard)
Corvid (God knows and now he's getting replaced so that'll make it even harder :) )
Ghostbone (I agree wit a lot of what he says but I'm lowkey scared he's just playing us all like he did last game)
KiwifruitKoala (??????????? no idea, you have added very little all game)
Spacejam (has certainly died off my scum radar but his play is definitely weird at times)
JLo
extra
HydroPimp
EIS-DUON (No confirmation of his role being what he says but such a ballsy play on day 2 is unlikely from maf)
8 years ago
I am glad that discussion has at least somewhat happened though and for once people are actually being decently pressured. Weird circumstances though that this is happening when we have a literal actual confirmed anti-town role but whatever. Discussion is discussion and I hope it continues.
my version of the #dean13, the #Maribro12
LuminousLucas
cjeccjec
ThatLaggyPerson (I don't think all of Lucas, cjeccjec and laggy are scum but I have a feeling one of them is)
Windkeeper0 (something about his play reminds me of when he was maf. Having said that, he definitely plays almost the same between games which makes it hard)
Corvid (God knows and now he's getting replaced so that'll make it even harder :) )
Ghostbone (I agree wit a lot of what he says but I'm lowkey scared he's just playing us all like he did last game)
KiwifruitKoala (??????????? no idea, you have added very little all game)
Spacejam (has certainly died off my scum radar but his play is definitely weird at times)
JLo
extra
HydroPimp
EIS-DUON (No confirmation of his role being what he says but such a ballsy play on day 2 is unlikely from maf)
8 years ago
My main issue with not postponing Dean's lynch is that if we don't obtain info on scum tonight, we're stuck in yet another day phase with a worrying issue: not enough people contributing to the discussion. Unless we agree on something like a mass roleclaim next day, I feel that we won't be able to make a lot of progress with the town's current situation. Pressuring someone else today lets us have Dean lined up as a lynch next day, a time where information may be the scarcest due to the absence of night kills. In my opinion, nailing a scum tonight and deciding whether to lynch the scum or Dean is a luxury problem.
8 years ago
8 years ago
That doesn't make any sense.
We can pressure anyone tomorrow that we would have pressured today.
If you think that if we lynch Dean today, we won't have anything to go off of in terms of lynching someone tomorrow, then what evidence do you think we have to lynch someone else today?
8 years ago
We can pressure anyone tomorrow that we would have pressured today.
If you think that if we lynch Dean today, we won't have anything to go off of in terms of lynching someone tomorrow, then what evidence do you think we have to lynch someone else today?
8 years ago
Can moderators double-check the votecount I'm pretty sure I voted for Lucas at some point
8 years ago
8 years ago
You sure did, missed it sorry.
8 years ago
8 years ago
Oh and Windkeeper0 voted as well
8 years ago
8 years ago
Bloody hell... So now people don't mind dean staying. -.-
I change my mind a lot, mostly because I want to follow the mob. I do this because I don't want to be marked as "Mafia, or just a really shit player." But from now on ill be a stubborn bitch.
So if dean stays it's purely for his discussion, Mafia reads, all that good stuff he does, you get the idea. I don't feel like having no night kills in the coming night should change how we play this day too much. That is lynch dean or someone else.
Like it has been said, anything we do today, we could also do tomorrow. I think laggy is an easier target at the moment, moreso than luminouslucas. But since you've all gone done the luminous road I guess we can leave laggy for later.
I say lynch dean today Vote: Dean
I have a few post histories I want to check. I'm suspicious of a few people whose posts just aren't adding up. But I must rest because I am very tired. Hopefully I remember sometime in the morning . Also what's with the deadline?
8 years ago
I change my mind a lot, mostly because I want to follow the mob. I do this because I don't want to be marked as "Mafia, or just a really shit player." But from now on ill be a stubborn bitch.
So if dean stays it's purely for his discussion, Mafia reads, all that good stuff he does, you get the idea. I don't feel like having no night kills in the coming night should change how we play this day too much. That is lynch dean or someone else.
Like it has been said, anything we do today, we could also do tomorrow. I think laggy is an easier target at the moment, moreso than luminouslucas. But since you've all gone done the luminous road I guess we can leave laggy for later.
I say lynch dean today Vote: Dean
I have a few post histories I want to check. I'm suspicious of a few people whose posts just aren't adding up. But I must rest because I am very tired. Hopefully I remember sometime in the morning . Also what's with the deadline?
8 years ago
Yeah that's about enough of that. Lucas has enough votes on him to respond with something.
Vote: Dean
Let's not get carried away, if you guys aren't lynching Dean today then I'm super suss lol. We have a confirmed anti town here. Will post after work too but my scum list is a lot different to the general consensus.
8 years ago
Vote: Dean
Let's not get carried away, if you guys aren't lynching Dean today then I'm super suss lol. We have a confirmed anti town here. Will post after work too but my scum list is a lot different to the general consensus.
8 years ago
Sorry for not posting, I've read through the thread though.
I've been parroting and contradicting myself so bad lately, and I'd like to say that my thoughts do change, I'll make sure to read my previous posts to make sure this doesn't happen again. I've said similar things in one of my posts.
I think dean is not telling us something, I know they wouldn't straight out explain give up like that which makes me suspicious of what they might know. What they know I cannot possibly think of.
Keeping dean alive is like keeping a bomb around, you never know when it will explode on you. So I'd like to finish today with dean being lynched.
8 years ago
I've been parroting and contradicting myself so bad lately, and I'd like to say that my thoughts do change, I'll make sure to read my previous posts to make sure this doesn't happen again. I've said similar things in one of my posts.
I think dean is not telling us something, I know they wouldn't straight out explain give up like that which makes me suspicious of what they might know. What they know I cannot possibly think of.
Keeping dean alive is like keeping a bomb around, you never know when it will explode on you. So I'd like to finish today with dean being lynched.
8 years ago
Dean is trustworthy. He's a really intelligent player and an intelligent player wouldnt want to waste their time bickering, pretending to lie about your role and make up some story when you have been exposed by an investigation role. The fact dean didnt kill nights 1 and 2 should make you want to trust him. Maybe it's like having a bomb around but what if that bomb had like a pink bow tie and was really cute, ye know?
It's pretty interesting how cjeccjec and LuminousLucas have had the same opinion about pretty much everything. Lucas didn't actually give a defense at all, He didnt even actually acknowledge that he had 7 votes on him. He pretty much just is acting like nothing ever happened. All his post was was him pretty much giving his poor reasons for when he votes dean later on in the game, he will say something along the lines of "VoteDean for reasons i have stated up previously" which is pretty much a tactic hoping nobody will make a big deal that you voted. Cjeccjec voting 2 posts before supports this. He obviously wasn't going to vote for the same target within 2 votes this is why they are setting up to lynch dean.
It makes sense mafia would want to get rid of dean, more so than town. Both factions need to get rid of dean to win the game but dean is very obviously on the side of town this game more so than mafia. Before and technically after he was very protown and stimulated discussion. Much more so than our own town like Murkiri and Duon. So when mafia sees the town voting for somebody that they probably need to kill early to win and is also a very protown player of course they are going to be all about that.
8 years ago
It's pretty interesting how cjeccjec and LuminousLucas have had the same opinion about pretty much everything. Lucas didn't actually give a defense at all, He didnt even actually acknowledge that he had 7 votes on him. He pretty much just is acting like nothing ever happened. All his post was was him pretty much giving his poor reasons for when he votes dean later on in the game, he will say something along the lines of "VoteDean for reasons i have stated up previously" which is pretty much a tactic hoping nobody will make a big deal that you voted. Cjeccjec voting 2 posts before supports this. He obviously wasn't going to vote for the same target within 2 votes this is why they are setting up to lynch dean.
It makes sense mafia would want to get rid of dean, more so than town. Both factions need to get rid of dean to win the game but dean is very obviously on the side of town this game more so than mafia. Before and technically after he was very protown and stimulated discussion. Much more so than our own town like Murkiri and Duon. So when mafia sees the town voting for somebody that they probably need to kill early to win and is also a very protown player of course they are going to be all about that.
8 years ago
There's literally no evidence to even prove Dean is SK since he had performed no night kills. We have to lynch all anti town players to win lol. Dean may have good intentions to help town but if he kills at night and is wrong we're still losing 2 players per night.
Here is my suss list in order of most to least. Feel free to ask for more detail if you disagree with a placing.
Hydro
Spacejam
Jlo
Autumnfruitsalad
Windkeeper
Maribro
Extra
Corvid
Lucas
Cjeccjeccjeccjeccjec
Ghost
Laggy
Duon
Excluded all the role mostly confirmed people which are Lumi, Murkiri, Dean and Invisi.
8 years ago
Here is my suss list in order of most to least. Feel free to ask for more detail if you disagree with a placing.
Hydro
Spacejam
Jlo
Autumnfruitsalad
Windkeeper
Maribro
Extra
Corvid
Lucas
Cjeccjeccjeccjeccjec
Ghost
Laggy
Duon
Excluded all the role mostly confirmed people which are Lumi, Murkiri, Dean and Invisi.
8 years ago
"dean is trustworthy"
Anti-town is never trustworthy lmao. If Dean doesn't get lynched today then you're all far too easy to manipulate. Just because someone acts like they have your best interests in mind, doesn't mean they do.
I can already tell tomorrow he's going to start talking about "Oh well it won't hurt to leave me alive for another night since I haven't killed anyone yet," and for some reason people will continue to fall for that.
We know a firefighter role exists, and this firefighter role was claimed after SK was claimed, but it was just brushed off like it's Aero trolling again. I mean this is a pretty big inconsistency that makes me even more inclined to just vote of Dean rather than taking dumb risks.
Also Hydro's starting to improve the formatting of his posts lol.
Also with Lucas, he's playing pretty bad but he could also be the victim of a mafia lynch train from Hydro/Jlo/Windkeeper. Voting Dean off will allow us to actually assess this situation better (if Dean comes up SK then I support the lucas vote tomorrow).
8 years ago
Anti-town is never trustworthy lmao. If Dean doesn't get lynched today then you're all far too easy to manipulate. Just because someone acts like they have your best interests in mind, doesn't mean they do.
I can already tell tomorrow he's going to start talking about "Oh well it won't hurt to leave me alive for another night since I haven't killed anyone yet," and for some reason people will continue to fall for that.
We know a firefighter role exists, and this firefighter role was claimed after SK was claimed, but it was just brushed off like it's Aero trolling again. I mean this is a pretty big inconsistency that makes me even more inclined to just vote of Dean rather than taking dumb risks.
Also Hydro's starting to improve the formatting of his posts lol.
Also with Lucas, he's playing pretty bad but he could also be the victim of a mafia lynch train from Hydro/Jlo/Windkeeper. Voting Dean off will allow us to actually assess this situation better (if Dean comes up SK then I support the lucas vote tomorrow).
8 years ago
I don't know why you trust dean so much? Not killing days 1 and 2 isn't an excuse to trust him? It's him telling us how he was planning on playing.
I'm with Bijou on this one though, I don't like the idea of keeping an anti town around.
Is this LuminousLucas' first game? I have a feeling they're just bad rather than trying to lie or whatever lol.
8 years ago
I'm with Bijou on this one though, I don't like the idea of keeping an anti town around.
Is this LuminousLucas' first game? I have a feeling they're just bad rather than trying to lie or whatever lol.
8 years ago
Murkiri has received his 2nd and last activity strike. (Hasn't posted for 4 days) Therefore he will be replaced.
Duon also is wishing to be replaced as he can't commit enough time to the game as he would like.
So if anyone has any ideas of who to replace them with that would be great. :)
8 years ago
Duon also is wishing to be replaced as he can't commit enough time to the game as he would like.
So if anyone has any ideas of who to replace them with that would be great. :)
8 years ago
okay sure maybe im dumb for trusting dean but how does trusting dean makes me suss doesnt it just make me retarded???? he is third party so like yea can i make an alt account and be murkiri so i get a 2nd vote
8 years ago
8 years ago
Why would voting Dean make me mafia. He's anti town, I would like to think that mafia would actually want him to be around for longer.
I don't like using "Dean is a good player" and "Dean is smart he knows what he is doing" as an excuse.
Also I don't think luminous has been parroting me, I haven't checked and to be honest I can't be fucked. If you haven't noticed my opinion is also shared with other people so I doubt luminous and I have been so aligned. Especially without lots of other people being in the mix, which you failed to point out.
Lucas is playing very worried. Something I can see happening from both a Mafia and a town. I have no idea about him.
8 years ago
I don't like using "Dean is a good player" and "Dean is smart he knows what he is doing" as an excuse.
Also I don't think luminous has been parroting me, I haven't checked and to be honest I can't be fucked. If you haven't noticed my opinion is also shared with other people so I doubt luminous and I have been so aligned. Especially without lots of other people being in the mix, which you failed to point out.
Lucas is playing very worried. Something I can see happening from both a Mafia and a town. I have no idea about him.
8 years ago
update: Since it took me awhile to reread everything I didnt realize there were several posts after hydros.
Bijou does make a good point about we don't even know if he is SK but why should it matter? I'm actually surprised by a few placings on your suss list. I might reread over a few peoples post and post my thoughts on them later (after work)
Ghost, I had a great plan to start copy pasting Hydros posts and formatting them correctly. I guess I can't do that anymore but at least I can read them now.
8 years ago
Bijou does make a good point about we don't even know if he is SK but why should it matter? I'm actually surprised by a few placings on your suss list. I might reread over a few peoples post and post my thoughts on them later (after work)
Ghost, I had a great plan to start copy pasting Hydros posts and formatting them correctly. I guess I can't do that anymore but at least I can read them now.
8 years ago