To put it simply, I think that we don't NEED loads of time today because I don't think we're getting anywhere. Jeez, where's the edit button when you need it?
12/16/2016 04:42:31
Honestly, there is nothing else I can say that hasn't already been said, if y'all want to Lynch me to start the First Night, I wouldn't recommend it but I think someone needs to be lynched.
I just have me a hunch that you will not be too happy when I die, but at the same time you will be very happy that I am dead.
The only thing we have to judge people on today is their voting patterns, so I think I will apply some pressure to someone who hasn't been super active, but like there isn't much I can say or do to convince you not to lynch me. As we have next to no information to go off.
Ive been busy this week doing TO stuff, and tomorrow I will be TO
Vote: Lynch
12/16/2016 06:48:07
I just have me a hunch that you will not be too happy when I die, but at the same time you will be very happy that I am dead.
The only thing we have to judge people on today is their voting patterns, so I think I will apply some pressure to someone who hasn't been super active, but like there isn't much I can say or do to convince you not to lynch me. As we have next to no information to go off.
Ive been busy this week doing TO stuff, and tomorrow I will be TO
Vote: Lynch
12/16/2016 06:48:07
You don't have to vote to do a lynch, just vote for a player. Baka.
12/16/2016 07:11:02
12/16/2016 07:11:02
Wtf is Vote: Lynch.
I don't think I'm going to consider that an option.
12/16/2016 07:13:23
I don't think I'm going to consider that an option.
12/16/2016 07:13:23
Revolutionary.
VOTE: Lynch
12/16/2016 07:14:06
VOTE: Lynch
12/16/2016 07:14:06
Stop.
12/16/2016 07:14:32
12/16/2016 07:14:32
What's actually sus about Lachlan?
At this stage it seems like he will be our day 1 lynch as mafia join in if they haven't already and other undecided townies join in.
Just wondering why I should vote him rather than Corvid who I'm more sus of.
12/16/2016 07:14:46
At this stage it seems like he will be our day 1 lynch as mafia join in if they haven't already and other undecided townies join in.
Just wondering why I should vote him rather than Corvid who I'm more sus of.
12/16/2016 07:14:46
Look, Lachlan is confusing even the game moderators.
12/16/2016 07:15:17
12/16/2016 07:15:17
I mean it probably means, voting for whoever has most votes which is himself, but like legit just pick a dude.
12/16/2016 07:17:01
12/16/2016 07:17:01
Vote: Lynch over No lynch.
12/16/2016 07:31:38
12/16/2016 07:31:38
MrL said:
Also regarding Dean and Bijou saying Spacejam is playing differently, could you please elaborate? It could be that you guys know him more and stuff, but other than him being arguably less active than last game I would've thought he's playing pretty similarly
I'll have to go back and really compare how he's playing now vs. how he has played in the past to give you a really solid answer, my instincts are just telling me something is off about his play so far is all. Will post later about it after I finish work, but yeah something just feels different and I'm not sure how to substantiate it right at the minute. Maybe Dean can give you a better reply in the mean time.
12/16/2016 07:34:09
Anyway it looks like we're starting to move somewhere.
"Autumnwind (1) - LachlanF"
I don't feel AutumnWind is truly on the radar right now.
"Spacejam (3) - Dean, Maribro, Bijou"
Honestly if every post is going to be written off with "I'm on painkillers so of course I'll be weird" I'm not sure we'll get anywhere, I'm not sure how valid this is I haven't taken any painkillers BUT apparently I was really weird after I took a general anesthetic for wisdom teeth removal so w/e
But it's very possible that he is on painkillers and also scum so shouldn't be completely overlooked down the track
"LachlanF (5) - Cjeccjec, Extra, JLo, Insertname, Windkeeper"
Honestly seems as good a bet as any at this stage. What the hell does "I just have me a hunch that you will not be too happy when I die, but at the same time you will be very happy that I am dead" mean? I don't think it's possible to be any more vague but you're really bad at defending yourself in general so w/e
BUT in general I would chase up people who mostly say "sorry I've been busy/sorry I will be busy", reminds me a lot of Windkeeper0 last game.
"Murkiri (1) - ThatLaggyPerson"
I'm also well on board with this. Murkiri you need to start properly contributing or you will be seen as scum along the line.
"Luminescent (3) - Spacejam, LuminousLucas, Autumnwind"
Had a thought about this, Luminescent has contributed nothing apart from campaigning for a No Lynch.
Also added something vague like "I'm forming my suspicions".
Vague/fluff statements like this are very scummy, Lumi if you have ANYTHING at all to say I urge you post it as there is no guarantee you will make it through to the next day. <- applies to all of us
"No Lynch (3) - Invisi, Murkiri, Duon"
I disagree with this but I won't push the point further.
Anyway, stole a post from a thread on mafia theory on another forum about how to play Day 1:
"You have to start making votes (work on non-posters because the mafia won't screw up if they never post... so you, as town, have to make not posting an error). Anything you can do to make discussion is good.
You analyze the reactions to those posts and use that information to find who you are looking for (mafia are looking for docs/cops/etc and the town are looking for mafia, obviously)"
It seems we're starting to get somewhere now but something to keep in mind for future games.
12/16/2016 07:35:16
"Autumnwind (1) - LachlanF"
I don't feel AutumnWind is truly on the radar right now.
"Spacejam (3) - Dean, Maribro, Bijou"
Honestly if every post is going to be written off with "I'm on painkillers so of course I'll be weird" I'm not sure we'll get anywhere, I'm not sure how valid this is I haven't taken any painkillers BUT apparently I was really weird after I took a general anesthetic for wisdom teeth removal so w/e
But it's very possible that he is on painkillers and also scum so shouldn't be completely overlooked down the track
"LachlanF (5) - Cjeccjec, Extra, JLo, Insertname, Windkeeper"
Honestly seems as good a bet as any at this stage. What the hell does "I just have me a hunch that you will not be too happy when I die, but at the same time you will be very happy that I am dead" mean? I don't think it's possible to be any more vague but you're really bad at defending yourself in general so w/e
BUT in general I would chase up people who mostly say "sorry I've been busy/sorry I will be busy", reminds me a lot of Windkeeper0 last game.
"Murkiri (1) - ThatLaggyPerson"
I'm also well on board with this. Murkiri you need to start properly contributing or you will be seen as scum along the line.
"Luminescent (3) - Spacejam, LuminousLucas, Autumnwind"
Had a thought about this, Luminescent has contributed nothing apart from campaigning for a No Lynch.
Also added something vague like "I'm forming my suspicions".
Vague/fluff statements like this are very scummy, Lumi if you have ANYTHING at all to say I urge you post it as there is no guarantee you will make it through to the next day. <- applies to all of us
"No Lynch (3) - Invisi, Murkiri, Duon"
I disagree with this but I won't push the point further.
Anyway, stole a post from a thread on mafia theory on another forum about how to play Day 1:
"You have to start making votes (work on non-posters because the mafia won't screw up if they never post... so you, as town, have to make not posting an error). Anything you can do to make discussion is good.
You analyze the reactions to those posts and use that information to find who you are looking for (mafia are looking for docs/cops/etc and the town are looking for mafia, obviously)"
It seems we're starting to get somewhere now but something to keep in mind for future games.
12/16/2016 07:35:16
It seems people are on my case so i will explain.
I'm new to this version of mafia where a day 1 lynch is a common thing (so I've been reading in the chats).
I play Town of Salem (which I am learning has quite a few differences to this game). In Town of Salem, lynching just 1 Town member is enough to lose the game, so I came into this game with that in mind.
I think Bijou said "don't follow the crowd and vote" or something along those lines and so I kept to my initial thoughts of no lynch day 1 (which is a Town of Salem mentality).
What else can I say? It's day 1, I'm inexperienced, and there is, in my opinion, not much information for me to go off, so I can't really contribute that much in general.
In regards to my comment "forming my suspicions", that's nothing more than me reading a sentence and thinking "I don't like the way it's formatted. They're probably scummy." I personally don't feel it is enough to cast a vote on them. And now I've learned that it outs me as suspicious. So I do now feel I should cast a vote.
Vote: Spacejam
I didn't like his "You're trying to sound very town" statement and he also is the first person to vote me up if that means anything.
But yeah, Even if this following statement outs me as suspicious.
I probably won't be able to contribute everyday as I am studying and working over the Christmas holidays so, I'm sorry in advance.
12/16/2016 09:31:41
I'm new to this version of mafia where a day 1 lynch is a common thing (so I've been reading in the chats).
I play Town of Salem (which I am learning has quite a few differences to this game). In Town of Salem, lynching just 1 Town member is enough to lose the game, so I came into this game with that in mind.
I think Bijou said "don't follow the crowd and vote" or something along those lines and so I kept to my initial thoughts of no lynch day 1 (which is a Town of Salem mentality).
What else can I say? It's day 1, I'm inexperienced, and there is, in my opinion, not much information for me to go off, so I can't really contribute that much in general.
In regards to my comment "forming my suspicions", that's nothing more than me reading a sentence and thinking "I don't like the way it's formatted. They're probably scummy." I personally don't feel it is enough to cast a vote on them. And now I've learned that it outs me as suspicious. So I do now feel I should cast a vote.
Vote: Spacejam
I didn't like his "You're trying to sound very town" statement and he also is the first person to vote me up if that means anything.
But yeah, Even if this following statement outs me as suspicious.
I probably won't be able to contribute everyday as I am studying and working over the Christmas holidays so, I'm sorry in advance.
12/16/2016 09:31:41
Its time to Balance? the scales. Vote:SpaceJam Sorry Dale.
12/16/2016 09:49:44
12/16/2016 09:49:44
Voting for spacejam just because you might get lynched instead, when spacejam hasn't even voted for you?
Vote: LachlanF
Trying to save yourself by diverting attention to someone else is pretty scummy.
12/16/2016 10:11:00
Vote: LachlanF
Trying to save yourself by diverting attention to someone else is pretty scummy.
12/16/2016 10:11:00
VOTE: LachlanF
voting space for no real reason?
12/16/2016 10:28:33
voting space for no real reason?
12/16/2016 10:28:33
Hey guys, I haven't really checked this in the last few hours but I'm here now...
I'll try responding to the points brought up about me.
Thank you for understanding at least.
My first vote was mainly to get you to join in the discussion. Prior to me voting for you, you had literally told the town none of your thoughts apart from "No Lynch". Any discussion is good discussion in my mind and I'm glad you at least posted something.
As for my "acting very town" statement, I do agree with that being worded extremely suspiciously. Looking back I can see why it raised eyebrows. I would like to blame the painkillers but it was probably due to my horrible English skills.
Regardless, I'm happy at the moment with this response.
Lol. I'll be the bigger man here and actually defend you (something you seem to be clueless about). I actually think Lachlan is town. Although he is extremely weak as a player, he appears to be playing how he does in towns in which he is game, including extremely bad defences. I do admit I can't remember how he played as Mafia but if someone could link a forum in which he was one it could help us greatly.
Since there is still several people who I think are suss, I would like to get them talking as well. Vote: Murkiri
Anyways, I'm here to answer any questions. I'm cool with anything.
12/16/2016 10:53:12
I'll try responding to the points brought up about me.
dean said:
"Spacejam (3) - Dean, Maribro, Bijou"
Honestly if every post is going to be written off with "I'm on painkillers so of course I'll be weird" I'm not sure we'll get anywhere, I'm not sure how valid this is I haven't taken any painkillers BUT apparently I was really weird after I took a general anesthetic for wisdom teeth removal so w/e
But it's very possible that he is on painkillers and also scum so shouldn't be completely overlooked down the track
Thank you for understanding at least.
Luminescent said:
In regards to my comment "forming my suspicions", that's nothing more than me reading a sentence and thinking "I don't like the way it's formatted. They're probably scummy." I personally don't feel it is enough to cast a vote on them. And now I've learned that it outs me as suspicious. So I do now feel I should cast a vote.
Vote: Spacejam
I didn't like his "You're trying to sound very town" statement and he also is the first person to vote me up if that means anything.
My first vote was mainly to get you to join in the discussion. Prior to me voting for you, you had literally told the town none of your thoughts apart from "No Lynch". Any discussion is good discussion in my mind and I'm glad you at least posted something.
As for my "acting very town" statement, I do agree with that being worded extremely suspiciously. Looking back I can see why it raised eyebrows. I would like to blame the painkillers but it was probably due to my horrible English skills.
Regardless, I'm happy at the moment with this response.
LachlanF said:
Its time to Balance? the scales. Vote:SpaceJam Sorry Dale.
Lol. I'll be the bigger man here and actually defend you (something you seem to be clueless about). I actually think Lachlan is town. Although he is extremely weak as a player, he appears to be playing how he does in towns in which he is game, including extremely bad defences. I do admit I can't remember how he played as Mafia but if someone could link a forum in which he was one it could help us greatly.
Since there is still several people who I think are suss, I would like to get them talking as well. Vote: Murkiri
Anyways, I'm here to answer any questions. I'm cool with anything.
12/16/2016 10:53:12
Balancing the scales just to make it so we'd both be at 5 votes lol. But I see the merit in a day 1 lynch and if the town feels it should be me. There isn't much I could say that could stop it. It would be a shame to see me Burn Up before getting a chance to shine. It might make me loose alot the Fire within.
12/16/2016 11:02:26
12/16/2016 11:02:26
Lachlan probably has some dumb power role that does something weird and I think reading his behaviour (although I have only read this game and the last one) is futile. Lachlan just acts to different and erratic as well as making decisions which probably won't help the side he is supposed to be playing for.
I'm leaning more towards lynching (or just me voting) Murkiri because hopefully i'll get an actual defence and I can only keep thinking that he's another Basty. Plus we gotta get that activity in. There's probably a few more fairly inactive players, but Murkiri is the one that has come to my attention the most.
Also Lachlan you should try defending yourself differently instead of clueing at things. I guess don't be too drastic unless it's absolutely necessary. Maybe imagine you're actually gonna get lynched irl and pour your heart out.
12/16/2016 11:56:19
I'm leaning more towards lynching (or just me voting) Murkiri because hopefully i'll get an actual defence and I can only keep thinking that he's another Basty. Plus we gotta get that activity in. There's probably a few more fairly inactive players, but Murkiri is the one that has come to my attention the most.
Also Lachlan you should try defending yourself differently instead of clueing at things. I guess don't be too drastic unless it's absolutely necessary. Maybe imagine you're actually gonna get lynched irl and pour your heart out.
12/16/2016 11:56:19
Someone plz lynch me IRL that would be great.
12/16/2016 12:02:57
12/16/2016 12:02:57
To sum up what Murkiri has posted
- Murkiri let us know he existed
- Murkiri jumped on the meme dean train (he voted dean)
- Murkiri unvoted because him hopping on the train was obviously a joke
- Murkiri voted for a no lynch saying he doesn't see the point in lynching anyone and voiced his suspicions for Corvid (with no explanation .-.)
hey thats my type of suicidal joke .-. First of all Murkiri hasn't said much at all, let alone anything useful with substance. He also seems to be jumping on bandwagons with little to no reasoning. Seems like he's trying to blend in while supporting decisions that will help mafia. (Depends on how you look at it I guess)
My advice is, give lots of information as to why you're doing things, (voting suspicions etc). Reasoning, if you will. Posting more would also be good obviously. I'm going to rule out inexperience as a factor here because personally, I don't think it's enough of a facto,r unless he proves to be a "weak" player regardless. (Which I don't believe will be the case, only time will tell)
12/16/2016 12:10:50
- Murkiri let us know he existed
- Murkiri jumped on the meme dean train (he voted dean)
- Murkiri unvoted because him hopping on the train was obviously a joke
- Murkiri voted for a no lynch saying he doesn't see the point in lynching anyone and voiced his suspicions for Corvid (with no explanation .-.)
LachlanF said:
Someone plz lynch me IRL that would be great.
hey thats my type of suicidal joke .-. First of all Murkiri hasn't said much at all, let alone anything useful with substance. He also seems to be jumping on bandwagons with little to no reasoning. Seems like he's trying to blend in while supporting decisions that will help mafia. (Depends on how you look at it I guess)
My advice is, give lots of information as to why you're doing things, (voting suspicions etc). Reasoning, if you will. Posting more would also be good obviously. I'm going to rule out inexperience as a factor here because personally, I don't think it's enough of a facto,r unless he proves to be a "weak" player regardless. (Which I don't believe will be the case, only time will tell)
12/16/2016 12:10:50
It may be too soon to say, but I also think Lachlan is town. He has made some very poor defenses, but I feel his comment"you will not be too happy when I die, but at the same time you will be very happy that I am dead." I read this as town believe it or not. The "You will be very happy that I am dead" sounds to me like just a comment based on the weakness he's been labelled as. Based off of cjeccjec's comments on Murkiri and also from what I've seen from him I'll vote him up to get him talking, I'd like to hear him explain himself some more with his drastic vote changes.
Vote: Murkiri
12/16/2016 12:10:52
Vote: Murkiri
12/16/2016 12:10:52
Now to explain why I think Lachlan is town...
I know I said reading him based off previous patterns is unreliable, but I realise now it's probably not as bad as I think. Plus it's the only solid lead I can think of. I believe Lachlan delights in the "I told you so" aspect of the game. When pressured by a lynch he seems to defend himself in that way. He goes with the "you'll be sorry" and once he turns out town boom "I told you so". Then he leaves his wierd clues and stuff behind. So i'll go back and see if there's anything of him being mafia but so far I'm sticking with this.
Vote: Unvote
Vote: Murkiri
And also on second thought there are other suspicions to look at as well, I just feel like bringing this one up because I feel it will get the most useful discussion going.
12/16/2016 12:17:56
I know I said reading him based off previous patterns is unreliable, but I realise now it's probably not as bad as I think. Plus it's the only solid lead I can think of. I believe Lachlan delights in the "I told you so" aspect of the game. When pressured by a lynch he seems to defend himself in that way. He goes with the "you'll be sorry" and once he turns out town boom "I told you so". Then he leaves his wierd clues and stuff behind. So i'll go back and see if there's anything of him being mafia but so far I'm sticking with this.
Vote: Unvote
Vote: Murkiri
And also on second thought there are other suspicions to look at as well, I just feel like bringing this one up because I feel it will get the most useful discussion going.
12/16/2016 12:17:56
I'll have a good post up soon, but in the meantime cjeccjec Lachlan was scum in Smashbox (3rd game) and in Qldsmash users.
12/16/2016 12:21:21
12/16/2016 12:21:21
VOTE: Murkiri
after reading spaces post, he could be right. but if lachlan turns out maf, hes in serious trouble
12/16/2016 12:27:33
after reading spaces post, he could be right. but if lachlan turns out maf, hes in serious trouble
12/16/2016 12:27:33